{
 "name": "Bout Book",
 "edition": "2026-11-08",
 "read_date": "2026-11-08",
 "source": "https://hriscomparison.com/datasets/",
 "license": "CC BY 4.0",
 "cite": "HRIS Comparison, Bout Book and Demo Script, edition 8 Nov 2026, https://hriscomparison.com/datasets/, read 8 Nov 2026. CC BY 4.0.",
 "description": "91 bouts among 14 platforms on six criteria with the weights 30, 25, 15, 10, 10, 10: per-side scores and reasons, weighted totals, winner, margin and five situation verdicts.",
 "rows": [
  {
   "bout": "Shapes vs Rippling",
   "a": "Shapes",
   "b": "Rippling",
   "total_a": "8.6",
   "total_b": "6.7",
   "winner": "Shapes",
   "margin": "1.9",
   "build_a": 9,
   "build_b": 8,
   "build_reason_a": "Dashboards, tools and workflows described in plain language on live permission-aware data, a community hub of named built views, and documented Workflows agent, any-field and date triggers, conditional tasks and task views, with only a template gallery missing.",
   "build_reason_b": "Reports and dashboards from a prompt that are editable and shareable, automations described in plain language with schedule, data and webhook triggers, branching, templates, App Studio and an inbox, with the builder claim largely vendor-stated and a library not clearly documented.",
   "agents_a": 9,
   "agents_b": 7,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents handle onboarding and the comp cycle, nothing goes live until approved, an audit log, separate AI off switches and field-level permissions are documented across several pages, with offboarding only partial.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Human confirmation before actions, AI off switches, draft state for high-impact MCP actions, hidden sensitive fields and an activity log are documented, but the automations are waitlisted and agent action logging is partial.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 7,
   "openness_reason_a": "An official read-only MCP server and Claude connector with 35 tools, OAuth 2.0, admin off switch, API on Core, webhooks on Plus and a long integrations list are documented, but MCP cannot write.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A first-party MCP with an admin gateway that writes within permissions (high-impact actions become drafts), named clients, plug-ins and webhooks are documented, but MCP calls need a Rippling AI subscription and carry no release label.",
   "ttv_a": 8,
   "ttv_b": 3,
   "ttv_reason_a": "Days-not-weeks claim, step-by-step guide, spreadsheet or agent directory build, guided implementation and sandbox on Plus are documented across two sources, but no fee amount.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "An implementation team and DIY App Studio are named, but no timeline, fee or sandbox is published.",
   "pricing_a": 8,
   "pricing_b": 4,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Per-seat prices ($8 and $12 billed annually), plan contents, seat counting, cancellation terms and in-product billing are documented, but add-ons are talk-to-sales and the minimum amount is not stated.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "A starting price of $8 per employee per month with a base fee, Core and Pro tiers and named add-ons are published by marketing pages, but no product prices or minimum.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 8,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields and tables, permission roles with filters, unlimited entities on Plus, workflows assigning policies per office and role, and per-policy approvers are documented with two sources, with plan limits and no currency or language detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Policies and permissions keyed to any employee attribute, custom fields, multi-entity and approval workflows are documented with two sources, with per-policy approver choice and currency or language not shown.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Shapes 8.4 to 5.9.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Shapes 8.6 to 6.9.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Shapes 8.4 to 6.7.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Shapes 8.7 to 7.0.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Shapes 8.5 to 6.1."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Shapes vs Humaans",
   "a": "Shapes",
   "b": "Humaans",
   "total_a": "8.6",
   "total_b": "6.6",
   "winner": "Shapes",
   "margin": "2.0",
   "build_a": 9,
   "build_b": 7,
   "build_reason_a": "Dashboards, tools and workflows described in plain language on live permission-aware data, a community hub of named built views, and documented Workflows agent, any-field and date triggers, conditional tasks and task views, with only a template gallery missing.",
   "build_reason_b": "Tables with live data and agents created in natural language, with workflow templates, date triggers, conditional actions and task views, but event triggers are only partly documented and sharing and permissions are not detailed.",
   "agents_a": 9,
   "agents_b": 7,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents handle onboarding and the comp cycle, nothing goes live until approved, an audit log, separate AI off switches and field-level permissions are documented across several pages, with offboarding only partial.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Agents run onboarding and a comp cycle end to end with approvals, an audit log of all actions and scoped permissions, but there is no off switch and no blanket approval-before-live statement.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 9,
   "openness_reason_a": "An official read-only MCP server and Claude connector with 35 tools, OAuth 2.0, admin off switch, API on Core, webhooks on Plus and a long integrations list are documented, but MCP cannot write.",
   "openness_reason_b": "MCP is included for all customers with read and write actions, OAuth 2.0 with dynamic client registration, many named clients, audited actions, API on Growth and webhooks on Enterprise, with the gap that webhooks need a higher plan.",
   "ttv_a": 8,
   "ttv_b": 5,
   "ttv_reason_a": "Days-not-weeks claim, step-by-step guide, spreadsheet or agent directory build, guided implementation and sandbox on Plus are documented across two sources, but no fee amount.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A few days to a few months and a three week claim are published and CSV import and an Enterprise sandbox are listed, but only by marketing pages, with no fee or guided implementation detail.",
   "pricing_a": 8,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Per-seat prices ($8 and $12 billed annually), plan contents, seat counting, cancellation terms and in-product billing are documented, but add-ons are talk-to-sales and the minimum amount is not stated.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Plan and add-on contents are listed, but all plans are Talk to sales with no prices or minimum.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 7,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields and tables, permission roles with filters, unlimited entities on Plus, workflows assigning policies per office and role, and per-policy approvers are documented with two sources, with plan limits and no currency or language detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields, custom roles, multi-entity, per-policy holiday calendars and allowances and 12 languages are documented, but currency support is marketing only and Growth is limited to two roles.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Shapes 8.4 to 5.8.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Shapes 8.6 to 6.9.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Shapes 8.4 to 6.6.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Shapes 8.7 to 7.1.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Shapes 8.5 to 6.1."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Shapes vs Factorial",
   "a": "Shapes",
   "b": "Factorial",
   "total_a": "8.6",
   "total_b": "6.2",
   "winner": "Shapes",
   "margin": "2.4",
   "build_a": 9,
   "build_b": 6,
   "build_reason_a": "Dashboards, tools and workflows described in plain language on live permission-aware data, a community hub of named built views, and documented Workflows agent, any-field and date triggers, conditional tasks and task views, with only a template gallery missing.",
   "build_reason_b": "Docs show plain-language report generation within permissions, templated and custom workflows and a widget builder, but the widget builder is Enterprise only, edits need SQL and no library of built items is documented.",
   "agents_a": 9,
   "agents_b": 6,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents handle onboarding and the comp cycle, nothing goes live until approved, an audit log, separate AI off switches and field-level permissions are documented across several pages, with offboarding only partial.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Docs show per-product on or off switches, approval for every change, permission-bound actions and an admin audit log, but agents act only inside specific processes, cannot take free-form actions and the audit log does not name agent actions.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 8,
   "openness_reason_a": "An official read-only MCP server and Claude connector with 35 tools, OAuth 2.0, admin off switch, API on Core, webhooks on Plus and a long integrations list are documented, but MCP cannot write.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Documented hosted MCP with read and write, public API, retried webhooks and Copilot, Slack and Zapier integrations is equivalent to another platform at 8 and stronger than another platform at 7, which has no webhooks.",
   "ttv_a": 8,
   "ttv_b": 4,
   "ttv_reason_a": "Days-not-weeks claim, step-by-step guide, spreadsheet or agent directory build, guided implementation and sandbox on Plus are documented across two sources, but no fee amount.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A free trial, documented spreadsheet import and a demo API environment, but no timeline, fee or guided implementation.",
   "pricing_a": 8,
   "pricing_b": 5,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Per-seat prices ($8 and $12 billed annually), plan contents, seat counting, cancellation terms and in-product billing are documented, but add-ons are talk-to-sales and the minimum amount is not stated.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "The One add-on price from 2.5 euros per user, its three tiers, credit billing and no minimum number of paid users are documented, but base module prices and Enterprise terms are not.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 8,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields and tables, permission roles with filters, unlimited entities on Plus, workflows assigning policies per office and role, and per-policy approvers are documented with two sources, with plan limits and no currency or language detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields, custom permission groups, independent secondary entities with their own currencies, 16 languages (three beta) and time off policies are documented, with policy assignment per office not shown.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Shapes 8.4 to 5.8.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Shapes 8.6 to 6.4.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Shapes 8.4 to 6.5.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Shapes 8.7 to 6.4.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Shapes 8.5 to 5.9."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Shapes vs Workday",
   "a": "Shapes",
   "b": "Workday",
   "total_a": "8.6",
   "total_b": "5.7",
   "winner": "Shapes",
   "margin": "2.9",
   "build_a": 9,
   "build_b": 5,
   "build_reason_a": "Dashboards, tools and workflows described in plain language on live permission-aware data, a community hub of named built views, and documented Workflows agent, any-field and date triggers, conditional tasks and task views, with only a template gallery missing.",
   "build_reason_b": "Agent & App Builder and Developer Agent build apps and agents in plain language and business process templates, triggers and conditions exist, but the builders target developers and prompt-built business processes are not documented.",
   "agents_a": 9,
   "agents_b": 7,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents handle onboarding and the comp cycle, nothing goes live until approved, an audit log, separate AI off switches and field-level permissions are documented across several pages, with offboarding only partial.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Agents draft and execute within guardrails, with human review of sensitive actions, sandboxed what-ifs, an Agent System of Record with auditability and identity-scoped data safeguards, but comp cycle and offboarding agents and a single off switch are not documented.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 6,
   "openness_reason_a": "An official read-only MCP server and Claude connector with 35 tools, OAuth 2.0, admin off switch, API on Core, webhooks on Plus and a long integrations list are documented, but MCP cannot write.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Official MCP tools with write actions for Claude, Gemini, OpenAI and Copilot and webhooks are documented, but only by vendor pages with no release stage, plan or audit detail.",
   "ttv_a": 8,
   "ttv_b": 6,
   "ttv_reason_a": "Days-not-weeks claim, step-by-step guide, spreadsheet or agent directory build, guided implementation and sandbox on Plus are documented across two sources, but no fee amount.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "Published 10 to 20 plus week go-live, fixed price with prescribed scope, and a what-if sandbox are documented, but only on one vendor page and no amount is published.",
   "pricing_a": 8,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Per-seat prices ($8 and $12 billed annually), plan contents, seat counting, cancellation terms and in-product billing are documented, but add-ons are talk-to-sales and the minimum amount is not stated.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "The Flex Credits usage model with top-ups and complimentary credits is described on a marketing page only, with no prices, plan contents or minimum.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 7,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields and tables, permission roles with filters, unlimited entities on Plus, workflows assigning policies per office and role, and per-policy approvers are documented with two sources, with plan limits and no currency or language detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Multi-entity, multi-country and granular security groups with approvers by role are documented, but only one summary source and no custom fields or language detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Shapes 8.4 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Shapes 8.6 to 6.1.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Shapes 8.4 to 6.1.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Shapes 8.7 to 6.0.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Shapes 8.5 to 5.7."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Shapes vs BambooHR",
   "a": "Shapes",
   "b": "BambooHR",
   "total_a": "8.6",
   "total_b": "5.6",
   "winner": "Shapes",
   "margin": "3.0",
   "build_a": 9,
   "build_b": 4,
   "build_reason_a": "Dashboards, tools and workflows described in plain language on live permission-aware data, a community hub of named built views, and documented Workflows agent, any-field and date triggers, conditional tasks and task views, with only a template gallery missing.",
   "build_reason_b": "Custom reports built and refined from a prompt but several capabilities are beta or coming soon, custom dashboards need Elite, and prompt-built flows and conditional tasks are not documented.",
   "agents_a": 9,
   "agents_b": 6,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents handle onboarding and the comp cycle, nothing goes live until approved, an audit log, separate AI off switches and field-level permissions are documented across several pages, with offboarding only partial.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Prepared work goes through the appropriate person, the Audit Trail records agent changes and admins can turn the feature off, but onboarding and comp cycle agents are absent, several items are beta or coming soon, and sensitive-field controls are not named.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 7,
   "openness_reason_a": "An official read-only MCP server and Claude connector with 35 tools, OAuth 2.0, admin off switch, API on Core, webhooks on Plus and a long integrations list are documented, but MCP cannot write.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented beta MCP server with OAuth 2.0, read and write tools and admin access control, plus signed webhooks and a public API, with beta status and no dynamic client registration as limits.",
   "ttv_a": 8,
   "ttv_b": 5,
   "ttv_reason_a": "Days-not-weeks claim, step-by-step guide, spreadsheet or agent directory build, guided implementation and sandbox on Plus are documented across two sources, but no fee amount.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A free trial, 30 extra implementation days on Elite, a dedicated payroll project manager and self-serve setup are documented, but no amount, timeline or customer sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 8,
   "pricing_b": 8,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Per-seat prices ($8 and $12 billed annually), plan contents, seat counting, cancellation terms and in-product billing are documented, but add-ons are talk-to-sales and the minimum amount is not stated.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Per-employee prices for Core, Pro and Elite, flat rates for 25 or fewer employees, plan contents and billing options are published, but add-on prices and any in-product billing detail are not.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 5,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields and tables, permission roles with filters, unlimited entities on Plus, workflows assigning policies per office and role, and per-policy approvers are documented with two sources, with plan limits and no currency or language detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom tabs, tables and fields, role visibility, eight languages and localized settings are listed, mostly by marketing, with only a beta MCP docs page and no multi-entity detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Shapes 8.4 to 5.7.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Shapes 8.6 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Shapes 8.4 to 5.6.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Shapes 8.7 to 5.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Shapes 8.5 to 5.6."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Shapes vs HiBob",
   "a": "Shapes",
   "b": "HiBob",
   "total_a": "8.6",
   "total_b": "5.6",
   "winner": "Shapes",
   "margin": "3.0",
   "build_a": 9,
   "build_b": 5,
   "build_reason_a": "Dashboards, tools and workflows described in plain language on live permission-aware data, a community hub of named built views, and documented Workflows agent, any-field and date triggers, conditional tasks and task views, with only a template gallery missing.",
   "build_reason_b": "No-code workflows with conditional logic and branching, lifecycle triggers and natural-language analytics are described, but only on marketing pages and with the AI builder not yet available.",
   "agents_a": 9,
   "agents_b": 5,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents handle onboarding and the comp cycle, nothing goes live until approved, an audit log, separate AI off switches and field-level permissions are documented across several pages, with offboarding only partial.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Human approval of write actions, an admin AI off switch, role-bound access and MCP AI logs are stated, but only on marketing pages and with no whole-process agent or detailed agent audit log.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 8,
   "openness_reason_a": "An official read-only MCP server and Claude connector with 35 tools, OAuth 2.0, admin off switch, API on Core, webhooks on Plus and a long integrations list are documented, but MCP cannot write.",
   "openness_reason_b": "An official MCP server with read and write where permitted, admin controls, logs, several named clients and a public API with webhooks are documented, with minor gaps on plan and audit detail.",
   "ttv_a": 8,
   "ttv_b": 5,
   "ttv_reason_a": "Days-not-weeks claim, step-by-step guide, spreadsheet or agent directory build, guided implementation and sandbox on Plus are documented across two sources, but no fee amount.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A weeks-not-months claim, a separately sold sandbox and implementation fees in partner terms are documented, but no fee amount or guided implementation detail.",
   "pricing_a": 8,
   "pricing_b": 3,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Per-seat prices ($8 and $12 billed annually), plan contents, seat counting, cancellation terms and in-product billing are documented, but add-ons are talk-to-sales and the minimum amount is not stated.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Core contents and a per-employee pricing basis with separate modules are described by marketing pages, but no amounts and the minimum is only set in the Order Form.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 8,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields and tables, permission roles with filters, unlimited entities on Plus, workflows assigning policies per office and role, and per-policy approvers are documented with two sources, with plan limits and no currency or language detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields and tables, group-based permissions, policy visibility settings, location policies and multi-entity are documented, with language support from marketing only and no per-policy approver choice.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Shapes 8.4 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Shapes 8.6 to 6.0.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Shapes 8.4 to 6.3.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Shapes 8.7 to 5.9.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Shapes 8.5 to 5.5."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Shapes vs Lattice",
   "a": "Shapes",
   "b": "Lattice",
   "total_a": "8.6",
   "total_b": "5.5",
   "winner": "Shapes",
   "margin": "3.1",
   "build_a": 9,
   "build_b": 4,
   "build_reason_a": "Dashboards, tools and workflows described in plain language on live permission-aware data, a community hub of named built views, and documented Workflows agent, any-field and date triggers, conditional tasks and task views, with only a template gallery missing.",
   "build_reason_b": "Docs show admin-built custom reports shared with chosen employees and scheduled exports, adding to limited-beta AI and review rules, but there is no prompt-built report or flow.",
   "agents_a": 9,
   "agents_b": 5,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents handle onboarding and the comp cycle, nothing goes live until approved, an audit log, separate AI off switches and field-level permissions are documented across several pages, with offboarding only partial.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Docs show a full AI off switch, opt-in per feature, draft review before actions, sensitive-field roles and an agent dashboard log with gaps, but the agent takes single actions and runs no whole process.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 7,
   "openness_reason_a": "An official read-only MCP server and Claude connector with 35 tools, OAuth 2.0, admin off switch, API on Core, webhooks on Plus and a long integrations list are documented, but MCP cannot write.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server with read and write scopes, same permissions, a Claude directory connector with a read-only option, a public API and SCIM, but no webhooks and API write-back limited to goals.",
   "ttv_a": 8,
   "ttv_b": 7,
   "ttv_reason_a": "Days-not-weeks claim, step-by-step guide, spreadsheet or agent directory build, guided implementation and sandbox on Plus are documented across two sources, but no fee amount.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A sandbox on request adds the one element the current reason lacked, which puts it level with or above another platform at 7 with no sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 8,
   "pricing_b": 7,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Per-seat prices ($8 and $12 billed annually), plan contents, seat counting, cancellation terms and in-product billing are documented, but add-ons are talk-to-sales and the minimum amount is not stated.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Per-seat prices for each talent module and add-on and a $4,000 minimum annual agreement are published, but the HRIS is unpriced, enterprise is by quote and in-product billing is not shown.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 6,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields and tables, permission roles with filters, unlimited entities on Plus, workflows assigning policies per office and role, and per-policy approvers are documented with two sources, with plan limits and no currency or language detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields, targeted custom roles with per-field permissions, 24 languages and multi-currency compensation cycles are documented, but there is no multi-entity or per-office policy and the HRIS is a US limited beta.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Shapes 8.4 to 6.0.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Shapes 8.6 to 5.6.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Shapes 8.4 to 6.0.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Shapes 8.7 to 5.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Shapes 8.5 to 5.9."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Shapes vs Personio",
   "a": "Shapes",
   "b": "Personio",
   "total_a": "8.6",
   "total_b": "5.4",
   "winner": "Shapes",
   "margin": "3.2",
   "build_a": 9,
   "build_b": 6,
   "build_reason_a": "Dashboards, tools and workflows described in plain language on live permission-aware data, a community hub of named built views, and documented Workflows agent, any-field and date triggers, conditional tasks and task views, with only a template gallery missing.",
   "build_reason_b": "Docs show a no-code workflow builder with templates, conditions and draft or activate, and a Report Builder with permission-respecting data, but natural-language workflow building and a library of built items are not documented.",
   "agents_a": 9,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents handle onboarding and the comp cycle, nothing goes live until approved, an audit log, separate AI off switches and field-level permissions are documented across several pages, with offboarding only partial.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Docs add central and per-feature AI off switches with a spend limit, advisory-only screening, audited MCP setting changes and hidden person attributes, but no process-running agent or agent audit log.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 6,
   "openness_reason_a": "An official read-only MCP server and Claude connector with 35 tools, OAuth 2.0, admin off switch, API on Core, webhooks on Plus and a long integrations list are documented, but MCP cannot write.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented official MCP server (beta, Core Pro) with read, opt-in write, per-tool switches and named clients, a webhooks API and Slack and Teams integrations, but beta status and the Core Pro API restriction limit it.",
   "ttv_a": 8,
   "ttv_b": 6,
   "ttv_reason_a": "Days-not-weeks claim, step-by-step guide, spreadsheet or agent directory build, guided implementation and sandbox on Plus are documented across two sources, but no fee amount.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A guided Implementation Specialist, phased payroll implementation, a 14-day trial, import tools and a one-time fee are documented, but no timeline or amount and the sandbox is on a paid support plan.",
   "pricing_a": 8,
   "pricing_b": 3,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Per-seat prices ($8 and $12 billed annually), plan contents, seat counting, cancellation terms and in-product billing are documented, but add-ons are talk-to-sales and the minimum amount is not stated.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Three plans with contents, named add-ons and a 12-month minimum run-time are published, but no prices and no implementation amount (a third-party figure is only a weak hint).",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 8,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields and tables, permission roles with filters, unlimited entities on Plus, workflows assigning policies per office and role, and per-policy approvers are documented with two sources, with plan limits and no currency or language detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Unlimited entities, permissions, custom attributes, per-process approvers, per-workplace currency and per-user language are documented in docs, with policies per office not shown.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Shapes 8.4 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Shapes 8.6 to 5.8.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Shapes 8.4 to 6.0.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Shapes 8.7 to 5.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Shapes 8.5 to 5.5."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Shapes vs Deel",
   "a": "Shapes",
   "b": "Deel",
   "total_a": "8.6",
   "total_b": "5.2",
   "winner": "Shapes",
   "margin": "3.4",
   "build_a": 9,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "Dashboards, tools and workflows described in plain language on live permission-aware data, a community hub of named built views, and documented Workflows agent, any-field and date triggers, conditional tasks and task views, with only a template gallery missing.",
   "build_reason_b": "A no-code workflow builder with triggers, filters, conditions, delay steps and a simulation tool is described on a marketing page, but building by description and sharing are not documented.",
   "agents_a": 9,
   "agents_b": 5,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents handle onboarding and the comp cycle, nothing goes live until approved, an audit log, separate AI off switches and field-level permissions are documented across several pages, with offboarding only partial.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Agentic workflows from triggers with human approval and logged actions cover about as many elements as another platform at 5, also on one marketing page, so 4 understates it.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 8,
   "openness_reason_a": "An official read-only MCP server and Claude connector with 35 tools, OAuth 2.0, admin off switch, API on Core, webhooks on Plus and a long integrations list are documented, but MCP cannot write.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented official MCP server with read and write OAuth scopes checked per call, signed webhooks with retries, REST API and named AI clients, with gaps on plan detail and audit.",
   "ttv_a": 8,
   "ttv_b": 6,
   "ttv_reason_a": "Days-not-weeks claim, step-by-step guide, spreadsheet or agent directory build, guided implementation and sandbox on Plus are documented across two sources, but no fee amount.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A weeks-not-months claim, described implementation steps with an onboarding manager and a documented API sandbox, but no fee and the claim is marketing only.",
   "pricing_a": 8,
   "pricing_b": 6,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Per-seat prices ($8 and $12 billed annually), plan contents, seat counting, cancellation terms and in-product billing are documented, but add-ons are talk-to-sales and the minimum amount is not stated.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Core from $5 per employee per month, contents of three tiers, and EOR, PEO, contractor, payroll and IT prices are published with month-to-month terms, but Advanced, Elite and recruiting prices are not.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 6,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields and tables, permission roles with filters, unlimited entities on Plus, workflows assigning policies per office and role, and per-policy approvers are documented with two sources, with plan limits and no currency or language detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Multi-country entities, job architecture, country time off policies and approvals plus payment in 120+ currencies are documented, but no custom fields, roles or per-policy approvers.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Shapes 8.4 to 5.5.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Shapes 8.6 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Shapes 8.4 to 5.8; Deel is the specialist for payroll in 150 countries inside the HRIS.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Shapes 8.7 to 5.3.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Shapes 8.5 to 5.5."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Shapes vs Gusto",
   "a": "Shapes",
   "b": "Gusto",
   "total_a": "8.6",
   "total_b": "4.1",
   "winner": "Shapes",
   "margin": "4.5",
   "build_a": 9,
   "build_b": 1,
   "build_reason_a": "Dashboards, tools and workflows described in plain language on live permission-aware data, a community hub of named built views, and documented Workflows agent, any-field and date triggers, conditional tasks and task views, with only a template gallery missing.",
   "build_reason_b": "Reports and AI suggestions with onboarding templates and employee tasks, but no natural-language builder, any-field triggers or conditions found.",
   "agents_a": 9,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents handle onboarding and the comp cycle, nothing goes live until approved, an audit log, separate AI off switches and field-level permissions are documented across several pages, with offboarding only partial.",
   "agents_reason_b": "MCP writes come back for confirmation and admins choose data categories, but there is no HR agent running processes, no audit statement and only partial off-switch controls.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 6,
   "openness_reason_a": "An official read-only MCP server and Claude connector with 35 tools, OAuth 2.0, admin off switch, API on Core, webhooks on Plus and a long integrations list are documented, but MCP cannot write.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server for customers exists, but the public API and webhooks are restricted to partners and the developer MCP server is beta.",
   "ttv_a": 8,
   "ttv_b": 7,
   "ttv_reason_a": "Days-not-weeks claim, step-by-step guide, spreadsheet or agent directory build, guided implementation and sandbox on Plus are documented across two sources, but no fee amount.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "No setup fee, guided setup included and self-serve are documented across two sources, but no timeline or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 8,
   "pricing_b": 9,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Per-seat prices ($8 and $12 billed annually), plan contents, seat counting, cancellation terms and in-product billing are documented, but add-ons are talk-to-sales and the minimum amount is not stated.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Base and per-person prices for three plans, priced add-ons and month-to-month terms with no plan minimum are published; in-product billing is not documented.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 3,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields and tables, permission roles with filters, unlimited entities on Plus, workflows assigning policies per office and role, and per-policy approvers are documented with two sources, with plan limits and no currency or language detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields through the API, time off approvals and report filters by department and address are documented, with no multi-entity, currency or language detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Shapes 8.4 to 5.0.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Shapes 8.6 to 3.9.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Shapes 8.4 to 4.3.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Shapes 8.7 to 3.8.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Shapes 8.5 to 4.8."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Shapes vs Paylocity",
   "a": "Shapes",
   "b": "Paylocity",
   "total_a": "8.6",
   "total_b": "3.3",
   "winner": "Shapes",
   "margin": "5.3",
   "build_a": 9,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "Dashboards, tools and workflows described in plain language on live permission-aware data, a community hub of named built views, and documented Workflows agent, any-field and date triggers, conditional tasks and task views, with only a template gallery missing.",
   "build_reason_b": "Ready-made and custom workflow templates with filters, conditional routing, manager creation rights and progress dashboards are described on a marketing page, but no natural-language builder is documented.",
   "agents_a": 9,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents handle onboarding and the comp cycle, nothing goes live until approved, an audit log, separate AI off switches and field-level permissions are documented across several pages, with offboarding only partial.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Purpose-built agents for onboarding, payroll and expenses with an enable choice and monitoring of actions are described on a marketing page, but no approval step, audit log or field-level control is stated.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 3,
   "openness_reason_a": "An official read-only MCP server and Claude connector with 35 tools, OAuth 2.0, admin off switch, API on Core, webhooks on Plus and a long integrations list are documented, but MCP cannot write.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server exists but only for API documentation, and webhooks and developer access are limited to early adopters, partners or custom-integration agreements.",
   "ttv_a": 8,
   "ttv_b": 2,
   "ttv_reason_a": "Days-not-weeks claim, step-by-step guide, spreadsheet or agent directory build, guided implementation and sandbox on Plus are documented across two sources, but no fee amount.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A 4 to 16 week integration estimate and a sandbox for approved customers and partners are documented, but nothing on HR platform go-live, fee or guided implementation.",
   "pricing_a": 8,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Per-seat prices ($8 and $12 billed annually), plan contents, seat counting, cancellation terms and in-product billing are documented, but add-ons are talk-to-sales and the minimum amount is not stated.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Contents are listed by module, but there are no prices, tiers or minimum, only a request for pricing through a demo.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 5,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields and tables, permission roles with filters, unlimited entities on Plus, workflows assigning policies per office and role, and per-policy approvers are documented with two sources, with plan limits and no currency or language detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Unlimited custom fields, location-based workflow filters and global payroll currencies are described, but only by marketing pages, with no entity or role detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Shapes 8.4 to 3.1.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Shapes 8.6 to 3.6.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Shapes 8.4 to 3.7.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Shapes 8.7 to 3.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Shapes 8.5 to 3.2."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Shapes vs ADP",
   "a": "Shapes",
   "b": "ADP",
   "total_a": "8.6",
   "total_b": "2.8",
   "winner": "Shapes",
   "margin": "5.8",
   "build_a": 9,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "Dashboards, tools and workflows described in plain language on live permission-aware data, a community hub of named built views, and documented Workflows agent, any-field and date triggers, conditional tasks and task views, with only a template gallery missing.",
   "build_reason_b": "Drag and drop report building with sharing and a prebuilt report library are described, plus guided workflows, but only on marketing pages and with no natural-language building or admin-editable triggers.",
   "agents_a": 9,
   "agents_b": 2,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents handle onboarding and the comp cycle, nothing goes live until approved, an audit log, separate AI off switches and field-level permissions are documented across several pages, with offboarding only partial.",
   "agents_reason_b": "A virtual assistant answers HR questions and role-based access exists, but no process agent, approval model, audit log or off switch is documented.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 3,
   "openness_reason_a": "An official read-only MCP server and Claude connector with 35 tools, OAuth 2.0, admin off switch, API on Core, webhooks on Plus and a long integrations list are documented, but MCP cannot write.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Docs-type developer pages show HR, time and payroll APIs with OAuth 2.0, but API Central is a separate purchase, the MCP mention is marketing only, and no webhooks were found.",
   "ttv_a": 8,
   "ttv_b": 3,
   "ttv_reason_a": "Days-not-weeks claim, step-by-step guide, spreadsheet or agent directory build, guided implementation and sandbox on Plus are documented across two sources, but no fee amount.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "An implementation team and Client Success Executive from day one are named, with no timeline, fee or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 8,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Per-seat prices ($8 and $12 billed annually), plan contents, seat counting, cancellation terms and in-product billing are documented, but add-ons are talk-to-sales and the minimum amount is not stated.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Three package names with contents are published, but every tier is Get Pricing with no amounts, add-on prices or minimum.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 4,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields and tables, permission roles with filters, unlimited entities on Plus, workflows assigning policies per office and role, and per-policy approvers are documented with two sources, with plan limits and no currency or language detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Role approvals, time off policies and multi-country support with a customizable portal are described, but mostly by marketing pages and with no custom fields or entity detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Shapes 8.4 to 2.9.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Shapes 8.6 to 3.0.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Shapes 8.4 to 3.2.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Shapes 8.7 to 2.9.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Shapes 8.5 to 2.9."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Shapes vs Sage",
   "a": "Shapes",
   "b": "Sage",
   "total_a": "8.6",
   "total_b": "2.2",
   "winner": "Shapes",
   "margin": "6.4",
   "build_a": 9,
   "build_b": 1,
   "build_reason_a": "Dashboards, tools and workflows described in plain language on live permission-aware data, a community hub of named built views, and documented Workflows agent, any-field and date triggers, conditional tasks and task views, with only a template gallery missing.",
   "build_reason_b": "Reports and checklist templates with employee task lists, but no natural-language builder, triggers or conditions found and only one source.",
   "agents_a": 9,
   "agents_b": 1,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents handle onboarding and the comp cycle, nothing goes live until approved, an audit log, separate AI off switches and field-level permissions are documented across several pages, with offboarding only partial.",
   "agents_reason_b": "No agent, approval model, audit log or AI off switch was found; only permission levels are mentioned.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 2,
   "openness_reason_a": "An official read-only MCP server and Claude connector with 35 tools, OAuth 2.0, admin off switch, API on Core, webhooks on Plus and a long integrations list are documented, but MCP cannot write.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Only a Sage API was found, with no MCP server, no webhooks and no AI integrations.",
   "ttv_a": 8,
   "ttv_b": 4,
   "ttv_reason_a": "Days-not-weeks claim, step-by-step guide, spreadsheet or agent directory build, guided implementation and sandbox on Plus are documented across two sources, but no fee amount.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A 30-day free trial and modular self-serve setup are documented, with implementation through partners and no fee, timeline or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 8,
   "pricing_b": 7,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Per-seat prices ($8 and $12 billed annually), plan contents, seat counting, cancellation terms and in-product billing are documented, but add-ons are talk-to-sales and the minimum amount is not stated.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Per-employee module prices and priced add-ons are published for the US, but no minimum is stated, the enterprise product is by quote and in-product billing is not shown.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 2,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields and tables, permission roles with filters, unlimited entities on Plus, workflows assigning policies per office and role, and per-policy approvers are documented with two sources, with plan limits and no currency or language detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Leave policies and manager approvals are documented, but multi-entity and multi-country configuration are not shown as available.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Shapes 8.4 to 3.3.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Shapes 8.6 to 2.2.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Shapes 8.4 to 2.8.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Shapes 8.7 to 2.0.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Shapes 8.5 to 3.0."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Rippling vs Humaans",
   "a": "Rippling",
   "b": "Humaans",
   "total_a": "6.7",
   "total_b": "6.6",
   "winner": "Rippling",
   "margin": "0.1",
   "build_a": 8,
   "build_b": 7,
   "build_reason_a": "Reports and dashboards from a prompt that are editable and shareable, automations described in plain language with schedule, data and webhook triggers, branching, templates, App Studio and an inbox, with the builder claim largely vendor-stated and a library not clearly documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Tables with live data and agents created in natural language, with workflow templates, date triggers, conditional actions and task views, but event triggers are only partly documented and sharing and permissions are not detailed.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 7,
   "agents_reason_a": "Human confirmation before actions, AI off switches, draft state for high-impact MCP actions, hidden sensitive fields and an activity log are documented, but the automations are waitlisted and agent action logging is partial.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Agents run onboarding and a comp cycle end to end with approvals, an audit log of all actions and scoped permissions, but there is no off switch and no blanket approval-before-live statement.",
   "openness_a": 7,
   "openness_b": 9,
   "openness_reason_a": "A first-party MCP with an admin gateway that writes within permissions (high-impact actions become drafts), named clients, plug-ins and webhooks are documented, but MCP calls need a Rippling AI subscription and carry no release label.",
   "openness_reason_b": "MCP is included for all customers with read and write actions, OAuth 2.0 with dynamic client registration, many named clients, audited actions, API on Growth and webhooks on Enterprise, with the gap that webhooks need a higher plan.",
   "ttv_a": 3,
   "ttv_b": 5,
   "ttv_reason_a": "An implementation team and DIY App Studio are named, but no timeline, fee or sandbox is published.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A few days to a few months and a three week claim are published and CSV import and an Enterprise sandbox are listed, but only by marketing pages, with no fee or guided implementation detail.",
   "pricing_a": 4,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "A starting price of $8 per employee per month with a base fee, Core and Pro tiers and named add-ons are published by marketing pages, but no product prices or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Plan and add-on contents are listed, but all plans are Talk to sales with no prices or minimum.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 7,
   "fit_reason_a": "Policies and permissions keyed to any employee attribute, custom fields, multi-entity and approval workflows are documented with two sources, with per-policy approver choice and currency or language not shown.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields, custom roles, multi-entity, per-policy holiday calendars and allowances and 12 languages are documented, but currency support is marketing only and Growth is limited to two roles.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Rippling 5.9 to 5.8.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Humaans 6.9 to 6.9.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Rippling 6.7 to 6.6.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Humaans 7.1 to 7.0.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Humaans 6.1 to 6.1."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Rippling vs Factorial",
   "a": "Rippling",
   "b": "Factorial",
   "total_a": "6.7",
   "total_b": "6.2",
   "winner": "Rippling",
   "margin": "0.5",
   "build_a": 8,
   "build_b": 6,
   "build_reason_a": "Reports and dashboards from a prompt that are editable and shareable, automations described in plain language with schedule, data and webhook triggers, branching, templates, App Studio and an inbox, with the builder claim largely vendor-stated and a library not clearly documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Docs show plain-language report generation within permissions, templated and custom workflows and a widget builder, but the widget builder is Enterprise only, edits need SQL and no library of built items is documented.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 6,
   "agents_reason_a": "Human confirmation before actions, AI off switches, draft state for high-impact MCP actions, hidden sensitive fields and an activity log are documented, but the automations are waitlisted and agent action logging is partial.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Docs show per-product on or off switches, approval for every change, permission-bound actions and an admin audit log, but agents act only inside specific processes, cannot take free-form actions and the audit log does not name agent actions.",
   "openness_a": 7,
   "openness_b": 8,
   "openness_reason_a": "A first-party MCP with an admin gateway that writes within permissions (high-impact actions become drafts), named clients, plug-ins and webhooks are documented, but MCP calls need a Rippling AI subscription and carry no release label.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Documented hosted MCP with read and write, public API, retried webhooks and Copilot, Slack and Zapier integrations is equivalent to another platform at 8 and stronger than another platform at 7, which has no webhooks.",
   "ttv_a": 3,
   "ttv_b": 4,
   "ttv_reason_a": "An implementation team and DIY App Studio are named, but no timeline, fee or sandbox is published.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A free trial, documented spreadsheet import and a demo API environment, but no timeline, fee or guided implementation.",
   "pricing_a": 4,
   "pricing_b": 5,
   "pricing_reason_a": "A starting price of $8 per employee per month with a base fee, Core and Pro tiers and named add-ons are published by marketing pages, but no product prices or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "The One add-on price from 2.5 euros per user, its three tiers, credit billing and no minimum number of paid users are documented, but base module prices and Enterprise terms are not.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 8,
   "fit_reason_a": "Policies and permissions keyed to any employee attribute, custom fields, multi-entity and approval workflows are documented with two sources, with per-policy approver choice and currency or language not shown.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields, custom permission groups, independent secondary entities with their own currencies, 16 languages (three beta) and time off policies are documented, with policy assignment per office not shown.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Rippling 5.9 to 5.8.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Rippling 6.9 to 6.4.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Rippling 6.7 to 6.5.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Rippling 7.0 to 6.4.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Rippling 6.1 to 5.9."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Rippling vs Workday",
   "a": "Rippling",
   "b": "Workday",
   "total_a": "6.7",
   "total_b": "5.7",
   "winner": "Rippling",
   "margin": "1.0",
   "build_a": 8,
   "build_b": 5,
   "build_reason_a": "Reports and dashboards from a prompt that are editable and shareable, automations described in plain language with schedule, data and webhook triggers, branching, templates, App Studio and an inbox, with the builder claim largely vendor-stated and a library not clearly documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Agent & App Builder and Developer Agent build apps and agents in plain language and business process templates, triggers and conditions exist, but the builders target developers and prompt-built business processes are not documented.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 7,
   "agents_reason_a": "Human confirmation before actions, AI off switches, draft state for high-impact MCP actions, hidden sensitive fields and an activity log are documented, but the automations are waitlisted and agent action logging is partial.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Agents draft and execute within guardrails, with human review of sensitive actions, sandboxed what-ifs, an Agent System of Record with auditability and identity-scoped data safeguards, but comp cycle and offboarding agents and a single off switch are not documented.",
   "openness_a": 7,
   "openness_b": 6,
   "openness_reason_a": "A first-party MCP with an admin gateway that writes within permissions (high-impact actions become drafts), named clients, plug-ins and webhooks are documented, but MCP calls need a Rippling AI subscription and carry no release label.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Official MCP tools with write actions for Claude, Gemini, OpenAI and Copilot and webhooks are documented, but only by vendor pages with no release stage, plan or audit detail.",
   "ttv_a": 3,
   "ttv_b": 6,
   "ttv_reason_a": "An implementation team and DIY App Studio are named, but no timeline, fee or sandbox is published.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "Published 10 to 20 plus week go-live, fixed price with prescribed scope, and a what-if sandbox are documented, but only on one vendor page and no amount is published.",
   "pricing_a": 4,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "A starting price of $8 per employee per month with a base fee, Core and Pro tiers and named add-ons are published by marketing pages, but no product prices or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "The Flex Credits usage model with top-ups and complimentary credits is described on a marketing page only, with no prices, plan contents or minimum.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 7,
   "fit_reason_a": "Policies and permissions keyed to any employee attribute, custom fields, multi-entity and approval workflows are documented with two sources, with per-policy approver choice and currency or language not shown.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Multi-entity, multi-country and granular security groups with approvers by role are documented, but only one summary source and no custom fields or language detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Rippling 5.9 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Rippling 6.9 to 6.1.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Rippling 6.7 to 6.1.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Rippling 7.0 to 6.0.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Rippling 6.1 to 5.7."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Rippling vs BambooHR",
   "a": "Rippling",
   "b": "BambooHR",
   "total_a": "6.7",
   "total_b": "5.6",
   "winner": "Rippling",
   "margin": "1.1",
   "build_a": 8,
   "build_b": 4,
   "build_reason_a": "Reports and dashboards from a prompt that are editable and shareable, automations described in plain language with schedule, data and webhook triggers, branching, templates, App Studio and an inbox, with the builder claim largely vendor-stated and a library not clearly documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Custom reports built and refined from a prompt but several capabilities are beta or coming soon, custom dashboards need Elite, and prompt-built flows and conditional tasks are not documented.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 6,
   "agents_reason_a": "Human confirmation before actions, AI off switches, draft state for high-impact MCP actions, hidden sensitive fields and an activity log are documented, but the automations are waitlisted and agent action logging is partial.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Prepared work goes through the appropriate person, the Audit Trail records agent changes and admins can turn the feature off, but onboarding and comp cycle agents are absent, several items are beta or coming soon, and sensitive-field controls are not named.",
   "openness_a": 7,
   "openness_b": 7,
   "openness_reason_a": "A first-party MCP with an admin gateway that writes within permissions (high-impact actions become drafts), named clients, plug-ins and webhooks are documented, but MCP calls need a Rippling AI subscription and carry no release label.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented beta MCP server with OAuth 2.0, read and write tools and admin access control, plus signed webhooks and a public API, with beta status and no dynamic client registration as limits.",
   "ttv_a": 3,
   "ttv_b": 5,
   "ttv_reason_a": "An implementation team and DIY App Studio are named, but no timeline, fee or sandbox is published.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A free trial, 30 extra implementation days on Elite, a dedicated payroll project manager and self-serve setup are documented, but no amount, timeline or customer sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 4,
   "pricing_b": 8,
   "pricing_reason_a": "A starting price of $8 per employee per month with a base fee, Core and Pro tiers and named add-ons are published by marketing pages, but no product prices or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Per-employee prices for Core, Pro and Elite, flat rates for 25 or fewer employees, plan contents and billing options are published, but add-on prices and any in-product billing detail are not.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 5,
   "fit_reason_a": "Policies and permissions keyed to any employee attribute, custom fields, multi-entity and approval workflows are documented with two sources, with per-policy approver choice and currency or language not shown.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom tabs, tables and fields, role visibility, eight languages and localized settings are listed, mostly by marketing, with only a beta MCP docs page and no multi-entity detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Rippling 5.9 to 5.7.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Rippling 6.9 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Rippling 6.7 to 5.6.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Rippling 7.0 to 5.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Rippling 6.1 to 5.6."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Rippling vs HiBob",
   "a": "Rippling",
   "b": "HiBob",
   "total_a": "6.7",
   "total_b": "5.6",
   "winner": "Rippling",
   "margin": "1.1",
   "build_a": 8,
   "build_b": 5,
   "build_reason_a": "Reports and dashboards from a prompt that are editable and shareable, automations described in plain language with schedule, data and webhook triggers, branching, templates, App Studio and an inbox, with the builder claim largely vendor-stated and a library not clearly documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "No-code workflows with conditional logic and branching, lifecycle triggers and natural-language analytics are described, but only on marketing pages and with the AI builder not yet available.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 5,
   "agents_reason_a": "Human confirmation before actions, AI off switches, draft state for high-impact MCP actions, hidden sensitive fields and an activity log are documented, but the automations are waitlisted and agent action logging is partial.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Human approval of write actions, an admin AI off switch, role-bound access and MCP AI logs are stated, but only on marketing pages and with no whole-process agent or detailed agent audit log.",
   "openness_a": 7,
   "openness_b": 8,
   "openness_reason_a": "A first-party MCP with an admin gateway that writes within permissions (high-impact actions become drafts), named clients, plug-ins and webhooks are documented, but MCP calls need a Rippling AI subscription and carry no release label.",
   "openness_reason_b": "An official MCP server with read and write where permitted, admin controls, logs, several named clients and a public API with webhooks are documented, with minor gaps on plan and audit detail.",
   "ttv_a": 3,
   "ttv_b": 5,
   "ttv_reason_a": "An implementation team and DIY App Studio are named, but no timeline, fee or sandbox is published.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A weeks-not-months claim, a separately sold sandbox and implementation fees in partner terms are documented, but no fee amount or guided implementation detail.",
   "pricing_a": 4,
   "pricing_b": 3,
   "pricing_reason_a": "A starting price of $8 per employee per month with a base fee, Core and Pro tiers and named add-ons are published by marketing pages, but no product prices or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Core contents and a per-employee pricing basis with separate modules are described by marketing pages, but no amounts and the minimum is only set in the Order Form.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 8,
   "fit_reason_a": "Policies and permissions keyed to any employee attribute, custom fields, multi-entity and approval workflows are documented with two sources, with per-policy approver choice and currency or language not shown.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields and tables, group-based permissions, policy visibility settings, location policies and multi-entity are documented, with language support from marketing only and no per-policy approver choice.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Rippling 5.9 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Rippling 6.9 to 6.0.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Rippling 6.7 to 6.3.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Rippling 7.0 to 5.9.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Rippling 6.1 to 5.5."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Rippling vs Lattice",
   "a": "Rippling",
   "b": "Lattice",
   "total_a": "6.7",
   "total_b": "5.5",
   "winner": "Rippling",
   "margin": "1.2",
   "build_a": 8,
   "build_b": 4,
   "build_reason_a": "Reports and dashboards from a prompt that are editable and shareable, automations described in plain language with schedule, data and webhook triggers, branching, templates, App Studio and an inbox, with the builder claim largely vendor-stated and a library not clearly documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Docs show admin-built custom reports shared with chosen employees and scheduled exports, adding to limited-beta AI and review rules, but there is no prompt-built report or flow.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 5,
   "agents_reason_a": "Human confirmation before actions, AI off switches, draft state for high-impact MCP actions, hidden sensitive fields and an activity log are documented, but the automations are waitlisted and agent action logging is partial.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Docs show a full AI off switch, opt-in per feature, draft review before actions, sensitive-field roles and an agent dashboard log with gaps, but the agent takes single actions and runs no whole process.",
   "openness_a": 7,
   "openness_b": 7,
   "openness_reason_a": "A first-party MCP with an admin gateway that writes within permissions (high-impact actions become drafts), named clients, plug-ins and webhooks are documented, but MCP calls need a Rippling AI subscription and carry no release label.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server with read and write scopes, same permissions, a Claude directory connector with a read-only option, a public API and SCIM, but no webhooks and API write-back limited to goals.",
   "ttv_a": 3,
   "ttv_b": 7,
   "ttv_reason_a": "An implementation team and DIY App Studio are named, but no timeline, fee or sandbox is published.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A sandbox on request adds the one element the current reason lacked, which puts it level with or above another platform at 7 with no sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 4,
   "pricing_b": 7,
   "pricing_reason_a": "A starting price of $8 per employee per month with a base fee, Core and Pro tiers and named add-ons are published by marketing pages, but no product prices or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Per-seat prices for each talent module and add-on and a $4,000 minimum annual agreement are published, but the HRIS is unpriced, enterprise is by quote and in-product billing is not shown.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 6,
   "fit_reason_a": "Policies and permissions keyed to any employee attribute, custom fields, multi-entity and approval workflows are documented with two sources, with per-policy approver choice and currency or language not shown.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields, targeted custom roles with per-field permissions, 24 languages and multi-currency compensation cycles are documented, but there is no multi-entity or per-office policy and the HRIS is a US limited beta.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Lattice 6.0 to 5.9.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Rippling 6.9 to 5.6.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Rippling 6.7 to 6.0.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Rippling 7.0 to 5.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Rippling 6.1 to 5.9."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Rippling vs Personio",
   "a": "Rippling",
   "b": "Personio",
   "total_a": "6.7",
   "total_b": "5.4",
   "winner": "Rippling",
   "margin": "1.3",
   "build_a": 8,
   "build_b": 6,
   "build_reason_a": "Reports and dashboards from a prompt that are editable and shareable, automations described in plain language with schedule, data and webhook triggers, branching, templates, App Studio and an inbox, with the builder claim largely vendor-stated and a library not clearly documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Docs show a no-code workflow builder with templates, conditions and draft or activate, and a Report Builder with permission-respecting data, but natural-language workflow building and a library of built items are not documented.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Human confirmation before actions, AI off switches, draft state for high-impact MCP actions, hidden sensitive fields and an activity log are documented, but the automations are waitlisted and agent action logging is partial.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Docs add central and per-feature AI off switches with a spend limit, advisory-only screening, audited MCP setting changes and hidden person attributes, but no process-running agent or agent audit log.",
   "openness_a": 7,
   "openness_b": 6,
   "openness_reason_a": "A first-party MCP with an admin gateway that writes within permissions (high-impact actions become drafts), named clients, plug-ins and webhooks are documented, but MCP calls need a Rippling AI subscription and carry no release label.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented official MCP server (beta, Core Pro) with read, opt-in write, per-tool switches and named clients, a webhooks API and Slack and Teams integrations, but beta status and the Core Pro API restriction limit it.",
   "ttv_a": 3,
   "ttv_b": 6,
   "ttv_reason_a": "An implementation team and DIY App Studio are named, but no timeline, fee or sandbox is published.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A guided Implementation Specialist, phased payroll implementation, a 14-day trial, import tools and a one-time fee are documented, but no timeline or amount and the sandbox is on a paid support plan.",
   "pricing_a": 4,
   "pricing_b": 3,
   "pricing_reason_a": "A starting price of $8 per employee per month with a base fee, Core and Pro tiers and named add-ons are published by marketing pages, but no product prices or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Three plans with contents, named add-ons and a 12-month minimum run-time are published, but no prices and no implementation amount (a third-party figure is only a weak hint).",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 8,
   "fit_reason_a": "Policies and permissions keyed to any employee attribute, custom fields, multi-entity and approval workflows are documented with two sources, with per-policy approver choice and currency or language not shown.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Unlimited entities, permissions, custom attributes, per-process approvers, per-workplace currency and per-user language are documented in docs, with policies per office not shown.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Rippling 5.9 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Rippling 6.9 to 5.8.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Rippling 6.7 to 6.0.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Rippling 7.0 to 5.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Rippling 6.1 to 5.5."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Rippling vs Deel",
   "a": "Rippling",
   "b": "Deel",
   "total_a": "6.7",
   "total_b": "5.2",
   "winner": "Rippling",
   "margin": "1.5",
   "build_a": 8,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "Reports and dashboards from a prompt that are editable and shareable, automations described in plain language with schedule, data and webhook triggers, branching, templates, App Studio and an inbox, with the builder claim largely vendor-stated and a library not clearly documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "A no-code workflow builder with triggers, filters, conditions, delay steps and a simulation tool is described on a marketing page, but building by description and sharing are not documented.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 5,
   "agents_reason_a": "Human confirmation before actions, AI off switches, draft state for high-impact MCP actions, hidden sensitive fields and an activity log are documented, but the automations are waitlisted and agent action logging is partial.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Agentic workflows from triggers with human approval and logged actions cover about as many elements as another platform at 5, also on one marketing page, so 4 understates it.",
   "openness_a": 7,
   "openness_b": 8,
   "openness_reason_a": "A first-party MCP with an admin gateway that writes within permissions (high-impact actions become drafts), named clients, plug-ins and webhooks are documented, but MCP calls need a Rippling AI subscription and carry no release label.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented official MCP server with read and write OAuth scopes checked per call, signed webhooks with retries, REST API and named AI clients, with gaps on plan detail and audit.",
   "ttv_a": 3,
   "ttv_b": 6,
   "ttv_reason_a": "An implementation team and DIY App Studio are named, but no timeline, fee or sandbox is published.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A weeks-not-months claim, described implementation steps with an onboarding manager and a documented API sandbox, but no fee and the claim is marketing only.",
   "pricing_a": 4,
   "pricing_b": 6,
   "pricing_reason_a": "A starting price of $8 per employee per month with a base fee, Core and Pro tiers and named add-ons are published by marketing pages, but no product prices or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Core from $5 per employee per month, contents of three tiers, and EOR, PEO, contractor, payroll and IT prices are published with month-to-month terms, but Advanced, Elite and recruiting prices are not.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 6,
   "fit_reason_a": "Policies and permissions keyed to any employee attribute, custom fields, multi-entity and approval workflows are documented with two sources, with per-policy approver choice and currency or language not shown.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Multi-country entities, job architecture, country time off policies and approvals plus payment in 120+ currencies are documented, but no custom fields, roles or per-policy approvers.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Rippling 5.9 to 5.5.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Rippling 6.9 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Rippling 6.7 to 5.8; Deel is the specialist for payroll in 150 countries inside the HRIS.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Rippling 7.0 to 5.3.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Rippling 6.1 to 5.5."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Rippling vs Gusto",
   "a": "Rippling",
   "b": "Gusto",
   "total_a": "6.7",
   "total_b": "4.1",
   "winner": "Rippling",
   "margin": "2.6",
   "build_a": 8,
   "build_b": 1,
   "build_reason_a": "Reports and dashboards from a prompt that are editable and shareable, automations described in plain language with schedule, data and webhook triggers, branching, templates, App Studio and an inbox, with the builder claim largely vendor-stated and a library not clearly documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Reports and AI suggestions with onboarding templates and employee tasks, but no natural-language builder, any-field triggers or conditions found.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Human confirmation before actions, AI off switches, draft state for high-impact MCP actions, hidden sensitive fields and an activity log are documented, but the automations are waitlisted and agent action logging is partial.",
   "agents_reason_b": "MCP writes come back for confirmation and admins choose data categories, but there is no HR agent running processes, no audit statement and only partial off-switch controls.",
   "openness_a": 7,
   "openness_b": 6,
   "openness_reason_a": "A first-party MCP with an admin gateway that writes within permissions (high-impact actions become drafts), named clients, plug-ins and webhooks are documented, but MCP calls need a Rippling AI subscription and carry no release label.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server for customers exists, but the public API and webhooks are restricted to partners and the developer MCP server is beta.",
   "ttv_a": 3,
   "ttv_b": 7,
   "ttv_reason_a": "An implementation team and DIY App Studio are named, but no timeline, fee or sandbox is published.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "No setup fee, guided setup included and self-serve are documented across two sources, but no timeline or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 4,
   "pricing_b": 9,
   "pricing_reason_a": "A starting price of $8 per employee per month with a base fee, Core and Pro tiers and named add-ons are published by marketing pages, but no product prices or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Base and per-person prices for three plans, priced add-ons and month-to-month terms with no plan minimum are published; in-product billing is not documented.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 3,
   "fit_reason_a": "Policies and permissions keyed to any employee attribute, custom fields, multi-entity and approval workflows are documented with two sources, with per-policy approver choice and currency or language not shown.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields through the API, time off approvals and report filters by department and address are documented, with no multi-entity, currency or language detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Rippling 5.9 to 5.0.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Rippling 6.9 to 3.9.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Rippling 6.7 to 4.3.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Rippling 7.0 to 3.8.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Rippling 6.1 to 4.8."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Rippling vs Paylocity",
   "a": "Rippling",
   "b": "Paylocity",
   "total_a": "6.7",
   "total_b": "3.3",
   "winner": "Rippling",
   "margin": "3.4",
   "build_a": 8,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "Reports and dashboards from a prompt that are editable and shareable, automations described in plain language with schedule, data and webhook triggers, branching, templates, App Studio and an inbox, with the builder claim largely vendor-stated and a library not clearly documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Ready-made and custom workflow templates with filters, conditional routing, manager creation rights and progress dashboards are described on a marketing page, but no natural-language builder is documented.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Human confirmation before actions, AI off switches, draft state for high-impact MCP actions, hidden sensitive fields and an activity log are documented, but the automations are waitlisted and agent action logging is partial.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Purpose-built agents for onboarding, payroll and expenses with an enable choice and monitoring of actions are described on a marketing page, but no approval step, audit log or field-level control is stated.",
   "openness_a": 7,
   "openness_b": 3,
   "openness_reason_a": "A first-party MCP with an admin gateway that writes within permissions (high-impact actions become drafts), named clients, plug-ins and webhooks are documented, but MCP calls need a Rippling AI subscription and carry no release label.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server exists but only for API documentation, and webhooks and developer access are limited to early adopters, partners or custom-integration agreements.",
   "ttv_a": 3,
   "ttv_b": 2,
   "ttv_reason_a": "An implementation team and DIY App Studio are named, but no timeline, fee or sandbox is published.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A 4 to 16 week integration estimate and a sandbox for approved customers and partners are documented, but nothing on HR platform go-live, fee or guided implementation.",
   "pricing_a": 4,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "A starting price of $8 per employee per month with a base fee, Core and Pro tiers and named add-ons are published by marketing pages, but no product prices or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Contents are listed by module, but there are no prices, tiers or minimum, only a request for pricing through a demo.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 5,
   "fit_reason_a": "Policies and permissions keyed to any employee attribute, custom fields, multi-entity and approval workflows are documented with two sources, with per-policy approver choice and currency or language not shown.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Unlimited custom fields, location-based workflow filters and global payroll currencies are described, but only by marketing pages, with no entity or role detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Rippling 5.9 to 3.1.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Rippling 6.9 to 3.6.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Rippling 6.7 to 3.7.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Rippling 7.0 to 3.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Rippling 6.1 to 3.2."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Rippling vs ADP",
   "a": "Rippling",
   "b": "ADP",
   "total_a": "6.7",
   "total_b": "2.8",
   "winner": "Rippling",
   "margin": "3.9",
   "build_a": 8,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "Reports and dashboards from a prompt that are editable and shareable, automations described in plain language with schedule, data and webhook triggers, branching, templates, App Studio and an inbox, with the builder claim largely vendor-stated and a library not clearly documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Drag and drop report building with sharing and a prebuilt report library are described, plus guided workflows, but only on marketing pages and with no natural-language building or admin-editable triggers.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 2,
   "agents_reason_a": "Human confirmation before actions, AI off switches, draft state for high-impact MCP actions, hidden sensitive fields and an activity log are documented, but the automations are waitlisted and agent action logging is partial.",
   "agents_reason_b": "A virtual assistant answers HR questions and role-based access exists, but no process agent, approval model, audit log or off switch is documented.",
   "openness_a": 7,
   "openness_b": 3,
   "openness_reason_a": "A first-party MCP with an admin gateway that writes within permissions (high-impact actions become drafts), named clients, plug-ins and webhooks are documented, but MCP calls need a Rippling AI subscription and carry no release label.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Docs-type developer pages show HR, time and payroll APIs with OAuth 2.0, but API Central is a separate purchase, the MCP mention is marketing only, and no webhooks were found.",
   "ttv_a": 3,
   "ttv_b": 3,
   "ttv_reason_a": "An implementation team and DIY App Studio are named, but no timeline, fee or sandbox is published.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "An implementation team and Client Success Executive from day one are named, with no timeline, fee or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 4,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "A starting price of $8 per employee per month with a base fee, Core and Pro tiers and named add-ons are published by marketing pages, but no product prices or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Three package names with contents are published, but every tier is Get Pricing with no amounts, add-on prices or minimum.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 4,
   "fit_reason_a": "Policies and permissions keyed to any employee attribute, custom fields, multi-entity and approval workflows are documented with two sources, with per-policy approver choice and currency or language not shown.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Role approvals, time off policies and multi-country support with a customizable portal are described, but mostly by marketing pages and with no custom fields or entity detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Rippling 5.9 to 2.9.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Rippling 6.9 to 3.0.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Rippling 6.7 to 3.2.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Rippling 7.0 to 2.9.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Rippling 6.1 to 2.9."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Rippling vs Sage",
   "a": "Rippling",
   "b": "Sage",
   "total_a": "6.7",
   "total_b": "2.2",
   "winner": "Rippling",
   "margin": "4.5",
   "build_a": 8,
   "build_b": 1,
   "build_reason_a": "Reports and dashboards from a prompt that are editable and shareable, automations described in plain language with schedule, data and webhook triggers, branching, templates, App Studio and an inbox, with the builder claim largely vendor-stated and a library not clearly documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Reports and checklist templates with employee task lists, but no natural-language builder, triggers or conditions found and only one source.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 1,
   "agents_reason_a": "Human confirmation before actions, AI off switches, draft state for high-impact MCP actions, hidden sensitive fields and an activity log are documented, but the automations are waitlisted and agent action logging is partial.",
   "agents_reason_b": "No agent, approval model, audit log or AI off switch was found; only permission levels are mentioned.",
   "openness_a": 7,
   "openness_b": 2,
   "openness_reason_a": "A first-party MCP with an admin gateway that writes within permissions (high-impact actions become drafts), named clients, plug-ins and webhooks are documented, but MCP calls need a Rippling AI subscription and carry no release label.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Only a Sage API was found, with no MCP server, no webhooks and no AI integrations.",
   "ttv_a": 3,
   "ttv_b": 4,
   "ttv_reason_a": "An implementation team and DIY App Studio are named, but no timeline, fee or sandbox is published.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A 30-day free trial and modular self-serve setup are documented, with implementation through partners and no fee, timeline or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 4,
   "pricing_b": 7,
   "pricing_reason_a": "A starting price of $8 per employee per month with a base fee, Core and Pro tiers and named add-ons are published by marketing pages, but no product prices or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Per-employee module prices and priced add-ons are published for the US, but no minimum is stated, the enterprise product is by quote and in-product billing is not shown.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 2,
   "fit_reason_a": "Policies and permissions keyed to any employee attribute, custom fields, multi-entity and approval workflows are documented with two sources, with per-policy approver choice and currency or language not shown.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Leave policies and manager approvals are documented, but multi-entity and multi-country configuration are not shown as available.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Rippling 5.9 to 3.3.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Rippling 6.9 to 2.2.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Rippling 6.7 to 2.8.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Rippling 7.0 to 2.0.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Rippling 6.1 to 3.0."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Humaans vs Factorial",
   "a": "Humaans",
   "b": "Factorial",
   "total_a": "6.6",
   "total_b": "6.2",
   "winner": "Humaans",
   "margin": "0.4",
   "build_a": 7,
   "build_b": 6,
   "build_reason_a": "Tables with live data and agents created in natural language, with workflow templates, date triggers, conditional actions and task views, but event triggers are only partly documented and sharing and permissions are not detailed.",
   "build_reason_b": "Docs show plain-language report generation within permissions, templated and custom workflows and a widget builder, but the widget builder is Enterprise only, edits need SQL and no library of built items is documented.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 6,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents run onboarding and a comp cycle end to end with approvals, an audit log of all actions and scoped permissions, but there is no off switch and no blanket approval-before-live statement.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Docs show per-product on or off switches, approval for every change, permission-bound actions and an admin audit log, but agents act only inside specific processes, cannot take free-form actions and the audit log does not name agent actions.",
   "openness_a": 9,
   "openness_b": 8,
   "openness_reason_a": "MCP is included for all customers with read and write actions, OAuth 2.0 with dynamic client registration, many named clients, audited actions, API on Growth and webhooks on Enterprise, with the gap that webhooks need a higher plan.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Documented hosted MCP with read and write, public API, retried webhooks and Copilot, Slack and Zapier integrations is equivalent to another platform at 8 and stronger than another platform at 7, which has no webhooks.",
   "ttv_a": 5,
   "ttv_b": 4,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A few days to a few months and a three week claim are published and CSV import and an Enterprise sandbox are listed, but only by marketing pages, with no fee or guided implementation detail.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A free trial, documented spreadsheet import and a demo API environment, but no timeline, fee or guided implementation.",
   "pricing_a": 2,
   "pricing_b": 5,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Plan and add-on contents are listed, but all plans are Talk to sales with no prices or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "The One add-on price from 2.5 euros per user, its three tiers, credit billing and no minimum number of paid users are documented, but base module prices and Enterprise terms are not.",
   "fit_a": 7,
   "fit_b": 8,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields, custom roles, multi-entity, per-policy holiday calendars and allowances and 12 languages are documented, but currency support is marketing only and Growth is limited to two roles.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields, custom permission groups, independent secondary entities with their own currencies, 16 languages (three beta) and time off policies are documented, with policy assignment per office not shown.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Factorial 5.8 to 5.8.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Humaans 6.9 to 6.4.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Humaans 6.6 to 6.5.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Humaans 7.1 to 6.4.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Humaans 6.1 to 5.9."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Humaans vs Workday",
   "a": "Humaans",
   "b": "Workday",
   "total_a": "6.6",
   "total_b": "5.7",
   "winner": "Humaans",
   "margin": "0.9",
   "build_a": 7,
   "build_b": 5,
   "build_reason_a": "Tables with live data and agents created in natural language, with workflow templates, date triggers, conditional actions and task views, but event triggers are only partly documented and sharing and permissions are not detailed.",
   "build_reason_b": "Agent & App Builder and Developer Agent build apps and agents in plain language and business process templates, triggers and conditions exist, but the builders target developers and prompt-built business processes are not documented.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 7,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents run onboarding and a comp cycle end to end with approvals, an audit log of all actions and scoped permissions, but there is no off switch and no blanket approval-before-live statement.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Agents draft and execute within guardrails, with human review of sensitive actions, sandboxed what-ifs, an Agent System of Record with auditability and identity-scoped data safeguards, but comp cycle and offboarding agents and a single off switch are not documented.",
   "openness_a": 9,
   "openness_b": 6,
   "openness_reason_a": "MCP is included for all customers with read and write actions, OAuth 2.0 with dynamic client registration, many named clients, audited actions, API on Growth and webhooks on Enterprise, with the gap that webhooks need a higher plan.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Official MCP tools with write actions for Claude, Gemini, OpenAI and Copilot and webhooks are documented, but only by vendor pages with no release stage, plan or audit detail.",
   "ttv_a": 5,
   "ttv_b": 6,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A few days to a few months and a three week claim are published and CSV import and an Enterprise sandbox are listed, but only by marketing pages, with no fee or guided implementation detail.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "Published 10 to 20 plus week go-live, fixed price with prescribed scope, and a what-if sandbox are documented, but only on one vendor page and no amount is published.",
   "pricing_a": 2,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Plan and add-on contents are listed, but all plans are Talk to sales with no prices or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "The Flex Credits usage model with top-ups and complimentary credits is described on a marketing page only, with no prices, plan contents or minimum.",
   "fit_a": 7,
   "fit_b": 7,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields, custom roles, multi-entity, per-policy holiday calendars and allowances and 12 languages are documented, but currency support is marketing only and Growth is limited to two roles.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Multi-entity, multi-country and granular security groups with approvers by role are documented, but only one summary source and no custom fields or language detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Humaans 5.8 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Humaans 6.9 to 6.1.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Humaans 6.6 to 6.1.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Humaans 7.1 to 6.0.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Humaans 6.1 to 5.7."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Humaans vs BambooHR",
   "a": "Humaans",
   "b": "BambooHR",
   "total_a": "6.6",
   "total_b": "5.6",
   "winner": "Humaans",
   "margin": "1.0",
   "build_a": 7,
   "build_b": 4,
   "build_reason_a": "Tables with live data and agents created in natural language, with workflow templates, date triggers, conditional actions and task views, but event triggers are only partly documented and sharing and permissions are not detailed.",
   "build_reason_b": "Custom reports built and refined from a prompt but several capabilities are beta or coming soon, custom dashboards need Elite, and prompt-built flows and conditional tasks are not documented.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 6,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents run onboarding and a comp cycle end to end with approvals, an audit log of all actions and scoped permissions, but there is no off switch and no blanket approval-before-live statement.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Prepared work goes through the appropriate person, the Audit Trail records agent changes and admins can turn the feature off, but onboarding and comp cycle agents are absent, several items are beta or coming soon, and sensitive-field controls are not named.",
   "openness_a": 9,
   "openness_b": 7,
   "openness_reason_a": "MCP is included for all customers with read and write actions, OAuth 2.0 with dynamic client registration, many named clients, audited actions, API on Growth and webhooks on Enterprise, with the gap that webhooks need a higher plan.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented beta MCP server with OAuth 2.0, read and write tools and admin access control, plus signed webhooks and a public API, with beta status and no dynamic client registration as limits.",
   "ttv_a": 5,
   "ttv_b": 5,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A few days to a few months and a three week claim are published and CSV import and an Enterprise sandbox are listed, but only by marketing pages, with no fee or guided implementation detail.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A free trial, 30 extra implementation days on Elite, a dedicated payroll project manager and self-serve setup are documented, but no amount, timeline or customer sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 2,
   "pricing_b": 8,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Plan and add-on contents are listed, but all plans are Talk to sales with no prices or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Per-employee prices for Core, Pro and Elite, flat rates for 25 or fewer employees, plan contents and billing options are published, but add-on prices and any in-product billing detail are not.",
   "fit_a": 7,
   "fit_b": 5,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields, custom roles, multi-entity, per-policy holiday calendars and allowances and 12 languages are documented, but currency support is marketing only and Growth is limited to two roles.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom tabs, tables and fields, role visibility, eight languages and localized settings are listed, mostly by marketing, with only a beta MCP docs page and no multi-entity detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Humaans 5.8 to 5.7.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Humaans 6.9 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Humaans 6.6 to 5.6.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Humaans 7.1 to 5.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Humaans 6.1 to 5.6."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Humaans vs HiBob",
   "a": "Humaans",
   "b": "HiBob",
   "total_a": "6.6",
   "total_b": "5.6",
   "winner": "Humaans",
   "margin": "1.0",
   "build_a": 7,
   "build_b": 5,
   "build_reason_a": "Tables with live data and agents created in natural language, with workflow templates, date triggers, conditional actions and task views, but event triggers are only partly documented and sharing and permissions are not detailed.",
   "build_reason_b": "No-code workflows with conditional logic and branching, lifecycle triggers and natural-language analytics are described, but only on marketing pages and with the AI builder not yet available.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 5,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents run onboarding and a comp cycle end to end with approvals, an audit log of all actions and scoped permissions, but there is no off switch and no blanket approval-before-live statement.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Human approval of write actions, an admin AI off switch, role-bound access and MCP AI logs are stated, but only on marketing pages and with no whole-process agent or detailed agent audit log.",
   "openness_a": 9,
   "openness_b": 8,
   "openness_reason_a": "MCP is included for all customers with read and write actions, OAuth 2.0 with dynamic client registration, many named clients, audited actions, API on Growth and webhooks on Enterprise, with the gap that webhooks need a higher plan.",
   "openness_reason_b": "An official MCP server with read and write where permitted, admin controls, logs, several named clients and a public API with webhooks are documented, with minor gaps on plan and audit detail.",
   "ttv_a": 5,
   "ttv_b": 5,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A few days to a few months and a three week claim are published and CSV import and an Enterprise sandbox are listed, but only by marketing pages, with no fee or guided implementation detail.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A weeks-not-months claim, a separately sold sandbox and implementation fees in partner terms are documented, but no fee amount or guided implementation detail.",
   "pricing_a": 2,
   "pricing_b": 3,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Plan and add-on contents are listed, but all plans are Talk to sales with no prices or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Core contents and a per-employee pricing basis with separate modules are described by marketing pages, but no amounts and the minimum is only set in the Order Form.",
   "fit_a": 7,
   "fit_b": 8,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields, custom roles, multi-entity, per-policy holiday calendars and allowances and 12 languages are documented, but currency support is marketing only and Growth is limited to two roles.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields and tables, group-based permissions, policy visibility settings, location policies and multi-entity are documented, with language support from marketing only and no per-policy approver choice.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Humaans 5.8 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Humaans 6.9 to 6.0.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Humaans 6.6 to 6.3.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Humaans 7.1 to 5.9.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Humaans 6.1 to 5.5."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Humaans vs Lattice",
   "a": "Humaans",
   "b": "Lattice",
   "total_a": "6.6",
   "total_b": "5.5",
   "winner": "Humaans",
   "margin": "1.1",
   "build_a": 7,
   "build_b": 4,
   "build_reason_a": "Tables with live data and agents created in natural language, with workflow templates, date triggers, conditional actions and task views, but event triggers are only partly documented and sharing and permissions are not detailed.",
   "build_reason_b": "Docs show admin-built custom reports shared with chosen employees and scheduled exports, adding to limited-beta AI and review rules, but there is no prompt-built report or flow.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 5,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents run onboarding and a comp cycle end to end with approvals, an audit log of all actions and scoped permissions, but there is no off switch and no blanket approval-before-live statement.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Docs show a full AI off switch, opt-in per feature, draft review before actions, sensitive-field roles and an agent dashboard log with gaps, but the agent takes single actions and runs no whole process.",
   "openness_a": 9,
   "openness_b": 7,
   "openness_reason_a": "MCP is included for all customers with read and write actions, OAuth 2.0 with dynamic client registration, many named clients, audited actions, API on Growth and webhooks on Enterprise, with the gap that webhooks need a higher plan.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server with read and write scopes, same permissions, a Claude directory connector with a read-only option, a public API and SCIM, but no webhooks and API write-back limited to goals.",
   "ttv_a": 5,
   "ttv_b": 7,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A few days to a few months and a three week claim are published and CSV import and an Enterprise sandbox are listed, but only by marketing pages, with no fee or guided implementation detail.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A sandbox on request adds the one element the current reason lacked, which puts it level with or above another platform at 7 with no sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 2,
   "pricing_b": 7,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Plan and add-on contents are listed, but all plans are Talk to sales with no prices or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Per-seat prices for each talent module and add-on and a $4,000 minimum annual agreement are published, but the HRIS is unpriced, enterprise is by quote and in-product billing is not shown.",
   "fit_a": 7,
   "fit_b": 6,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields, custom roles, multi-entity, per-policy holiday calendars and allowances and 12 languages are documented, but currency support is marketing only and Growth is limited to two roles.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields, targeted custom roles with per-field permissions, 24 languages and multi-currency compensation cycles are documented, but there is no multi-entity or per-office policy and the HRIS is a US limited beta.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Lattice 6.0 to 5.8.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Humaans 6.9 to 5.6.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Humaans 6.6 to 6.0.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Humaans 7.1 to 5.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Humaans 6.1 to 5.9."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Humaans vs Personio",
   "a": "Humaans",
   "b": "Personio",
   "total_a": "6.6",
   "total_b": "5.4",
   "winner": "Humaans",
   "margin": "1.2",
   "build_a": 7,
   "build_b": 6,
   "build_reason_a": "Tables with live data and agents created in natural language, with workflow templates, date triggers, conditional actions and task views, but event triggers are only partly documented and sharing and permissions are not detailed.",
   "build_reason_b": "Docs show a no-code workflow builder with templates, conditions and draft or activate, and a Report Builder with permission-respecting data, but natural-language workflow building and a library of built items are not documented.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents run onboarding and a comp cycle end to end with approvals, an audit log of all actions and scoped permissions, but there is no off switch and no blanket approval-before-live statement.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Docs add central and per-feature AI off switches with a spend limit, advisory-only screening, audited MCP setting changes and hidden person attributes, but no process-running agent or agent audit log.",
   "openness_a": 9,
   "openness_b": 6,
   "openness_reason_a": "MCP is included for all customers with read and write actions, OAuth 2.0 with dynamic client registration, many named clients, audited actions, API on Growth and webhooks on Enterprise, with the gap that webhooks need a higher plan.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented official MCP server (beta, Core Pro) with read, opt-in write, per-tool switches and named clients, a webhooks API and Slack and Teams integrations, but beta status and the Core Pro API restriction limit it.",
   "ttv_a": 5,
   "ttv_b": 6,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A few days to a few months and a three week claim are published and CSV import and an Enterprise sandbox are listed, but only by marketing pages, with no fee or guided implementation detail.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A guided Implementation Specialist, phased payroll implementation, a 14-day trial, import tools and a one-time fee are documented, but no timeline or amount and the sandbox is on a paid support plan.",
   "pricing_a": 2,
   "pricing_b": 3,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Plan and add-on contents are listed, but all plans are Talk to sales with no prices or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Three plans with contents, named add-ons and a 12-month minimum run-time are published, but no prices and no implementation amount (a third-party figure is only a weak hint).",
   "fit_a": 7,
   "fit_b": 8,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields, custom roles, multi-entity, per-policy holiday calendars and allowances and 12 languages are documented, but currency support is marketing only and Growth is limited to two roles.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Unlimited entities, permissions, custom attributes, per-process approvers, per-workplace currency and per-user language are documented in docs, with policies per office not shown.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Humaans 5.8 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Humaans 6.9 to 5.8.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Humaans 6.6 to 6.0.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Humaans 7.1 to 5.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Humaans 6.1 to 5.5."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Humaans vs Deel",
   "a": "Humaans",
   "b": "Deel",
   "total_a": "6.6",
   "total_b": "5.2",
   "winner": "Humaans",
   "margin": "1.4",
   "build_a": 7,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "Tables with live data and agents created in natural language, with workflow templates, date triggers, conditional actions and task views, but event triggers are only partly documented and sharing and permissions are not detailed.",
   "build_reason_b": "A no-code workflow builder with triggers, filters, conditions, delay steps and a simulation tool is described on a marketing page, but building by description and sharing are not documented.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 5,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents run onboarding and a comp cycle end to end with approvals, an audit log of all actions and scoped permissions, but there is no off switch and no blanket approval-before-live statement.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Agentic workflows from triggers with human approval and logged actions cover about as many elements as another platform at 5, also on one marketing page, so 4 understates it.",
   "openness_a": 9,
   "openness_b": 8,
   "openness_reason_a": "MCP is included for all customers with read and write actions, OAuth 2.0 with dynamic client registration, many named clients, audited actions, API on Growth and webhooks on Enterprise, with the gap that webhooks need a higher plan.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented official MCP server with read and write OAuth scopes checked per call, signed webhooks with retries, REST API and named AI clients, with gaps on plan detail and audit.",
   "ttv_a": 5,
   "ttv_b": 6,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A few days to a few months and a three week claim are published and CSV import and an Enterprise sandbox are listed, but only by marketing pages, with no fee or guided implementation detail.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A weeks-not-months claim, described implementation steps with an onboarding manager and a documented API sandbox, but no fee and the claim is marketing only.",
   "pricing_a": 2,
   "pricing_b": 6,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Plan and add-on contents are listed, but all plans are Talk to sales with no prices or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Core from $5 per employee per month, contents of three tiers, and EOR, PEO, contractor, payroll and IT prices are published with month-to-month terms, but Advanced, Elite and recruiting prices are not.",
   "fit_a": 7,
   "fit_b": 6,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields, custom roles, multi-entity, per-policy holiday calendars and allowances and 12 languages are documented, but currency support is marketing only and Growth is limited to two roles.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Multi-country entities, job architecture, country time off policies and approvals plus payment in 120+ currencies are documented, but no custom fields, roles or per-policy approvers.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Humaans 5.8 to 5.5.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Humaans 6.9 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Humaans 6.6 to 5.8; Deel is the specialist for payroll in 150 countries inside the HRIS.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Humaans 7.1 to 5.3.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Humaans 6.1 to 5.5."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Humaans vs Gusto",
   "a": "Humaans",
   "b": "Gusto",
   "total_a": "6.6",
   "total_b": "4.1",
   "winner": "Humaans",
   "margin": "2.5",
   "build_a": 7,
   "build_b": 1,
   "build_reason_a": "Tables with live data and agents created in natural language, with workflow templates, date triggers, conditional actions and task views, but event triggers are only partly documented and sharing and permissions are not detailed.",
   "build_reason_b": "Reports and AI suggestions with onboarding templates and employee tasks, but no natural-language builder, any-field triggers or conditions found.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents run onboarding and a comp cycle end to end with approvals, an audit log of all actions and scoped permissions, but there is no off switch and no blanket approval-before-live statement.",
   "agents_reason_b": "MCP writes come back for confirmation and admins choose data categories, but there is no HR agent running processes, no audit statement and only partial off-switch controls.",
   "openness_a": 9,
   "openness_b": 6,
   "openness_reason_a": "MCP is included for all customers with read and write actions, OAuth 2.0 with dynamic client registration, many named clients, audited actions, API on Growth and webhooks on Enterprise, with the gap that webhooks need a higher plan.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server for customers exists, but the public API and webhooks are restricted to partners and the developer MCP server is beta.",
   "ttv_a": 5,
   "ttv_b": 7,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A few days to a few months and a three week claim are published and CSV import and an Enterprise sandbox are listed, but only by marketing pages, with no fee or guided implementation detail.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "No setup fee, guided setup included and self-serve are documented across two sources, but no timeline or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 2,
   "pricing_b": 9,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Plan and add-on contents are listed, but all plans are Talk to sales with no prices or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Base and per-person prices for three plans, priced add-ons and month-to-month terms with no plan minimum are published; in-product billing is not documented.",
   "fit_a": 7,
   "fit_b": 3,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields, custom roles, multi-entity, per-policy holiday calendars and allowances and 12 languages are documented, but currency support is marketing only and Growth is limited to two roles.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields through the API, time off approvals and report filters by department and address are documented, with no multi-entity, currency or language detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Humaans 5.8 to 5.0.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Humaans 6.9 to 3.9.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Humaans 6.6 to 4.3.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Humaans 7.1 to 3.8.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Humaans 6.1 to 4.8."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Humaans vs Paylocity",
   "a": "Humaans",
   "b": "Paylocity",
   "total_a": "6.6",
   "total_b": "3.3",
   "winner": "Humaans",
   "margin": "3.3",
   "build_a": 7,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "Tables with live data and agents created in natural language, with workflow templates, date triggers, conditional actions and task views, but event triggers are only partly documented and sharing and permissions are not detailed.",
   "build_reason_b": "Ready-made and custom workflow templates with filters, conditional routing, manager creation rights and progress dashboards are described on a marketing page, but no natural-language builder is documented.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents run onboarding and a comp cycle end to end with approvals, an audit log of all actions and scoped permissions, but there is no off switch and no blanket approval-before-live statement.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Purpose-built agents for onboarding, payroll and expenses with an enable choice and monitoring of actions are described on a marketing page, but no approval step, audit log or field-level control is stated.",
   "openness_a": 9,
   "openness_b": 3,
   "openness_reason_a": "MCP is included for all customers with read and write actions, OAuth 2.0 with dynamic client registration, many named clients, audited actions, API on Growth and webhooks on Enterprise, with the gap that webhooks need a higher plan.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server exists but only for API documentation, and webhooks and developer access are limited to early adopters, partners or custom-integration agreements.",
   "ttv_a": 5,
   "ttv_b": 2,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A few days to a few months and a three week claim are published and CSV import and an Enterprise sandbox are listed, but only by marketing pages, with no fee or guided implementation detail.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A 4 to 16 week integration estimate and a sandbox for approved customers and partners are documented, but nothing on HR platform go-live, fee or guided implementation.",
   "pricing_a": 2,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Plan and add-on contents are listed, but all plans are Talk to sales with no prices or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Contents are listed by module, but there are no prices, tiers or minimum, only a request for pricing through a demo.",
   "fit_a": 7,
   "fit_b": 5,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields, custom roles, multi-entity, per-policy holiday calendars and allowances and 12 languages are documented, but currency support is marketing only and Growth is limited to two roles.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Unlimited custom fields, location-based workflow filters and global payroll currencies are described, but only by marketing pages, with no entity or role detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Humaans 5.8 to 3.1.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Humaans 6.9 to 3.6.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Humaans 6.6 to 3.7.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Humaans 7.1 to 3.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Humaans 6.1 to 3.2."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Humaans vs ADP",
   "a": "Humaans",
   "b": "ADP",
   "total_a": "6.6",
   "total_b": "2.8",
   "winner": "Humaans",
   "margin": "3.8",
   "build_a": 7,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "Tables with live data and agents created in natural language, with workflow templates, date triggers, conditional actions and task views, but event triggers are only partly documented and sharing and permissions are not detailed.",
   "build_reason_b": "Drag and drop report building with sharing and a prebuilt report library are described, plus guided workflows, but only on marketing pages and with no natural-language building or admin-editable triggers.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 2,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents run onboarding and a comp cycle end to end with approvals, an audit log of all actions and scoped permissions, but there is no off switch and no blanket approval-before-live statement.",
   "agents_reason_b": "A virtual assistant answers HR questions and role-based access exists, but no process agent, approval model, audit log or off switch is documented.",
   "openness_a": 9,
   "openness_b": 3,
   "openness_reason_a": "MCP is included for all customers with read and write actions, OAuth 2.0 with dynamic client registration, many named clients, audited actions, API on Growth and webhooks on Enterprise, with the gap that webhooks need a higher plan.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Docs-type developer pages show HR, time and payroll APIs with OAuth 2.0, but API Central is a separate purchase, the MCP mention is marketing only, and no webhooks were found.",
   "ttv_a": 5,
   "ttv_b": 3,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A few days to a few months and a three week claim are published and CSV import and an Enterprise sandbox are listed, but only by marketing pages, with no fee or guided implementation detail.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "An implementation team and Client Success Executive from day one are named, with no timeline, fee or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 2,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Plan and add-on contents are listed, but all plans are Talk to sales with no prices or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Three package names with contents are published, but every tier is Get Pricing with no amounts, add-on prices or minimum.",
   "fit_a": 7,
   "fit_b": 4,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields, custom roles, multi-entity, per-policy holiday calendars and allowances and 12 languages are documented, but currency support is marketing only and Growth is limited to two roles.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Role approvals, time off policies and multi-country support with a customizable portal are described, but mostly by marketing pages and with no custom fields or entity detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Humaans 5.8 to 2.9.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Humaans 6.9 to 3.0.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Humaans 6.6 to 3.2.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Humaans 7.1 to 2.9.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Humaans 6.1 to 2.9."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Humaans vs Sage",
   "a": "Humaans",
   "b": "Sage",
   "total_a": "6.6",
   "total_b": "2.2",
   "winner": "Humaans",
   "margin": "4.4",
   "build_a": 7,
   "build_b": 1,
   "build_reason_a": "Tables with live data and agents created in natural language, with workflow templates, date triggers, conditional actions and task views, but event triggers are only partly documented and sharing and permissions are not detailed.",
   "build_reason_b": "Reports and checklist templates with employee task lists, but no natural-language builder, triggers or conditions found and only one source.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 1,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents run onboarding and a comp cycle end to end with approvals, an audit log of all actions and scoped permissions, but there is no off switch and no blanket approval-before-live statement.",
   "agents_reason_b": "No agent, approval model, audit log or AI off switch was found; only permission levels are mentioned.",
   "openness_a": 9,
   "openness_b": 2,
   "openness_reason_a": "MCP is included for all customers with read and write actions, OAuth 2.0 with dynamic client registration, many named clients, audited actions, API on Growth and webhooks on Enterprise, with the gap that webhooks need a higher plan.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Only a Sage API was found, with no MCP server, no webhooks and no AI integrations.",
   "ttv_a": 5,
   "ttv_b": 4,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A few days to a few months and a three week claim are published and CSV import and an Enterprise sandbox are listed, but only by marketing pages, with no fee or guided implementation detail.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A 30-day free trial and modular self-serve setup are documented, with implementation through partners and no fee, timeline or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 2,
   "pricing_b": 7,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Plan and add-on contents are listed, but all plans are Talk to sales with no prices or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Per-employee module prices and priced add-ons are published for the US, but no minimum is stated, the enterprise product is by quote and in-product billing is not shown.",
   "fit_a": 7,
   "fit_b": 2,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields, custom roles, multi-entity, per-policy holiday calendars and allowances and 12 languages are documented, but currency support is marketing only and Growth is limited to two roles.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Leave policies and manager approvals are documented, but multi-entity and multi-country configuration are not shown as available.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Humaans 5.8 to 3.3.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Humaans 6.9 to 2.2.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Humaans 6.6 to 2.8.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Humaans 7.1 to 2.0.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Humaans 6.1 to 3.0."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Factorial vs Workday",
   "a": "Factorial",
   "b": "Workday",
   "total_a": "6.2",
   "total_b": "5.7",
   "winner": "Factorial",
   "margin": "0.5",
   "build_a": 6,
   "build_b": 5,
   "build_reason_a": "Docs show plain-language report generation within permissions, templated and custom workflows and a widget builder, but the widget builder is Enterprise only, edits need SQL and no library of built items is documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Agent & App Builder and Developer Agent build apps and agents in plain language and business process templates, triggers and conditions exist, but the builders target developers and prompt-built business processes are not documented.",
   "agents_a": 6,
   "agents_b": 7,
   "agents_reason_a": "Docs show per-product on or off switches, approval for every change, permission-bound actions and an admin audit log, but agents act only inside specific processes, cannot take free-form actions and the audit log does not name agent actions.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Agents draft and execute within guardrails, with human review of sensitive actions, sandboxed what-ifs, an Agent System of Record with auditability and identity-scoped data safeguards, but comp cycle and offboarding agents and a single off switch are not documented.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 6,
   "openness_reason_a": "Documented hosted MCP with read and write, public API, retried webhooks and Copilot, Slack and Zapier integrations is equivalent to another platform at 8 and stronger than another platform at 7, which has no webhooks.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Official MCP tools with write actions for Claude, Gemini, OpenAI and Copilot and webhooks are documented, but only by vendor pages with no release stage, plan or audit detail.",
   "ttv_a": 4,
   "ttv_b": 6,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A free trial, documented spreadsheet import and a demo API environment, but no timeline, fee or guided implementation.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "Published 10 to 20 plus week go-live, fixed price with prescribed scope, and a what-if sandbox are documented, but only on one vendor page and no amount is published.",
   "pricing_a": 5,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "The One add-on price from 2.5 euros per user, its three tiers, credit billing and no minimum number of paid users are documented, but base module prices and Enterprise terms are not.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "The Flex Credits usage model with top-ups and complimentary credits is described on a marketing page only, with no prices, plan contents or minimum.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 7,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields, custom permission groups, independent secondary entities with their own currencies, 16 languages (three beta) and time off policies are documented, with policy assignment per office not shown.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Multi-entity, multi-country and granular security groups with approvers by role are documented, but only one summary source and no custom fields or language detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Factorial 5.8 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Factorial 6.4 to 6.1.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Factorial 6.5 to 6.1.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Factorial 6.4 to 6.0.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Factorial 5.9 to 5.7."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Factorial vs BambooHR",
   "a": "Factorial",
   "b": "BambooHR",
   "total_a": "6.2",
   "total_b": "5.6",
   "winner": "Factorial",
   "margin": "0.6",
   "build_a": 6,
   "build_b": 4,
   "build_reason_a": "Docs show plain-language report generation within permissions, templated and custom workflows and a widget builder, but the widget builder is Enterprise only, edits need SQL and no library of built items is documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Custom reports built and refined from a prompt but several capabilities are beta or coming soon, custom dashboards need Elite, and prompt-built flows and conditional tasks are not documented.",
   "agents_a": 6,
   "agents_b": 6,
   "agents_reason_a": "Docs show per-product on or off switches, approval for every change, permission-bound actions and an admin audit log, but agents act only inside specific processes, cannot take free-form actions and the audit log does not name agent actions.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Prepared work goes through the appropriate person, the Audit Trail records agent changes and admins can turn the feature off, but onboarding and comp cycle agents are absent, several items are beta or coming soon, and sensitive-field controls are not named.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 7,
   "openness_reason_a": "Documented hosted MCP with read and write, public API, retried webhooks and Copilot, Slack and Zapier integrations is equivalent to another platform at 8 and stronger than another platform at 7, which has no webhooks.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented beta MCP server with OAuth 2.0, read and write tools and admin access control, plus signed webhooks and a public API, with beta status and no dynamic client registration as limits.",
   "ttv_a": 4,
   "ttv_b": 5,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A free trial, documented spreadsheet import and a demo API environment, but no timeline, fee or guided implementation.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A free trial, 30 extra implementation days on Elite, a dedicated payroll project manager and self-serve setup are documented, but no amount, timeline or customer sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 5,
   "pricing_b": 8,
   "pricing_reason_a": "The One add-on price from 2.5 euros per user, its three tiers, credit billing and no minimum number of paid users are documented, but base module prices and Enterprise terms are not.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Per-employee prices for Core, Pro and Elite, flat rates for 25 or fewer employees, plan contents and billing options are published, but add-on prices and any in-product billing detail are not.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 5,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields, custom permission groups, independent secondary entities with their own currencies, 16 languages (three beta) and time off policies are documented, with policy assignment per office not shown.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom tabs, tables and fields, role visibility, eight languages and localized settings are listed, mostly by marketing, with only a beta MCP docs page and no multi-entity detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Factorial 5.8 to 5.7.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Factorial 6.4 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Factorial 6.5 to 5.6.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Factorial 6.4 to 5.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Factorial 5.9 to 5.6."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Factorial vs HiBob",
   "a": "Factorial",
   "b": "HiBob",
   "total_a": "6.2",
   "total_b": "5.6",
   "winner": "Factorial",
   "margin": "0.6",
   "build_a": 6,
   "build_b": 5,
   "build_reason_a": "Docs show plain-language report generation within permissions, templated and custom workflows and a widget builder, but the widget builder is Enterprise only, edits need SQL and no library of built items is documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "No-code workflows with conditional logic and branching, lifecycle triggers and natural-language analytics are described, but only on marketing pages and with the AI builder not yet available.",
   "agents_a": 6,
   "agents_b": 5,
   "agents_reason_a": "Docs show per-product on or off switches, approval for every change, permission-bound actions and an admin audit log, but agents act only inside specific processes, cannot take free-form actions and the audit log does not name agent actions.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Human approval of write actions, an admin AI off switch, role-bound access and MCP AI logs are stated, but only on marketing pages and with no whole-process agent or detailed agent audit log.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 8,
   "openness_reason_a": "Documented hosted MCP with read and write, public API, retried webhooks and Copilot, Slack and Zapier integrations is equivalent to another platform at 8 and stronger than another platform at 7, which has no webhooks.",
   "openness_reason_b": "An official MCP server with read and write where permitted, admin controls, logs, several named clients and a public API with webhooks are documented, with minor gaps on plan and audit detail.",
   "ttv_a": 4,
   "ttv_b": 5,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A free trial, documented spreadsheet import and a demo API environment, but no timeline, fee or guided implementation.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A weeks-not-months claim, a separately sold sandbox and implementation fees in partner terms are documented, but no fee amount or guided implementation detail.",
   "pricing_a": 5,
   "pricing_b": 3,
   "pricing_reason_a": "The One add-on price from 2.5 euros per user, its three tiers, credit billing and no minimum number of paid users are documented, but base module prices and Enterprise terms are not.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Core contents and a per-employee pricing basis with separate modules are described by marketing pages, but no amounts and the minimum is only set in the Order Form.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 8,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields, custom permission groups, independent secondary entities with their own currencies, 16 languages (three beta) and time off policies are documented, with policy assignment per office not shown.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields and tables, group-based permissions, policy visibility settings, location policies and multi-entity are documented, with language support from marketing only and no per-policy approver choice.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Factorial 5.8 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Factorial 6.4 to 6.0.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Factorial 6.5 to 6.3.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Factorial 6.4 to 5.9.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Factorial 5.9 to 5.5."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Factorial vs Lattice",
   "a": "Factorial",
   "b": "Lattice",
   "total_a": "6.2",
   "total_b": "5.5",
   "winner": "Factorial",
   "margin": "0.7",
   "build_a": 6,
   "build_b": 4,
   "build_reason_a": "Docs show plain-language report generation within permissions, templated and custom workflows and a widget builder, but the widget builder is Enterprise only, edits need SQL and no library of built items is documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Docs show admin-built custom reports shared with chosen employees and scheduled exports, adding to limited-beta AI and review rules, but there is no prompt-built report or flow.",
   "agents_a": 6,
   "agents_b": 5,
   "agents_reason_a": "Docs show per-product on or off switches, approval for every change, permission-bound actions and an admin audit log, but agents act only inside specific processes, cannot take free-form actions and the audit log does not name agent actions.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Docs show a full AI off switch, opt-in per feature, draft review before actions, sensitive-field roles and an agent dashboard log with gaps, but the agent takes single actions and runs no whole process.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 7,
   "openness_reason_a": "Documented hosted MCP with read and write, public API, retried webhooks and Copilot, Slack and Zapier integrations is equivalent to another platform at 8 and stronger than another platform at 7, which has no webhooks.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server with read and write scopes, same permissions, a Claude directory connector with a read-only option, a public API and SCIM, but no webhooks and API write-back limited to goals.",
   "ttv_a": 4,
   "ttv_b": 7,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A free trial, documented spreadsheet import and a demo API environment, but no timeline, fee or guided implementation.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A sandbox on request adds the one element the current reason lacked, which puts it level with or above another platform at 7 with no sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 5,
   "pricing_b": 7,
   "pricing_reason_a": "The One add-on price from 2.5 euros per user, its three tiers, credit billing and no minimum number of paid users are documented, but base module prices and Enterprise terms are not.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Per-seat prices for each talent module and add-on and a $4,000 minimum annual agreement are published, but the HRIS is unpriced, enterprise is by quote and in-product billing is not shown.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 6,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields, custom permission groups, independent secondary entities with their own currencies, 16 languages (three beta) and time off policies are documented, with policy assignment per office not shown.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields, targeted custom roles with per-field permissions, 24 languages and multi-currency compensation cycles are documented, but there is no multi-entity or per-office policy and the HRIS is a US limited beta.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Lattice 6.0 to 5.8.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Factorial 6.4 to 5.6.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Factorial 6.5 to 6.0.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Factorial 6.4 to 5.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Factorial 5.9 to 5.9."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Factorial vs Personio",
   "a": "Factorial",
   "b": "Personio",
   "total_a": "6.2",
   "total_b": "5.4",
   "winner": "Factorial",
   "margin": "0.8",
   "build_a": 6,
   "build_b": 6,
   "build_reason_a": "Docs show plain-language report generation within permissions, templated and custom workflows and a widget builder, but the widget builder is Enterprise only, edits need SQL and no library of built items is documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Docs show a no-code workflow builder with templates, conditions and draft or activate, and a Report Builder with permission-respecting data, but natural-language workflow building and a library of built items are not documented.",
   "agents_a": 6,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Docs show per-product on or off switches, approval for every change, permission-bound actions and an admin audit log, but agents act only inside specific processes, cannot take free-form actions and the audit log does not name agent actions.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Docs add central and per-feature AI off switches with a spend limit, advisory-only screening, audited MCP setting changes and hidden person attributes, but no process-running agent or agent audit log.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 6,
   "openness_reason_a": "Documented hosted MCP with read and write, public API, retried webhooks and Copilot, Slack and Zapier integrations is equivalent to another platform at 8 and stronger than another platform at 7, which has no webhooks.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented official MCP server (beta, Core Pro) with read, opt-in write, per-tool switches and named clients, a webhooks API and Slack and Teams integrations, but beta status and the Core Pro API restriction limit it.",
   "ttv_a": 4,
   "ttv_b": 6,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A free trial, documented spreadsheet import and a demo API environment, but no timeline, fee or guided implementation.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A guided Implementation Specialist, phased payroll implementation, a 14-day trial, import tools and a one-time fee are documented, but no timeline or amount and the sandbox is on a paid support plan.",
   "pricing_a": 5,
   "pricing_b": 3,
   "pricing_reason_a": "The One add-on price from 2.5 euros per user, its three tiers, credit billing and no minimum number of paid users are documented, but base module prices and Enterprise terms are not.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Three plans with contents, named add-ons and a 12-month minimum run-time are published, but no prices and no implementation amount (a third-party figure is only a weak hint).",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 8,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields, custom permission groups, independent secondary entities with their own currencies, 16 languages (three beta) and time off policies are documented, with policy assignment per office not shown.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Unlimited entities, permissions, custom attributes, per-process approvers, per-workplace currency and per-user language are documented in docs, with policies per office not shown.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Factorial 5.8 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Factorial 6.4 to 5.8.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Factorial 6.5 to 6.0.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Factorial 6.4 to 5.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Factorial 5.9 to 5.5."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Factorial vs Deel",
   "a": "Factorial",
   "b": "Deel",
   "total_a": "6.2",
   "total_b": "5.2",
   "winner": "Factorial",
   "margin": "1.0",
   "build_a": 6,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "Docs show plain-language report generation within permissions, templated and custom workflows and a widget builder, but the widget builder is Enterprise only, edits need SQL and no library of built items is documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "A no-code workflow builder with triggers, filters, conditions, delay steps and a simulation tool is described on a marketing page, but building by description and sharing are not documented.",
   "agents_a": 6,
   "agents_b": 5,
   "agents_reason_a": "Docs show per-product on or off switches, approval for every change, permission-bound actions and an admin audit log, but agents act only inside specific processes, cannot take free-form actions and the audit log does not name agent actions.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Agentic workflows from triggers with human approval and logged actions cover about as many elements as another platform at 5, also on one marketing page, so 4 understates it.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 8,
   "openness_reason_a": "Documented hosted MCP with read and write, public API, retried webhooks and Copilot, Slack and Zapier integrations is equivalent to another platform at 8 and stronger than another platform at 7, which has no webhooks.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented official MCP server with read and write OAuth scopes checked per call, signed webhooks with retries, REST API and named AI clients, with gaps on plan detail and audit.",
   "ttv_a": 4,
   "ttv_b": 6,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A free trial, documented spreadsheet import and a demo API environment, but no timeline, fee or guided implementation.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A weeks-not-months claim, described implementation steps with an onboarding manager and a documented API sandbox, but no fee and the claim is marketing only.",
   "pricing_a": 5,
   "pricing_b": 6,
   "pricing_reason_a": "The One add-on price from 2.5 euros per user, its three tiers, credit billing and no minimum number of paid users are documented, but base module prices and Enterprise terms are not.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Core from $5 per employee per month, contents of three tiers, and EOR, PEO, contractor, payroll and IT prices are published with month-to-month terms, but Advanced, Elite and recruiting prices are not.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 6,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields, custom permission groups, independent secondary entities with their own currencies, 16 languages (three beta) and time off policies are documented, with policy assignment per office not shown.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Multi-country entities, job architecture, country time off policies and approvals plus payment in 120+ currencies are documented, but no custom fields, roles or per-policy approvers.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Factorial 5.8 to 5.5.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Factorial 6.4 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Factorial 6.5 to 5.8; Deel is the specialist for payroll in 150 countries inside the HRIS.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Factorial 6.4 to 5.3.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Factorial 5.9 to 5.5."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Factorial vs Gusto",
   "a": "Factorial",
   "b": "Gusto",
   "total_a": "6.2",
   "total_b": "4.1",
   "winner": "Factorial",
   "margin": "2.1",
   "build_a": 6,
   "build_b": 1,
   "build_reason_a": "Docs show plain-language report generation within permissions, templated and custom workflows and a widget builder, but the widget builder is Enterprise only, edits need SQL and no library of built items is documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Reports and AI suggestions with onboarding templates and employee tasks, but no natural-language builder, any-field triggers or conditions found.",
   "agents_a": 6,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Docs show per-product on or off switches, approval for every change, permission-bound actions and an admin audit log, but agents act only inside specific processes, cannot take free-form actions and the audit log does not name agent actions.",
   "agents_reason_b": "MCP writes come back for confirmation and admins choose data categories, but there is no HR agent running processes, no audit statement and only partial off-switch controls.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 6,
   "openness_reason_a": "Documented hosted MCP with read and write, public API, retried webhooks and Copilot, Slack and Zapier integrations is equivalent to another platform at 8 and stronger than another platform at 7, which has no webhooks.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server for customers exists, but the public API and webhooks are restricted to partners and the developer MCP server is beta.",
   "ttv_a": 4,
   "ttv_b": 7,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A free trial, documented spreadsheet import and a demo API environment, but no timeline, fee or guided implementation.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "No setup fee, guided setup included and self-serve are documented across two sources, but no timeline or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 5,
   "pricing_b": 9,
   "pricing_reason_a": "The One add-on price from 2.5 euros per user, its three tiers, credit billing and no minimum number of paid users are documented, but base module prices and Enterprise terms are not.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Base and per-person prices for three plans, priced add-ons and month-to-month terms with no plan minimum are published; in-product billing is not documented.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 3,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields, custom permission groups, independent secondary entities with their own currencies, 16 languages (three beta) and time off policies are documented, with policy assignment per office not shown.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields through the API, time off approvals and report filters by department and address are documented, with no multi-entity, currency or language detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Factorial 5.8 to 5.0.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Factorial 6.4 to 3.9.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Factorial 6.5 to 4.3.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Factorial 6.4 to 3.8.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Factorial 5.9 to 4.8."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Factorial vs Paylocity",
   "a": "Factorial",
   "b": "Paylocity",
   "total_a": "6.2",
   "total_b": "3.3",
   "winner": "Factorial",
   "margin": "2.9",
   "build_a": 6,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "Docs show plain-language report generation within permissions, templated and custom workflows and a widget builder, but the widget builder is Enterprise only, edits need SQL and no library of built items is documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Ready-made and custom workflow templates with filters, conditional routing, manager creation rights and progress dashboards are described on a marketing page, but no natural-language builder is documented.",
   "agents_a": 6,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Docs show per-product on or off switches, approval for every change, permission-bound actions and an admin audit log, but agents act only inside specific processes, cannot take free-form actions and the audit log does not name agent actions.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Purpose-built agents for onboarding, payroll and expenses with an enable choice and monitoring of actions are described on a marketing page, but no approval step, audit log or field-level control is stated.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 3,
   "openness_reason_a": "Documented hosted MCP with read and write, public API, retried webhooks and Copilot, Slack and Zapier integrations is equivalent to another platform at 8 and stronger than another platform at 7, which has no webhooks.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server exists but only for API documentation, and webhooks and developer access are limited to early adopters, partners or custom-integration agreements.",
   "ttv_a": 4,
   "ttv_b": 2,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A free trial, documented spreadsheet import and a demo API environment, but no timeline, fee or guided implementation.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A 4 to 16 week integration estimate and a sandbox for approved customers and partners are documented, but nothing on HR platform go-live, fee or guided implementation.",
   "pricing_a": 5,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "The One add-on price from 2.5 euros per user, its three tiers, credit billing and no minimum number of paid users are documented, but base module prices and Enterprise terms are not.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Contents are listed by module, but there are no prices, tiers or minimum, only a request for pricing through a demo.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 5,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields, custom permission groups, independent secondary entities with their own currencies, 16 languages (three beta) and time off policies are documented, with policy assignment per office not shown.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Unlimited custom fields, location-based workflow filters and global payroll currencies are described, but only by marketing pages, with no entity or role detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Factorial 5.8 to 3.1.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Factorial 6.4 to 3.6.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Factorial 6.5 to 3.7.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Factorial 6.4 to 3.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Factorial 5.9 to 3.2."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Factorial vs ADP",
   "a": "Factorial",
   "b": "ADP",
   "total_a": "6.2",
   "total_b": "2.8",
   "winner": "Factorial",
   "margin": "3.4",
   "build_a": 6,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "Docs show plain-language report generation within permissions, templated and custom workflows and a widget builder, but the widget builder is Enterprise only, edits need SQL and no library of built items is documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Drag and drop report building with sharing and a prebuilt report library are described, plus guided workflows, but only on marketing pages and with no natural-language building or admin-editable triggers.",
   "agents_a": 6,
   "agents_b": 2,
   "agents_reason_a": "Docs show per-product on or off switches, approval for every change, permission-bound actions and an admin audit log, but agents act only inside specific processes, cannot take free-form actions and the audit log does not name agent actions.",
   "agents_reason_b": "A virtual assistant answers HR questions and role-based access exists, but no process agent, approval model, audit log or off switch is documented.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 3,
   "openness_reason_a": "Documented hosted MCP with read and write, public API, retried webhooks and Copilot, Slack and Zapier integrations is equivalent to another platform at 8 and stronger than another platform at 7, which has no webhooks.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Docs-type developer pages show HR, time and payroll APIs with OAuth 2.0, but API Central is a separate purchase, the MCP mention is marketing only, and no webhooks were found.",
   "ttv_a": 4,
   "ttv_b": 3,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A free trial, documented spreadsheet import and a demo API environment, but no timeline, fee or guided implementation.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "An implementation team and Client Success Executive from day one are named, with no timeline, fee or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 5,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "The One add-on price from 2.5 euros per user, its three tiers, credit billing and no minimum number of paid users are documented, but base module prices and Enterprise terms are not.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Three package names with contents are published, but every tier is Get Pricing with no amounts, add-on prices or minimum.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 4,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields, custom permission groups, independent secondary entities with their own currencies, 16 languages (three beta) and time off policies are documented, with policy assignment per office not shown.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Role approvals, time off policies and multi-country support with a customizable portal are described, but mostly by marketing pages and with no custom fields or entity detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Factorial 5.8 to 2.9.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Factorial 6.4 to 3.0.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Factorial 6.5 to 3.2.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Factorial 6.4 to 2.9.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Factorial 5.9 to 2.9."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Factorial vs Sage",
   "a": "Factorial",
   "b": "Sage",
   "total_a": "6.2",
   "total_b": "2.2",
   "winner": "Factorial",
   "margin": "4.0",
   "build_a": 6,
   "build_b": 1,
   "build_reason_a": "Docs show plain-language report generation within permissions, templated and custom workflows and a widget builder, but the widget builder is Enterprise only, edits need SQL and no library of built items is documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Reports and checklist templates with employee task lists, but no natural-language builder, triggers or conditions found and only one source.",
   "agents_a": 6,
   "agents_b": 1,
   "agents_reason_a": "Docs show per-product on or off switches, approval for every change, permission-bound actions and an admin audit log, but agents act only inside specific processes, cannot take free-form actions and the audit log does not name agent actions.",
   "agents_reason_b": "No agent, approval model, audit log or AI off switch was found; only permission levels are mentioned.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 2,
   "openness_reason_a": "Documented hosted MCP with read and write, public API, retried webhooks and Copilot, Slack and Zapier integrations is equivalent to another platform at 8 and stronger than another platform at 7, which has no webhooks.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Only a Sage API was found, with no MCP server, no webhooks and no AI integrations.",
   "ttv_a": 4,
   "ttv_b": 4,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A free trial, documented spreadsheet import and a demo API environment, but no timeline, fee or guided implementation.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A 30-day free trial and modular self-serve setup are documented, with implementation through partners and no fee, timeline or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 5,
   "pricing_b": 7,
   "pricing_reason_a": "The One add-on price from 2.5 euros per user, its three tiers, credit billing and no minimum number of paid users are documented, but base module prices and Enterprise terms are not.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Per-employee module prices and priced add-ons are published for the US, but no minimum is stated, the enterprise product is by quote and in-product billing is not shown.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 2,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields, custom permission groups, independent secondary entities with their own currencies, 16 languages (three beta) and time off policies are documented, with policy assignment per office not shown.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Leave policies and manager approvals are documented, but multi-entity and multi-country configuration are not shown as available.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Factorial 5.8 to 3.3.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Factorial 6.4 to 2.2.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Factorial 6.5 to 2.8.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Factorial 6.4 to 2.0.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Factorial 5.9 to 3.0."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Workday vs BambooHR",
   "a": "Workday",
   "b": "BambooHR",
   "total_a": "5.7",
   "total_b": "5.6",
   "winner": "Workday",
   "margin": "0.1",
   "build_a": 5,
   "build_b": 4,
   "build_reason_a": "Agent & App Builder and Developer Agent build apps and agents in plain language and business process templates, triggers and conditions exist, but the builders target developers and prompt-built business processes are not documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Custom reports built and refined from a prompt but several capabilities are beta or coming soon, custom dashboards need Elite, and prompt-built flows and conditional tasks are not documented.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 6,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents draft and execute within guardrails, with human review of sensitive actions, sandboxed what-ifs, an Agent System of Record with auditability and identity-scoped data safeguards, but comp cycle and offboarding agents and a single off switch are not documented.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Prepared work goes through the appropriate person, the Audit Trail records agent changes and admins can turn the feature off, but onboarding and comp cycle agents are absent, several items are beta or coming soon, and sensitive-field controls are not named.",
   "openness_a": 6,
   "openness_b": 7,
   "openness_reason_a": "Official MCP tools with write actions for Claude, Gemini, OpenAI and Copilot and webhooks are documented, but only by vendor pages with no release stage, plan or audit detail.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented beta MCP server with OAuth 2.0, read and write tools and admin access control, plus signed webhooks and a public API, with beta status and no dynamic client registration as limits.",
   "ttv_a": 6,
   "ttv_b": 5,
   "ttv_reason_a": "Published 10 to 20 plus week go-live, fixed price with prescribed scope, and a what-if sandbox are documented, but only on one vendor page and no amount is published.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A free trial, 30 extra implementation days on Elite, a dedicated payroll project manager and self-serve setup are documented, but no amount, timeline or customer sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 2,
   "pricing_b": 8,
   "pricing_reason_a": "The Flex Credits usage model with top-ups and complimentary credits is described on a marketing page only, with no prices, plan contents or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Per-employee prices for Core, Pro and Elite, flat rates for 25 or fewer employees, plan contents and billing options are published, but add-on prices and any in-product billing detail are not.",
   "fit_a": 7,
   "fit_b": 5,
   "fit_reason_a": "Multi-entity, multi-country and granular security groups with approvers by role are documented, but only one summary source and no custom fields or language detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom tabs, tables and fields, role visibility, eight languages and localized settings are listed, mostly by marketing, with only a beta MCP docs page and no multi-entity detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "BambooHR 5.7 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Workday 6.1 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Workday 6.1 to 5.6.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Workday 6.0 to 5.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Workday 5.7 to 5.6."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Workday vs HiBob",
   "a": "Workday",
   "b": "HiBob",
   "total_a": "5.7",
   "total_b": "5.6",
   "winner": "Workday",
   "margin": "0.1",
   "build_a": 5,
   "build_b": 5,
   "build_reason_a": "Agent & App Builder and Developer Agent build apps and agents in plain language and business process templates, triggers and conditions exist, but the builders target developers and prompt-built business processes are not documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "No-code workflows with conditional logic and branching, lifecycle triggers and natural-language analytics are described, but only on marketing pages and with the AI builder not yet available.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 5,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents draft and execute within guardrails, with human review of sensitive actions, sandboxed what-ifs, an Agent System of Record with auditability and identity-scoped data safeguards, but comp cycle and offboarding agents and a single off switch are not documented.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Human approval of write actions, an admin AI off switch, role-bound access and MCP AI logs are stated, but only on marketing pages and with no whole-process agent or detailed agent audit log.",
   "openness_a": 6,
   "openness_b": 8,
   "openness_reason_a": "Official MCP tools with write actions for Claude, Gemini, OpenAI and Copilot and webhooks are documented, but only by vendor pages with no release stage, plan or audit detail.",
   "openness_reason_b": "An official MCP server with read and write where permitted, admin controls, logs, several named clients and a public API with webhooks are documented, with minor gaps on plan and audit detail.",
   "ttv_a": 6,
   "ttv_b": 5,
   "ttv_reason_a": "Published 10 to 20 plus week go-live, fixed price with prescribed scope, and a what-if sandbox are documented, but only on one vendor page and no amount is published.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A weeks-not-months claim, a separately sold sandbox and implementation fees in partner terms are documented, but no fee amount or guided implementation detail.",
   "pricing_a": 2,
   "pricing_b": 3,
   "pricing_reason_a": "The Flex Credits usage model with top-ups and complimentary credits is described on a marketing page only, with no prices, plan contents or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Core contents and a per-employee pricing basis with separate modules are described by marketing pages, but no amounts and the minimum is only set in the Order Form.",
   "fit_a": 7,
   "fit_b": 8,
   "fit_reason_a": "Multi-entity, multi-country and granular security groups with approvers by role are documented, but only one summary source and no custom fields or language detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields and tables, group-based permissions, policy visibility settings, location policies and multi-entity are documented, with language support from marketing only and no per-policy approver choice.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "HiBob 5.4 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Workday 6.1 to 6.0.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "HiBob 6.3 to 6.1.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Workday 6.0 to 5.9.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Workday 5.7 to 5.5."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Workday vs Lattice",
   "a": "Workday",
   "b": "Lattice",
   "total_a": "5.7",
   "total_b": "5.5",
   "winner": "Workday",
   "margin": "0.2",
   "build_a": 5,
   "build_b": 4,
   "build_reason_a": "Agent & App Builder and Developer Agent build apps and agents in plain language and business process templates, triggers and conditions exist, but the builders target developers and prompt-built business processes are not documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Docs show admin-built custom reports shared with chosen employees and scheduled exports, adding to limited-beta AI and review rules, but there is no prompt-built report or flow.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 5,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents draft and execute within guardrails, with human review of sensitive actions, sandboxed what-ifs, an Agent System of Record with auditability and identity-scoped data safeguards, but comp cycle and offboarding agents and a single off switch are not documented.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Docs show a full AI off switch, opt-in per feature, draft review before actions, sensitive-field roles and an agent dashboard log with gaps, but the agent takes single actions and runs no whole process.",
   "openness_a": 6,
   "openness_b": 7,
   "openness_reason_a": "Official MCP tools with write actions for Claude, Gemini, OpenAI and Copilot and webhooks are documented, but only by vendor pages with no release stage, plan or audit detail.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server with read and write scopes, same permissions, a Claude directory connector with a read-only option, a public API and SCIM, but no webhooks and API write-back limited to goals.",
   "ttv_a": 6,
   "ttv_b": 7,
   "ttv_reason_a": "Published 10 to 20 plus week go-live, fixed price with prescribed scope, and a what-if sandbox are documented, but only on one vendor page and no amount is published.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A sandbox on request adds the one element the current reason lacked, which puts it level with or above another platform at 7 with no sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 2,
   "pricing_b": 7,
   "pricing_reason_a": "The Flex Credits usage model with top-ups and complimentary credits is described on a marketing page only, with no prices, plan contents or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Per-seat prices for each talent module and add-on and a $4,000 minimum annual agreement are published, but the HRIS is unpriced, enterprise is by quote and in-product billing is not shown.",
   "fit_a": 7,
   "fit_b": 6,
   "fit_reason_a": "Multi-entity, multi-country and granular security groups with approvers by role are documented, but only one summary source and no custom fields or language detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields, targeted custom roles with per-field permissions, 24 languages and multi-currency compensation cycles are documented, but there is no multi-entity or per-office policy and the HRIS is a US limited beta.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Lattice 6.0 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Workday 6.1 to 5.6.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Workday 6.1 to 6.0.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Workday 6.0 to 5.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Lattice 5.9 to 5.7."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Workday vs Personio",
   "a": "Workday",
   "b": "Personio",
   "total_a": "5.7",
   "total_b": "5.4",
   "winner": "Workday",
   "margin": "0.3",
   "build_a": 5,
   "build_b": 6,
   "build_reason_a": "Agent & App Builder and Developer Agent build apps and agents in plain language and business process templates, triggers and conditions exist, but the builders target developers and prompt-built business processes are not documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Docs show a no-code workflow builder with templates, conditions and draft or activate, and a Report Builder with permission-respecting data, but natural-language workflow building and a library of built items are not documented.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents draft and execute within guardrails, with human review of sensitive actions, sandboxed what-ifs, an Agent System of Record with auditability and identity-scoped data safeguards, but comp cycle and offboarding agents and a single off switch are not documented.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Docs add central and per-feature AI off switches with a spend limit, advisory-only screening, audited MCP setting changes and hidden person attributes, but no process-running agent or agent audit log.",
   "openness_a": 6,
   "openness_b": 6,
   "openness_reason_a": "Official MCP tools with write actions for Claude, Gemini, OpenAI and Copilot and webhooks are documented, but only by vendor pages with no release stage, plan or audit detail.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented official MCP server (beta, Core Pro) with read, opt-in write, per-tool switches and named clients, a webhooks API and Slack and Teams integrations, but beta status and the Core Pro API restriction limit it.",
   "ttv_a": 6,
   "ttv_b": 6,
   "ttv_reason_a": "Published 10 to 20 plus week go-live, fixed price with prescribed scope, and a what-if sandbox are documented, but only on one vendor page and no amount is published.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A guided Implementation Specialist, phased payroll implementation, a 14-day trial, import tools and a one-time fee are documented, but no timeline or amount and the sandbox is on a paid support plan.",
   "pricing_a": 2,
   "pricing_b": 3,
   "pricing_reason_a": "The Flex Credits usage model with top-ups and complimentary credits is described on a marketing page only, with no prices, plan contents or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Three plans with contents, named add-ons and a 12-month minimum run-time are published, but no prices and no implementation amount (a third-party figure is only a weak hint).",
   "fit_a": 7,
   "fit_b": 8,
   "fit_reason_a": "Multi-entity, multi-country and granular security groups with approvers by role are documented, but only one summary source and no custom fields or language detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Unlimited entities, permissions, custom attributes, per-process approvers, per-workplace currency and per-user language are documented in docs, with policies per office not shown.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Personio 5.4 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Workday 6.1 to 5.8.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Workday 6.1 to 6.0.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Workday 6.0 to 5.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Workday 5.7 to 5.5."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Workday vs Deel",
   "a": "Workday",
   "b": "Deel",
   "total_a": "5.7",
   "total_b": "5.2",
   "winner": "Workday",
   "margin": "0.5",
   "build_a": 5,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "Agent & App Builder and Developer Agent build apps and agents in plain language and business process templates, triggers and conditions exist, but the builders target developers and prompt-built business processes are not documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "A no-code workflow builder with triggers, filters, conditions, delay steps and a simulation tool is described on a marketing page, but building by description and sharing are not documented.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 5,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents draft and execute within guardrails, with human review of sensitive actions, sandboxed what-ifs, an Agent System of Record with auditability and identity-scoped data safeguards, but comp cycle and offboarding agents and a single off switch are not documented.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Agentic workflows from triggers with human approval and logged actions cover about as many elements as another platform at 5, also on one marketing page, so 4 understates it.",
   "openness_a": 6,
   "openness_b": 8,
   "openness_reason_a": "Official MCP tools with write actions for Claude, Gemini, OpenAI and Copilot and webhooks are documented, but only by vendor pages with no release stage, plan or audit detail.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented official MCP server with read and write OAuth scopes checked per call, signed webhooks with retries, REST API and named AI clients, with gaps on plan detail and audit.",
   "ttv_a": 6,
   "ttv_b": 6,
   "ttv_reason_a": "Published 10 to 20 plus week go-live, fixed price with prescribed scope, and a what-if sandbox are documented, but only on one vendor page and no amount is published.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A weeks-not-months claim, described implementation steps with an onboarding manager and a documented API sandbox, but no fee and the claim is marketing only.",
   "pricing_a": 2,
   "pricing_b": 6,
   "pricing_reason_a": "The Flex Credits usage model with top-ups and complimentary credits is described on a marketing page only, with no prices, plan contents or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Core from $5 per employee per month, contents of three tiers, and EOR, PEO, contractor, payroll and IT prices are published with month-to-month terms, but Advanced, Elite and recruiting prices are not.",
   "fit_a": 7,
   "fit_b": 6,
   "fit_reason_a": "Multi-entity, multi-country and granular security groups with approvers by role are documented, but only one summary source and no custom fields or language detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Multi-country entities, job architecture, country time off policies and approvals plus payment in 120+ currencies are documented, but no custom fields, roles or per-policy approvers.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Deel 5.5 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Workday 6.1 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Workday 6.1 to 5.8; Deel is the specialist for payroll in 150 countries inside the HRIS.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Workday 6.0 to 5.3.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Workday 5.7 to 5.5."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Workday vs Gusto",
   "a": "Workday",
   "b": "Gusto",
   "total_a": "5.7",
   "total_b": "4.1",
   "winner": "Workday",
   "margin": "1.6",
   "build_a": 5,
   "build_b": 1,
   "build_reason_a": "Agent & App Builder and Developer Agent build apps and agents in plain language and business process templates, triggers and conditions exist, but the builders target developers and prompt-built business processes are not documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Reports and AI suggestions with onboarding templates and employee tasks, but no natural-language builder, any-field triggers or conditions found.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents draft and execute within guardrails, with human review of sensitive actions, sandboxed what-ifs, an Agent System of Record with auditability and identity-scoped data safeguards, but comp cycle and offboarding agents and a single off switch are not documented.",
   "agents_reason_b": "MCP writes come back for confirmation and admins choose data categories, but there is no HR agent running processes, no audit statement and only partial off-switch controls.",
   "openness_a": 6,
   "openness_b": 6,
   "openness_reason_a": "Official MCP tools with write actions for Claude, Gemini, OpenAI and Copilot and webhooks are documented, but only by vendor pages with no release stage, plan or audit detail.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server for customers exists, but the public API and webhooks are restricted to partners and the developer MCP server is beta.",
   "ttv_a": 6,
   "ttv_b": 7,
   "ttv_reason_a": "Published 10 to 20 plus week go-live, fixed price with prescribed scope, and a what-if sandbox are documented, but only on one vendor page and no amount is published.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "No setup fee, guided setup included and self-serve are documented across two sources, but no timeline or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 2,
   "pricing_b": 9,
   "pricing_reason_a": "The Flex Credits usage model with top-ups and complimentary credits is described on a marketing page only, with no prices, plan contents or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Base and per-person prices for three plans, priced add-ons and month-to-month terms with no plan minimum are published; in-product billing is not documented.",
   "fit_a": 7,
   "fit_b": 3,
   "fit_reason_a": "Multi-entity, multi-country and granular security groups with approvers by role are documented, but only one summary source and no custom fields or language detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields through the API, time off approvals and report filters by department and address are documented, with no multi-entity, currency or language detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Workday 5.4 to 5.0.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Workday 6.1 to 3.9.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Workday 6.1 to 4.3.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Workday 6.0 to 3.8.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Workday 5.7 to 4.8."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Workday vs Paylocity",
   "a": "Workday",
   "b": "Paylocity",
   "total_a": "5.7",
   "total_b": "3.3",
   "winner": "Workday",
   "margin": "2.4",
   "build_a": 5,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "Agent & App Builder and Developer Agent build apps and agents in plain language and business process templates, triggers and conditions exist, but the builders target developers and prompt-built business processes are not documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Ready-made and custom workflow templates with filters, conditional routing, manager creation rights and progress dashboards are described on a marketing page, but no natural-language builder is documented.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents draft and execute within guardrails, with human review of sensitive actions, sandboxed what-ifs, an Agent System of Record with auditability and identity-scoped data safeguards, but comp cycle and offboarding agents and a single off switch are not documented.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Purpose-built agents for onboarding, payroll and expenses with an enable choice and monitoring of actions are described on a marketing page, but no approval step, audit log or field-level control is stated.",
   "openness_a": 6,
   "openness_b": 3,
   "openness_reason_a": "Official MCP tools with write actions for Claude, Gemini, OpenAI and Copilot and webhooks are documented, but only by vendor pages with no release stage, plan or audit detail.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server exists but only for API documentation, and webhooks and developer access are limited to early adopters, partners or custom-integration agreements.",
   "ttv_a": 6,
   "ttv_b": 2,
   "ttv_reason_a": "Published 10 to 20 plus week go-live, fixed price with prescribed scope, and a what-if sandbox are documented, but only on one vendor page and no amount is published.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A 4 to 16 week integration estimate and a sandbox for approved customers and partners are documented, but nothing on HR platform go-live, fee or guided implementation.",
   "pricing_a": 2,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "The Flex Credits usage model with top-ups and complimentary credits is described on a marketing page only, with no prices, plan contents or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Contents are listed by module, but there are no prices, tiers or minimum, only a request for pricing through a demo.",
   "fit_a": 7,
   "fit_b": 5,
   "fit_reason_a": "Multi-entity, multi-country and granular security groups with approvers by role are documented, but only one summary source and no custom fields or language detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Unlimited custom fields, location-based workflow filters and global payroll currencies are described, but only by marketing pages, with no entity or role detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Workday 5.4 to 3.1.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Workday 6.1 to 3.6.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Workday 6.1 to 3.7.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Workday 6.0 to 3.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Workday 5.7 to 3.2."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Workday vs ADP",
   "a": "Workday",
   "b": "ADP",
   "total_a": "5.7",
   "total_b": "2.8",
   "winner": "Workday",
   "margin": "2.9",
   "build_a": 5,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "Agent & App Builder and Developer Agent build apps and agents in plain language and business process templates, triggers and conditions exist, but the builders target developers and prompt-built business processes are not documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Drag and drop report building with sharing and a prebuilt report library are described, plus guided workflows, but only on marketing pages and with no natural-language building or admin-editable triggers.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 2,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents draft and execute within guardrails, with human review of sensitive actions, sandboxed what-ifs, an Agent System of Record with auditability and identity-scoped data safeguards, but comp cycle and offboarding agents and a single off switch are not documented.",
   "agents_reason_b": "A virtual assistant answers HR questions and role-based access exists, but no process agent, approval model, audit log or off switch is documented.",
   "openness_a": 6,
   "openness_b": 3,
   "openness_reason_a": "Official MCP tools with write actions for Claude, Gemini, OpenAI and Copilot and webhooks are documented, but only by vendor pages with no release stage, plan or audit detail.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Docs-type developer pages show HR, time and payroll APIs with OAuth 2.0, but API Central is a separate purchase, the MCP mention is marketing only, and no webhooks were found.",
   "ttv_a": 6,
   "ttv_b": 3,
   "ttv_reason_a": "Published 10 to 20 plus week go-live, fixed price with prescribed scope, and a what-if sandbox are documented, but only on one vendor page and no amount is published.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "An implementation team and Client Success Executive from day one are named, with no timeline, fee or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 2,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "The Flex Credits usage model with top-ups and complimentary credits is described on a marketing page only, with no prices, plan contents or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Three package names with contents are published, but every tier is Get Pricing with no amounts, add-on prices or minimum.",
   "fit_a": 7,
   "fit_b": 4,
   "fit_reason_a": "Multi-entity, multi-country and granular security groups with approvers by role are documented, but only one summary source and no custom fields or language detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Role approvals, time off policies and multi-country support with a customizable portal are described, but mostly by marketing pages and with no custom fields or entity detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Workday 5.4 to 2.9.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Workday 6.1 to 3.0.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Workday 6.1 to 3.2.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Workday 6.0 to 2.9.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Workday 5.7 to 2.9."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Workday vs Sage",
   "a": "Workday",
   "b": "Sage",
   "total_a": "5.7",
   "total_b": "2.2",
   "winner": "Workday",
   "margin": "3.5",
   "build_a": 5,
   "build_b": 1,
   "build_reason_a": "Agent & App Builder and Developer Agent build apps and agents in plain language and business process templates, triggers and conditions exist, but the builders target developers and prompt-built business processes are not documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Reports and checklist templates with employee task lists, but no natural-language builder, triggers or conditions found and only one source.",
   "agents_a": 7,
   "agents_b": 1,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agents draft and execute within guardrails, with human review of sensitive actions, sandboxed what-ifs, an Agent System of Record with auditability and identity-scoped data safeguards, but comp cycle and offboarding agents and a single off switch are not documented.",
   "agents_reason_b": "No agent, approval model, audit log or AI off switch was found; only permission levels are mentioned.",
   "openness_a": 6,
   "openness_b": 2,
   "openness_reason_a": "Official MCP tools with write actions for Claude, Gemini, OpenAI and Copilot and webhooks are documented, but only by vendor pages with no release stage, plan or audit detail.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Only a Sage API was found, with no MCP server, no webhooks and no AI integrations.",
   "ttv_a": 6,
   "ttv_b": 4,
   "ttv_reason_a": "Published 10 to 20 plus week go-live, fixed price with prescribed scope, and a what-if sandbox are documented, but only on one vendor page and no amount is published.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A 30-day free trial and modular self-serve setup are documented, with implementation through partners and no fee, timeline or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 2,
   "pricing_b": 7,
   "pricing_reason_a": "The Flex Credits usage model with top-ups and complimentary credits is described on a marketing page only, with no prices, plan contents or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Per-employee module prices and priced add-ons are published for the US, but no minimum is stated, the enterprise product is by quote and in-product billing is not shown.",
   "fit_a": 7,
   "fit_b": 2,
   "fit_reason_a": "Multi-entity, multi-country and granular security groups with approvers by role are documented, but only one summary source and no custom fields or language detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Leave policies and manager approvals are documented, but multi-entity and multi-country configuration are not shown as available.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Workday 5.4 to 3.3.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Workday 6.1 to 2.2.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Workday 6.1 to 2.8.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Workday 6.0 to 2.0.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Workday 5.7 to 3.0."
  },
  {
   "bout": "BambooHR vs HiBob",
   "a": "BambooHR",
   "b": "HiBob",
   "total_a": "5.6",
   "total_b": "5.6",
   "winner": "BambooHR",
   "margin": "0.0",
   "build_a": 4,
   "build_b": 5,
   "build_reason_a": "Custom reports built and refined from a prompt but several capabilities are beta or coming soon, custom dashboards need Elite, and prompt-built flows and conditional tasks are not documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "No-code workflows with conditional logic and branching, lifecycle triggers and natural-language analytics are described, but only on marketing pages and with the AI builder not yet available.",
   "agents_a": 6,
   "agents_b": 5,
   "agents_reason_a": "Prepared work goes through the appropriate person, the Audit Trail records agent changes and admins can turn the feature off, but onboarding and comp cycle agents are absent, several items are beta or coming soon, and sensitive-field controls are not named.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Human approval of write actions, an admin AI off switch, role-bound access and MCP AI logs are stated, but only on marketing pages and with no whole-process agent or detailed agent audit log.",
   "openness_a": 7,
   "openness_b": 8,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented beta MCP server with OAuth 2.0, read and write tools and admin access control, plus signed webhooks and a public API, with beta status and no dynamic client registration as limits.",
   "openness_reason_b": "An official MCP server with read and write where permitted, admin controls, logs, several named clients and a public API with webhooks are documented, with minor gaps on plan and audit detail.",
   "ttv_a": 5,
   "ttv_b": 5,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A free trial, 30 extra implementation days on Elite, a dedicated payroll project manager and self-serve setup are documented, but no amount, timeline or customer sandbox.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A weeks-not-months claim, a separately sold sandbox and implementation fees in partner terms are documented, but no fee amount or guided implementation detail.",
   "pricing_a": 8,
   "pricing_b": 3,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Per-employee prices for Core, Pro and Elite, flat rates for 25 or fewer employees, plan contents and billing options are published, but add-on prices and any in-product billing detail are not.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Core contents and a per-employee pricing basis with separate modules are described by marketing pages, but no amounts and the minimum is only set in the Order Form.",
   "fit_a": 5,
   "fit_b": 8,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom tabs, tables and fields, role visibility, eight languages and localized settings are listed, mostly by marketing, with only a beta MCP docs page and no multi-entity detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields and tables, group-based permissions, policy visibility settings, location policies and multi-entity are documented, with language support from marketing only and no per-policy approver choice.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "BambooHR 5.7 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "HiBob 6.0 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "HiBob 6.3 to 5.6.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "HiBob 5.9 to 5.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "BambooHR 5.6 to 5.5."
  },
  {
   "bout": "BambooHR vs Lattice",
   "a": "BambooHR",
   "b": "Lattice",
   "total_a": "5.6",
   "total_b": "5.5",
   "winner": "BambooHR",
   "margin": "0.1",
   "build_a": 4,
   "build_b": 4,
   "build_reason_a": "Custom reports built and refined from a prompt but several capabilities are beta or coming soon, custom dashboards need Elite, and prompt-built flows and conditional tasks are not documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Docs show admin-built custom reports shared with chosen employees and scheduled exports, adding to limited-beta AI and review rules, but there is no prompt-built report or flow.",
   "agents_a": 6,
   "agents_b": 5,
   "agents_reason_a": "Prepared work goes through the appropriate person, the Audit Trail records agent changes and admins can turn the feature off, but onboarding and comp cycle agents are absent, several items are beta or coming soon, and sensitive-field controls are not named.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Docs show a full AI off switch, opt-in per feature, draft review before actions, sensitive-field roles and an agent dashboard log with gaps, but the agent takes single actions and runs no whole process.",
   "openness_a": 7,
   "openness_b": 7,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented beta MCP server with OAuth 2.0, read and write tools and admin access control, plus signed webhooks and a public API, with beta status and no dynamic client registration as limits.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server with read and write scopes, same permissions, a Claude directory connector with a read-only option, a public API and SCIM, but no webhooks and API write-back limited to goals.",
   "ttv_a": 5,
   "ttv_b": 7,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A free trial, 30 extra implementation days on Elite, a dedicated payroll project manager and self-serve setup are documented, but no amount, timeline or customer sandbox.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A sandbox on request adds the one element the current reason lacked, which puts it level with or above another platform at 7 with no sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 8,
   "pricing_b": 7,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Per-employee prices for Core, Pro and Elite, flat rates for 25 or fewer employees, plan contents and billing options are published, but add-on prices and any in-product billing detail are not.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Per-seat prices for each talent module and add-on and a $4,000 minimum annual agreement are published, but the HRIS is unpriced, enterprise is by quote and in-product billing is not shown.",
   "fit_a": 5,
   "fit_b": 6,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom tabs, tables and fields, role visibility, eight languages and localized settings are listed, mostly by marketing, with only a beta MCP docs page and no multi-entity detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields, targeted custom roles with per-field permissions, 24 languages and multi-currency compensation cycles are documented, but there is no multi-entity or per-office policy and the HRIS is a US limited beta.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Lattice 6.0 to 5.7.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Lattice 5.6 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Lattice 6.0 to 5.6.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "BambooHR 5.5 to 5.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Lattice 5.9 to 5.6."
  },
  {
   "bout": "BambooHR vs Personio",
   "a": "BambooHR",
   "b": "Personio",
   "total_a": "5.6",
   "total_b": "5.4",
   "winner": "BambooHR",
   "margin": "0.2",
   "build_a": 4,
   "build_b": 6,
   "build_reason_a": "Custom reports built and refined from a prompt but several capabilities are beta or coming soon, custom dashboards need Elite, and prompt-built flows and conditional tasks are not documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Docs show a no-code workflow builder with templates, conditions and draft or activate, and a Report Builder with permission-respecting data, but natural-language workflow building and a library of built items are not documented.",
   "agents_a": 6,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Prepared work goes through the appropriate person, the Audit Trail records agent changes and admins can turn the feature off, but onboarding and comp cycle agents are absent, several items are beta or coming soon, and sensitive-field controls are not named.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Docs add central and per-feature AI off switches with a spend limit, advisory-only screening, audited MCP setting changes and hidden person attributes, but no process-running agent or agent audit log.",
   "openness_a": 7,
   "openness_b": 6,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented beta MCP server with OAuth 2.0, read and write tools and admin access control, plus signed webhooks and a public API, with beta status and no dynamic client registration as limits.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented official MCP server (beta, Core Pro) with read, opt-in write, per-tool switches and named clients, a webhooks API and Slack and Teams integrations, but beta status and the Core Pro API restriction limit it.",
   "ttv_a": 5,
   "ttv_b": 6,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A free trial, 30 extra implementation days on Elite, a dedicated payroll project manager and self-serve setup are documented, but no amount, timeline or customer sandbox.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A guided Implementation Specialist, phased payroll implementation, a 14-day trial, import tools and a one-time fee are documented, but no timeline or amount and the sandbox is on a paid support plan.",
   "pricing_a": 8,
   "pricing_b": 3,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Per-employee prices for Core, Pro and Elite, flat rates for 25 or fewer employees, plan contents and billing options are published, but add-on prices and any in-product billing detail are not.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Three plans with contents, named add-ons and a 12-month minimum run-time are published, but no prices and no implementation amount (a third-party figure is only a weak hint).",
   "fit_a": 5,
   "fit_b": 8,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom tabs, tables and fields, role visibility, eight languages and localized settings are listed, mostly by marketing, with only a beta MCP docs page and no multi-entity detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Unlimited entities, permissions, custom attributes, per-process approvers, per-workplace currency and per-user language are documented in docs, with policies per office not shown.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "BambooHR 5.7 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Personio 5.8 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Personio 6.0 to 5.6.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "BambooHR 5.5 to 5.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "BambooHR 5.6 to 5.5."
  },
  {
   "bout": "BambooHR vs Deel",
   "a": "BambooHR",
   "b": "Deel",
   "total_a": "5.6",
   "total_b": "5.2",
   "winner": "BambooHR",
   "margin": "0.4",
   "build_a": 4,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "Custom reports built and refined from a prompt but several capabilities are beta or coming soon, custom dashboards need Elite, and prompt-built flows and conditional tasks are not documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "A no-code workflow builder with triggers, filters, conditions, delay steps and a simulation tool is described on a marketing page, but building by description and sharing are not documented.",
   "agents_a": 6,
   "agents_b": 5,
   "agents_reason_a": "Prepared work goes through the appropriate person, the Audit Trail records agent changes and admins can turn the feature off, but onboarding and comp cycle agents are absent, several items are beta or coming soon, and sensitive-field controls are not named.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Agentic workflows from triggers with human approval and logged actions cover about as many elements as another platform at 5, also on one marketing page, so 4 understates it.",
   "openness_a": 7,
   "openness_b": 8,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented beta MCP server with OAuth 2.0, read and write tools and admin access control, plus signed webhooks and a public API, with beta status and no dynamic client registration as limits.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented official MCP server with read and write OAuth scopes checked per call, signed webhooks with retries, REST API and named AI clients, with gaps on plan detail and audit.",
   "ttv_a": 5,
   "ttv_b": 6,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A free trial, 30 extra implementation days on Elite, a dedicated payroll project manager and self-serve setup are documented, but no amount, timeline or customer sandbox.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A weeks-not-months claim, described implementation steps with an onboarding manager and a documented API sandbox, but no fee and the claim is marketing only.",
   "pricing_a": 8,
   "pricing_b": 6,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Per-employee prices for Core, Pro and Elite, flat rates for 25 or fewer employees, plan contents and billing options are published, but add-on prices and any in-product billing detail are not.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Core from $5 per employee per month, contents of three tiers, and EOR, PEO, contractor, payroll and IT prices are published with month-to-month terms, but Advanced, Elite and recruiting prices are not.",
   "fit_a": 5,
   "fit_b": 6,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom tabs, tables and fields, role visibility, eight languages and localized settings are listed, mostly by marketing, with only a beta MCP docs page and no multi-entity detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Multi-country entities, job architecture, country time off policies and approvals plus payment in 120+ currencies are documented, but no custom fields, roles or per-policy approvers.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "BambooHR 5.7 to 5.5.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "BambooHR 5.4 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Deel 5.8 to 5.6.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "BambooHR 5.5 to 5.3.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "BambooHR 5.6 to 5.5."
  },
  {
   "bout": "BambooHR vs Gusto",
   "a": "BambooHR",
   "b": "Gusto",
   "total_a": "5.6",
   "total_b": "4.1",
   "winner": "BambooHR",
   "margin": "1.5",
   "build_a": 4,
   "build_b": 1,
   "build_reason_a": "Custom reports built and refined from a prompt but several capabilities are beta or coming soon, custom dashboards need Elite, and prompt-built flows and conditional tasks are not documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Reports and AI suggestions with onboarding templates and employee tasks, but no natural-language builder, any-field triggers or conditions found.",
   "agents_a": 6,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Prepared work goes through the appropriate person, the Audit Trail records agent changes and admins can turn the feature off, but onboarding and comp cycle agents are absent, several items are beta or coming soon, and sensitive-field controls are not named.",
   "agents_reason_b": "MCP writes come back for confirmation and admins choose data categories, but there is no HR agent running processes, no audit statement and only partial off-switch controls.",
   "openness_a": 7,
   "openness_b": 6,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented beta MCP server with OAuth 2.0, read and write tools and admin access control, plus signed webhooks and a public API, with beta status and no dynamic client registration as limits.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server for customers exists, but the public API and webhooks are restricted to partners and the developer MCP server is beta.",
   "ttv_a": 5,
   "ttv_b": 7,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A free trial, 30 extra implementation days on Elite, a dedicated payroll project manager and self-serve setup are documented, but no amount, timeline or customer sandbox.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "No setup fee, guided setup included and self-serve are documented across two sources, but no timeline or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 8,
   "pricing_b": 9,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Per-employee prices for Core, Pro and Elite, flat rates for 25 or fewer employees, plan contents and billing options are published, but add-on prices and any in-product billing detail are not.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Base and per-person prices for three plans, priced add-ons and month-to-month terms with no plan minimum are published; in-product billing is not documented.",
   "fit_a": 5,
   "fit_b": 3,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom tabs, tables and fields, role visibility, eight languages and localized settings are listed, mostly by marketing, with only a beta MCP docs page and no multi-entity detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields through the API, time off approvals and report filters by department and address are documented, with no multi-entity, currency or language detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "BambooHR 5.7 to 5.0.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "BambooHR 5.4 to 3.9.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "BambooHR 5.6 to 4.3.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "BambooHR 5.5 to 3.8.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "BambooHR 5.6 to 4.8."
  },
  {
   "bout": "BambooHR vs Paylocity",
   "a": "BambooHR",
   "b": "Paylocity",
   "total_a": "5.6",
   "total_b": "3.3",
   "winner": "BambooHR",
   "margin": "2.3",
   "build_a": 4,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "Custom reports built and refined from a prompt but several capabilities are beta or coming soon, custom dashboards need Elite, and prompt-built flows and conditional tasks are not documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Ready-made and custom workflow templates with filters, conditional routing, manager creation rights and progress dashboards are described on a marketing page, but no natural-language builder is documented.",
   "agents_a": 6,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Prepared work goes through the appropriate person, the Audit Trail records agent changes and admins can turn the feature off, but onboarding and comp cycle agents are absent, several items are beta or coming soon, and sensitive-field controls are not named.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Purpose-built agents for onboarding, payroll and expenses with an enable choice and monitoring of actions are described on a marketing page, but no approval step, audit log or field-level control is stated.",
   "openness_a": 7,
   "openness_b": 3,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented beta MCP server with OAuth 2.0, read and write tools and admin access control, plus signed webhooks and a public API, with beta status and no dynamic client registration as limits.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server exists but only for API documentation, and webhooks and developer access are limited to early adopters, partners or custom-integration agreements.",
   "ttv_a": 5,
   "ttv_b": 2,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A free trial, 30 extra implementation days on Elite, a dedicated payroll project manager and self-serve setup are documented, but no amount, timeline or customer sandbox.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A 4 to 16 week integration estimate and a sandbox for approved customers and partners are documented, but nothing on HR platform go-live, fee or guided implementation.",
   "pricing_a": 8,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Per-employee prices for Core, Pro and Elite, flat rates for 25 or fewer employees, plan contents and billing options are published, but add-on prices and any in-product billing detail are not.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Contents are listed by module, but there are no prices, tiers or minimum, only a request for pricing through a demo.",
   "fit_a": 5,
   "fit_b": 5,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom tabs, tables and fields, role visibility, eight languages and localized settings are listed, mostly by marketing, with only a beta MCP docs page and no multi-entity detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Unlimited custom fields, location-based workflow filters and global payroll currencies are described, but only by marketing pages, with no entity or role detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "BambooHR 5.7 to 3.1.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "BambooHR 5.4 to 3.6.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "BambooHR 5.6 to 3.7.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "BambooHR 5.5 to 3.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "BambooHR 5.6 to 3.2."
  },
  {
   "bout": "BambooHR vs ADP",
   "a": "BambooHR",
   "b": "ADP",
   "total_a": "5.6",
   "total_b": "2.8",
   "winner": "BambooHR",
   "margin": "2.8",
   "build_a": 4,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "Custom reports built and refined from a prompt but several capabilities are beta or coming soon, custom dashboards need Elite, and prompt-built flows and conditional tasks are not documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Drag and drop report building with sharing and a prebuilt report library are described, plus guided workflows, but only on marketing pages and with no natural-language building or admin-editable triggers.",
   "agents_a": 6,
   "agents_b": 2,
   "agents_reason_a": "Prepared work goes through the appropriate person, the Audit Trail records agent changes and admins can turn the feature off, but onboarding and comp cycle agents are absent, several items are beta or coming soon, and sensitive-field controls are not named.",
   "agents_reason_b": "A virtual assistant answers HR questions and role-based access exists, but no process agent, approval model, audit log or off switch is documented.",
   "openness_a": 7,
   "openness_b": 3,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented beta MCP server with OAuth 2.0, read and write tools and admin access control, plus signed webhooks and a public API, with beta status and no dynamic client registration as limits.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Docs-type developer pages show HR, time and payroll APIs with OAuth 2.0, but API Central is a separate purchase, the MCP mention is marketing only, and no webhooks were found.",
   "ttv_a": 5,
   "ttv_b": 3,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A free trial, 30 extra implementation days on Elite, a dedicated payroll project manager and self-serve setup are documented, but no amount, timeline or customer sandbox.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "An implementation team and Client Success Executive from day one are named, with no timeline, fee or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 8,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Per-employee prices for Core, Pro and Elite, flat rates for 25 or fewer employees, plan contents and billing options are published, but add-on prices and any in-product billing detail are not.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Three package names with contents are published, but every tier is Get Pricing with no amounts, add-on prices or minimum.",
   "fit_a": 5,
   "fit_b": 4,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom tabs, tables and fields, role visibility, eight languages and localized settings are listed, mostly by marketing, with only a beta MCP docs page and no multi-entity detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Role approvals, time off policies and multi-country support with a customizable portal are described, but mostly by marketing pages and with no custom fields or entity detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "BambooHR 5.7 to 2.9.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "BambooHR 5.4 to 3.0.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "BambooHR 5.6 to 3.2.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "BambooHR 5.5 to 2.9.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "BambooHR 5.6 to 2.9."
  },
  {
   "bout": "BambooHR vs Sage",
   "a": "BambooHR",
   "b": "Sage",
   "total_a": "5.6",
   "total_b": "2.2",
   "winner": "BambooHR",
   "margin": "3.4",
   "build_a": 4,
   "build_b": 1,
   "build_reason_a": "Custom reports built and refined from a prompt but several capabilities are beta or coming soon, custom dashboards need Elite, and prompt-built flows and conditional tasks are not documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Reports and checklist templates with employee task lists, but no natural-language builder, triggers or conditions found and only one source.",
   "agents_a": 6,
   "agents_b": 1,
   "agents_reason_a": "Prepared work goes through the appropriate person, the Audit Trail records agent changes and admins can turn the feature off, but onboarding and comp cycle agents are absent, several items are beta or coming soon, and sensitive-field controls are not named.",
   "agents_reason_b": "No agent, approval model, audit log or AI off switch was found; only permission levels are mentioned.",
   "openness_a": 7,
   "openness_b": 2,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented beta MCP server with OAuth 2.0, read and write tools and admin access control, plus signed webhooks and a public API, with beta status and no dynamic client registration as limits.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Only a Sage API was found, with no MCP server, no webhooks and no AI integrations.",
   "ttv_a": 5,
   "ttv_b": 4,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A free trial, 30 extra implementation days on Elite, a dedicated payroll project manager and self-serve setup are documented, but no amount, timeline or customer sandbox.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A 30-day free trial and modular self-serve setup are documented, with implementation through partners and no fee, timeline or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 8,
   "pricing_b": 7,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Per-employee prices for Core, Pro and Elite, flat rates for 25 or fewer employees, plan contents and billing options are published, but add-on prices and any in-product billing detail are not.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Per-employee module prices and priced add-ons are published for the US, but no minimum is stated, the enterprise product is by quote and in-product billing is not shown.",
   "fit_a": 5,
   "fit_b": 2,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom tabs, tables and fields, role visibility, eight languages and localized settings are listed, mostly by marketing, with only a beta MCP docs page and no multi-entity detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Leave policies and manager approvals are documented, but multi-entity and multi-country configuration are not shown as available.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "BambooHR 5.7 to 3.3.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "BambooHR 5.4 to 2.2.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "BambooHR 5.6 to 2.8.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "BambooHR 5.5 to 2.0.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "BambooHR 5.6 to 3.0."
  },
  {
   "bout": "HiBob vs Lattice",
   "a": "HiBob",
   "b": "Lattice",
   "total_a": "5.6",
   "total_b": "5.5",
   "winner": "HiBob",
   "margin": "0.1",
   "build_a": 5,
   "build_b": 4,
   "build_reason_a": "No-code workflows with conditional logic and branching, lifecycle triggers and natural-language analytics are described, but only on marketing pages and with the AI builder not yet available.",
   "build_reason_b": "Docs show admin-built custom reports shared with chosen employees and scheduled exports, adding to limited-beta AI and review rules, but there is no prompt-built report or flow.",
   "agents_a": 5,
   "agents_b": 5,
   "agents_reason_a": "Human approval of write actions, an admin AI off switch, role-bound access and MCP AI logs are stated, but only on marketing pages and with no whole-process agent or detailed agent audit log.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Docs show a full AI off switch, opt-in per feature, draft review before actions, sensitive-field roles and an agent dashboard log with gaps, but the agent takes single actions and runs no whole process.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 7,
   "openness_reason_a": "An official MCP server with read and write where permitted, admin controls, logs, several named clients and a public API with webhooks are documented, with minor gaps on plan and audit detail.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server with read and write scopes, same permissions, a Claude directory connector with a read-only option, a public API and SCIM, but no webhooks and API write-back limited to goals.",
   "ttv_a": 5,
   "ttv_b": 7,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A weeks-not-months claim, a separately sold sandbox and implementation fees in partner terms are documented, but no fee amount or guided implementation detail.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A sandbox on request adds the one element the current reason lacked, which puts it level with or above another platform at 7 with no sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 3,
   "pricing_b": 7,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Core contents and a per-employee pricing basis with separate modules are described by marketing pages, but no amounts and the minimum is only set in the Order Form.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Per-seat prices for each talent module and add-on and a $4,000 minimum annual agreement are published, but the HRIS is unpriced, enterprise is by quote and in-product billing is not shown.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 6,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields and tables, group-based permissions, policy visibility settings, location policies and multi-entity are documented, with language support from marketing only and no per-policy approver choice.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields, targeted custom roles with per-field permissions, 24 languages and multi-currency compensation cycles are documented, but there is no multi-entity or per-office policy and the HRIS is a US limited beta.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Lattice 6.0 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "HiBob 6.0 to 5.6.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "HiBob 6.3 to 6.0.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "HiBob 5.9 to 5.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Lattice 5.9 to 5.5."
  },
  {
   "bout": "HiBob vs Personio",
   "a": "HiBob",
   "b": "Personio",
   "total_a": "5.6",
   "total_b": "5.4",
   "winner": "HiBob",
   "margin": "0.2",
   "build_a": 5,
   "build_b": 6,
   "build_reason_a": "No-code workflows with conditional logic and branching, lifecycle triggers and natural-language analytics are described, but only on marketing pages and with the AI builder not yet available.",
   "build_reason_b": "Docs show a no-code workflow builder with templates, conditions and draft or activate, and a Report Builder with permission-respecting data, but natural-language workflow building and a library of built items are not documented.",
   "agents_a": 5,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Human approval of write actions, an admin AI off switch, role-bound access and MCP AI logs are stated, but only on marketing pages and with no whole-process agent or detailed agent audit log.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Docs add central and per-feature AI off switches with a spend limit, advisory-only screening, audited MCP setting changes and hidden person attributes, but no process-running agent or agent audit log.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 6,
   "openness_reason_a": "An official MCP server with read and write where permitted, admin controls, logs, several named clients and a public API with webhooks are documented, with minor gaps on plan and audit detail.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented official MCP server (beta, Core Pro) with read, opt-in write, per-tool switches and named clients, a webhooks API and Slack and Teams integrations, but beta status and the Core Pro API restriction limit it.",
   "ttv_a": 5,
   "ttv_b": 6,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A weeks-not-months claim, a separately sold sandbox and implementation fees in partner terms are documented, but no fee amount or guided implementation detail.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A guided Implementation Specialist, phased payroll implementation, a 14-day trial, import tools and a one-time fee are documented, but no timeline or amount and the sandbox is on a paid support plan.",
   "pricing_a": 3,
   "pricing_b": 3,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Core contents and a per-employee pricing basis with separate modules are described by marketing pages, but no amounts and the minimum is only set in the Order Form.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Three plans with contents, named add-ons and a 12-month minimum run-time are published, but no prices and no implementation amount (a third-party figure is only a weak hint).",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 8,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields and tables, group-based permissions, policy visibility settings, location policies and multi-entity are documented, with language support from marketing only and no per-policy approver choice.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Unlimited entities, permissions, custom attributes, per-process approvers, per-workplace currency and per-user language are documented in docs, with policies per office not shown.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "HiBob 5.4 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "HiBob 6.0 to 5.8.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "HiBob 6.3 to 6.0.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "HiBob 5.9 to 5.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "HiBob 5.5 to 5.5."
  },
  {
   "bout": "HiBob vs Deel",
   "a": "HiBob",
   "b": "Deel",
   "total_a": "5.6",
   "total_b": "5.2",
   "winner": "HiBob",
   "margin": "0.4",
   "build_a": 5,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "No-code workflows with conditional logic and branching, lifecycle triggers and natural-language analytics are described, but only on marketing pages and with the AI builder not yet available.",
   "build_reason_b": "A no-code workflow builder with triggers, filters, conditions, delay steps and a simulation tool is described on a marketing page, but building by description and sharing are not documented.",
   "agents_a": 5,
   "agents_b": 5,
   "agents_reason_a": "Human approval of write actions, an admin AI off switch, role-bound access and MCP AI logs are stated, but only on marketing pages and with no whole-process agent or detailed agent audit log.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Agentic workflows from triggers with human approval and logged actions cover about as many elements as another platform at 5, also on one marketing page, so 4 understates it.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 8,
   "openness_reason_a": "An official MCP server with read and write where permitted, admin controls, logs, several named clients and a public API with webhooks are documented, with minor gaps on plan and audit detail.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented official MCP server with read and write OAuth scopes checked per call, signed webhooks with retries, REST API and named AI clients, with gaps on plan detail and audit.",
   "ttv_a": 5,
   "ttv_b": 6,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A weeks-not-months claim, a separately sold sandbox and implementation fees in partner terms are documented, but no fee amount or guided implementation detail.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A weeks-not-months claim, described implementation steps with an onboarding manager and a documented API sandbox, but no fee and the claim is marketing only.",
   "pricing_a": 3,
   "pricing_b": 6,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Core contents and a per-employee pricing basis with separate modules are described by marketing pages, but no amounts and the minimum is only set in the Order Form.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Core from $5 per employee per month, contents of three tiers, and EOR, PEO, contractor, payroll and IT prices are published with month-to-month terms, but Advanced, Elite and recruiting prices are not.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 6,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields and tables, group-based permissions, policy visibility settings, location policies and multi-entity are documented, with language support from marketing only and no per-policy approver choice.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Multi-country entities, job architecture, country time off policies and approvals plus payment in 120+ currencies are documented, but no custom fields, roles or per-policy approvers.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Deel 5.5 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "HiBob 6.0 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "HiBob 6.3 to 5.8; Deel is the specialist for payroll in 150 countries inside the HRIS.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "HiBob 5.9 to 5.3.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Deel 5.5 to 5.5."
  },
  {
   "bout": "HiBob vs Gusto",
   "a": "HiBob",
   "b": "Gusto",
   "total_a": "5.6",
   "total_b": "4.1",
   "winner": "HiBob",
   "margin": "1.5",
   "build_a": 5,
   "build_b": 1,
   "build_reason_a": "No-code workflows with conditional logic and branching, lifecycle triggers and natural-language analytics are described, but only on marketing pages and with the AI builder not yet available.",
   "build_reason_b": "Reports and AI suggestions with onboarding templates and employee tasks, but no natural-language builder, any-field triggers or conditions found.",
   "agents_a": 5,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Human approval of write actions, an admin AI off switch, role-bound access and MCP AI logs are stated, but only on marketing pages and with no whole-process agent or detailed agent audit log.",
   "agents_reason_b": "MCP writes come back for confirmation and admins choose data categories, but there is no HR agent running processes, no audit statement and only partial off-switch controls.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 6,
   "openness_reason_a": "An official MCP server with read and write where permitted, admin controls, logs, several named clients and a public API with webhooks are documented, with minor gaps on plan and audit detail.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server for customers exists, but the public API and webhooks are restricted to partners and the developer MCP server is beta.",
   "ttv_a": 5,
   "ttv_b": 7,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A weeks-not-months claim, a separately sold sandbox and implementation fees in partner terms are documented, but no fee amount or guided implementation detail.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "No setup fee, guided setup included and self-serve are documented across two sources, but no timeline or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 3,
   "pricing_b": 9,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Core contents and a per-employee pricing basis with separate modules are described by marketing pages, but no amounts and the minimum is only set in the Order Form.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Base and per-person prices for three plans, priced add-ons and month-to-month terms with no plan minimum are published; in-product billing is not documented.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 3,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields and tables, group-based permissions, policy visibility settings, location policies and multi-entity are documented, with language support from marketing only and no per-policy approver choice.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields through the API, time off approvals and report filters by department and address are documented, with no multi-entity, currency or language detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "HiBob 5.4 to 5.0.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "HiBob 6.0 to 3.9.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "HiBob 6.3 to 4.3.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "HiBob 5.9 to 3.8.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "HiBob 5.5 to 4.8."
  },
  {
   "bout": "HiBob vs Paylocity",
   "a": "HiBob",
   "b": "Paylocity",
   "total_a": "5.6",
   "total_b": "3.3",
   "winner": "HiBob",
   "margin": "2.3",
   "build_a": 5,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "No-code workflows with conditional logic and branching, lifecycle triggers and natural-language analytics are described, but only on marketing pages and with the AI builder not yet available.",
   "build_reason_b": "Ready-made and custom workflow templates with filters, conditional routing, manager creation rights and progress dashboards are described on a marketing page, but no natural-language builder is documented.",
   "agents_a": 5,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Human approval of write actions, an admin AI off switch, role-bound access and MCP AI logs are stated, but only on marketing pages and with no whole-process agent or detailed agent audit log.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Purpose-built agents for onboarding, payroll and expenses with an enable choice and monitoring of actions are described on a marketing page, but no approval step, audit log or field-level control is stated.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 3,
   "openness_reason_a": "An official MCP server with read and write where permitted, admin controls, logs, several named clients and a public API with webhooks are documented, with minor gaps on plan and audit detail.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server exists but only for API documentation, and webhooks and developer access are limited to early adopters, partners or custom-integration agreements.",
   "ttv_a": 5,
   "ttv_b": 2,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A weeks-not-months claim, a separately sold sandbox and implementation fees in partner terms are documented, but no fee amount or guided implementation detail.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A 4 to 16 week integration estimate and a sandbox for approved customers and partners are documented, but nothing on HR platform go-live, fee or guided implementation.",
   "pricing_a": 3,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Core contents and a per-employee pricing basis with separate modules are described by marketing pages, but no amounts and the minimum is only set in the Order Form.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Contents are listed by module, but there are no prices, tiers or minimum, only a request for pricing through a demo.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 5,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields and tables, group-based permissions, policy visibility settings, location policies and multi-entity are documented, with language support from marketing only and no per-policy approver choice.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Unlimited custom fields, location-based workflow filters and global payroll currencies are described, but only by marketing pages, with no entity or role detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "HiBob 5.4 to 3.1.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "HiBob 6.0 to 3.6.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "HiBob 6.3 to 3.7.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "HiBob 5.9 to 3.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "HiBob 5.5 to 3.2."
  },
  {
   "bout": "HiBob vs ADP",
   "a": "HiBob",
   "b": "ADP",
   "total_a": "5.6",
   "total_b": "2.8",
   "winner": "HiBob",
   "margin": "2.8",
   "build_a": 5,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "No-code workflows with conditional logic and branching, lifecycle triggers and natural-language analytics are described, but only on marketing pages and with the AI builder not yet available.",
   "build_reason_b": "Drag and drop report building with sharing and a prebuilt report library are described, plus guided workflows, but only on marketing pages and with no natural-language building or admin-editable triggers.",
   "agents_a": 5,
   "agents_b": 2,
   "agents_reason_a": "Human approval of write actions, an admin AI off switch, role-bound access and MCP AI logs are stated, but only on marketing pages and with no whole-process agent or detailed agent audit log.",
   "agents_reason_b": "A virtual assistant answers HR questions and role-based access exists, but no process agent, approval model, audit log or off switch is documented.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 3,
   "openness_reason_a": "An official MCP server with read and write where permitted, admin controls, logs, several named clients and a public API with webhooks are documented, with minor gaps on plan and audit detail.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Docs-type developer pages show HR, time and payroll APIs with OAuth 2.0, but API Central is a separate purchase, the MCP mention is marketing only, and no webhooks were found.",
   "ttv_a": 5,
   "ttv_b": 3,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A weeks-not-months claim, a separately sold sandbox and implementation fees in partner terms are documented, but no fee amount or guided implementation detail.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "An implementation team and Client Success Executive from day one are named, with no timeline, fee or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 3,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Core contents and a per-employee pricing basis with separate modules are described by marketing pages, but no amounts and the minimum is only set in the Order Form.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Three package names with contents are published, but every tier is Get Pricing with no amounts, add-on prices or minimum.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 4,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields and tables, group-based permissions, policy visibility settings, location policies and multi-entity are documented, with language support from marketing only and no per-policy approver choice.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Role approvals, time off policies and multi-country support with a customizable portal are described, but mostly by marketing pages and with no custom fields or entity detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "HiBob 5.4 to 2.9.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "HiBob 6.0 to 3.0.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "HiBob 6.3 to 3.2.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "HiBob 5.9 to 2.9.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "HiBob 5.5 to 2.9."
  },
  {
   "bout": "HiBob vs Sage",
   "a": "HiBob",
   "b": "Sage",
   "total_a": "5.6",
   "total_b": "2.2",
   "winner": "HiBob",
   "margin": "3.4",
   "build_a": 5,
   "build_b": 1,
   "build_reason_a": "No-code workflows with conditional logic and branching, lifecycle triggers and natural-language analytics are described, but only on marketing pages and with the AI builder not yet available.",
   "build_reason_b": "Reports and checklist templates with employee task lists, but no natural-language builder, triggers or conditions found and only one source.",
   "agents_a": 5,
   "agents_b": 1,
   "agents_reason_a": "Human approval of write actions, an admin AI off switch, role-bound access and MCP AI logs are stated, but only on marketing pages and with no whole-process agent or detailed agent audit log.",
   "agents_reason_b": "No agent, approval model, audit log or AI off switch was found; only permission levels are mentioned.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 2,
   "openness_reason_a": "An official MCP server with read and write where permitted, admin controls, logs, several named clients and a public API with webhooks are documented, with minor gaps on plan and audit detail.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Only a Sage API was found, with no MCP server, no webhooks and no AI integrations.",
   "ttv_a": 5,
   "ttv_b": 4,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A weeks-not-months claim, a separately sold sandbox and implementation fees in partner terms are documented, but no fee amount or guided implementation detail.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A 30-day free trial and modular self-serve setup are documented, with implementation through partners and no fee, timeline or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 3,
   "pricing_b": 7,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Core contents and a per-employee pricing basis with separate modules are described by marketing pages, but no amounts and the minimum is only set in the Order Form.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Per-employee module prices and priced add-ons are published for the US, but no minimum is stated, the enterprise product is by quote and in-product billing is not shown.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 2,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields and tables, group-based permissions, policy visibility settings, location policies and multi-entity are documented, with language support from marketing only and no per-policy approver choice.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Leave policies and manager approvals are documented, but multi-entity and multi-country configuration are not shown as available.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "HiBob 5.4 to 3.3.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "HiBob 6.0 to 2.2.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "HiBob 6.3 to 2.8.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "HiBob 5.9 to 2.0.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "HiBob 5.5 to 3.0."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Lattice vs Personio",
   "a": "Lattice",
   "b": "Personio",
   "total_a": "5.5",
   "total_b": "5.4",
   "winner": "Lattice",
   "margin": "0.1",
   "build_a": 4,
   "build_b": 6,
   "build_reason_a": "Docs show admin-built custom reports shared with chosen employees and scheduled exports, adding to limited-beta AI and review rules, but there is no prompt-built report or flow.",
   "build_reason_b": "Docs show a no-code workflow builder with templates, conditions and draft or activate, and a Report Builder with permission-respecting data, but natural-language workflow building and a library of built items are not documented.",
   "agents_a": 5,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Docs show a full AI off switch, opt-in per feature, draft review before actions, sensitive-field roles and an agent dashboard log with gaps, but the agent takes single actions and runs no whole process.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Docs add central and per-feature AI off switches with a spend limit, advisory-only screening, audited MCP setting changes and hidden person attributes, but no process-running agent or agent audit log.",
   "openness_a": 7,
   "openness_b": 6,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented MCP server with read and write scopes, same permissions, a Claude directory connector with a read-only option, a public API and SCIM, but no webhooks and API write-back limited to goals.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented official MCP server (beta, Core Pro) with read, opt-in write, per-tool switches and named clients, a webhooks API and Slack and Teams integrations, but beta status and the Core Pro API restriction limit it.",
   "ttv_a": 7,
   "ttv_b": 6,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A sandbox on request adds the one element the current reason lacked, which puts it level with or above another platform at 7 with no sandbox.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A guided Implementation Specialist, phased payroll implementation, a 14-day trial, import tools and a one-time fee are documented, but no timeline or amount and the sandbox is on a paid support plan.",
   "pricing_a": 7,
   "pricing_b": 3,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Per-seat prices for each talent module and add-on and a $4,000 minimum annual agreement are published, but the HRIS is unpriced, enterprise is by quote and in-product billing is not shown.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Three plans with contents, named add-ons and a 12-month minimum run-time are published, but no prices and no implementation amount (a third-party figure is only a weak hint).",
   "fit_a": 6,
   "fit_b": 8,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields, targeted custom roles with per-field permissions, 24 languages and multi-currency compensation cycles are documented, but there is no multi-entity or per-office policy and the HRIS is a US limited beta.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Unlimited entities, permissions, custom attributes, per-process approvers, per-workplace currency and per-user language are documented in docs, with policies per office not shown.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Lattice 6.0 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Personio 5.8 to 5.6.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Lattice 6.0 to 6.0.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Lattice 5.5 to 5.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Lattice 5.9 to 5.5."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Lattice vs Deel",
   "a": "Lattice",
   "b": "Deel",
   "total_a": "5.5",
   "total_b": "5.2",
   "winner": "Lattice",
   "margin": "0.3",
   "build_a": 4,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "Docs show admin-built custom reports shared with chosen employees and scheduled exports, adding to limited-beta AI and review rules, but there is no prompt-built report or flow.",
   "build_reason_b": "A no-code workflow builder with triggers, filters, conditions, delay steps and a simulation tool is described on a marketing page, but building by description and sharing are not documented.",
   "agents_a": 5,
   "agents_b": 5,
   "agents_reason_a": "Docs show a full AI off switch, opt-in per feature, draft review before actions, sensitive-field roles and an agent dashboard log with gaps, but the agent takes single actions and runs no whole process.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Agentic workflows from triggers with human approval and logged actions cover about as many elements as another platform at 5, also on one marketing page, so 4 understates it.",
   "openness_a": 7,
   "openness_b": 8,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented MCP server with read and write scopes, same permissions, a Claude directory connector with a read-only option, a public API and SCIM, but no webhooks and API write-back limited to goals.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented official MCP server with read and write OAuth scopes checked per call, signed webhooks with retries, REST API and named AI clients, with gaps on plan detail and audit.",
   "ttv_a": 7,
   "ttv_b": 6,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A sandbox on request adds the one element the current reason lacked, which puts it level with or above another platform at 7 with no sandbox.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A weeks-not-months claim, described implementation steps with an onboarding manager and a documented API sandbox, but no fee and the claim is marketing only.",
   "pricing_a": 7,
   "pricing_b": 6,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Per-seat prices for each talent module and add-on and a $4,000 minimum annual agreement are published, but the HRIS is unpriced, enterprise is by quote and in-product billing is not shown.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Core from $5 per employee per month, contents of three tiers, and EOR, PEO, contractor, payroll and IT prices are published with month-to-month terms, but Advanced, Elite and recruiting prices are not.",
   "fit_a": 6,
   "fit_b": 6,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields, targeted custom roles with per-field permissions, 24 languages and multi-currency compensation cycles are documented, but there is no multi-entity or per-office policy and the HRIS is a US limited beta.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Multi-country entities, job architecture, country time off policies and approvals plus payment in 120+ currencies are documented, but no custom fields, roles or per-policy approvers.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Lattice 6.0 to 5.5.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Lattice 5.6 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Lattice 6.0 to 5.8; Deel is the specialist for payroll in 150 countries inside the HRIS.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Lattice 5.5 to 5.3.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Lattice 5.9 to 5.5."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Lattice vs Gusto",
   "a": "Lattice",
   "b": "Gusto",
   "total_a": "5.5",
   "total_b": "4.1",
   "winner": "Lattice",
   "margin": "1.4",
   "build_a": 4,
   "build_b": 1,
   "build_reason_a": "Docs show admin-built custom reports shared with chosen employees and scheduled exports, adding to limited-beta AI and review rules, but there is no prompt-built report or flow.",
   "build_reason_b": "Reports and AI suggestions with onboarding templates and employee tasks, but no natural-language builder, any-field triggers or conditions found.",
   "agents_a": 5,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Docs show a full AI off switch, opt-in per feature, draft review before actions, sensitive-field roles and an agent dashboard log with gaps, but the agent takes single actions and runs no whole process.",
   "agents_reason_b": "MCP writes come back for confirmation and admins choose data categories, but there is no HR agent running processes, no audit statement and only partial off-switch controls.",
   "openness_a": 7,
   "openness_b": 6,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented MCP server with read and write scopes, same permissions, a Claude directory connector with a read-only option, a public API and SCIM, but no webhooks and API write-back limited to goals.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server for customers exists, but the public API and webhooks are restricted to partners and the developer MCP server is beta.",
   "ttv_a": 7,
   "ttv_b": 7,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A sandbox on request adds the one element the current reason lacked, which puts it level with or above another platform at 7 with no sandbox.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "No setup fee, guided setup included and self-serve are documented across two sources, but no timeline or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 7,
   "pricing_b": 9,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Per-seat prices for each talent module and add-on and a $4,000 minimum annual agreement are published, but the HRIS is unpriced, enterprise is by quote and in-product billing is not shown.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Base and per-person prices for three plans, priced add-ons and month-to-month terms with no plan minimum are published; in-product billing is not documented.",
   "fit_a": 6,
   "fit_b": 3,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields, targeted custom roles with per-field permissions, 24 languages and multi-currency compensation cycles are documented, but there is no multi-entity or per-office policy and the HRIS is a US limited beta.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields through the API, time off approvals and report filters by department and address are documented, with no multi-entity, currency or language detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Lattice 6.0 to 5.0.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Lattice 5.6 to 3.9.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Lattice 6.0 to 4.3.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Lattice 5.5 to 3.8.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Lattice 5.9 to 4.8."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Lattice vs Paylocity",
   "a": "Lattice",
   "b": "Paylocity",
   "total_a": "5.5",
   "total_b": "3.3",
   "winner": "Lattice",
   "margin": "2.2",
   "build_a": 4,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "Docs show admin-built custom reports shared with chosen employees and scheduled exports, adding to limited-beta AI and review rules, but there is no prompt-built report or flow.",
   "build_reason_b": "Ready-made and custom workflow templates with filters, conditional routing, manager creation rights and progress dashboards are described on a marketing page, but no natural-language builder is documented.",
   "agents_a": 5,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Docs show a full AI off switch, opt-in per feature, draft review before actions, sensitive-field roles and an agent dashboard log with gaps, but the agent takes single actions and runs no whole process.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Purpose-built agents for onboarding, payroll and expenses with an enable choice and monitoring of actions are described on a marketing page, but no approval step, audit log or field-level control is stated.",
   "openness_a": 7,
   "openness_b": 3,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented MCP server with read and write scopes, same permissions, a Claude directory connector with a read-only option, a public API and SCIM, but no webhooks and API write-back limited to goals.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server exists but only for API documentation, and webhooks and developer access are limited to early adopters, partners or custom-integration agreements.",
   "ttv_a": 7,
   "ttv_b": 2,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A sandbox on request adds the one element the current reason lacked, which puts it level with or above another platform at 7 with no sandbox.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A 4 to 16 week integration estimate and a sandbox for approved customers and partners are documented, but nothing on HR platform go-live, fee or guided implementation.",
   "pricing_a": 7,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Per-seat prices for each talent module and add-on and a $4,000 minimum annual agreement are published, but the HRIS is unpriced, enterprise is by quote and in-product billing is not shown.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Contents are listed by module, but there are no prices, tiers or minimum, only a request for pricing through a demo.",
   "fit_a": 6,
   "fit_b": 5,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields, targeted custom roles with per-field permissions, 24 languages and multi-currency compensation cycles are documented, but there is no multi-entity or per-office policy and the HRIS is a US limited beta.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Unlimited custom fields, location-based workflow filters and global payroll currencies are described, but only by marketing pages, with no entity or role detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Lattice 6.0 to 3.1.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Lattice 5.6 to 3.6.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Lattice 6.0 to 3.7.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Lattice 5.5 to 3.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Lattice 5.9 to 3.2."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Lattice vs ADP",
   "a": "Lattice",
   "b": "ADP",
   "total_a": "5.5",
   "total_b": "2.8",
   "winner": "Lattice",
   "margin": "2.7",
   "build_a": 4,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "Docs show admin-built custom reports shared with chosen employees and scheduled exports, adding to limited-beta AI and review rules, but there is no prompt-built report or flow.",
   "build_reason_b": "Drag and drop report building with sharing and a prebuilt report library are described, plus guided workflows, but only on marketing pages and with no natural-language building or admin-editable triggers.",
   "agents_a": 5,
   "agents_b": 2,
   "agents_reason_a": "Docs show a full AI off switch, opt-in per feature, draft review before actions, sensitive-field roles and an agent dashboard log with gaps, but the agent takes single actions and runs no whole process.",
   "agents_reason_b": "A virtual assistant answers HR questions and role-based access exists, but no process agent, approval model, audit log or off switch is documented.",
   "openness_a": 7,
   "openness_b": 3,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented MCP server with read and write scopes, same permissions, a Claude directory connector with a read-only option, a public API and SCIM, but no webhooks and API write-back limited to goals.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Docs-type developer pages show HR, time and payroll APIs with OAuth 2.0, but API Central is a separate purchase, the MCP mention is marketing only, and no webhooks were found.",
   "ttv_a": 7,
   "ttv_b": 3,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A sandbox on request adds the one element the current reason lacked, which puts it level with or above another platform at 7 with no sandbox.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "An implementation team and Client Success Executive from day one are named, with no timeline, fee or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 7,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Per-seat prices for each talent module and add-on and a $4,000 minimum annual agreement are published, but the HRIS is unpriced, enterprise is by quote and in-product billing is not shown.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Three package names with contents are published, but every tier is Get Pricing with no amounts, add-on prices or minimum.",
   "fit_a": 6,
   "fit_b": 4,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields, targeted custom roles with per-field permissions, 24 languages and multi-currency compensation cycles are documented, but there is no multi-entity or per-office policy and the HRIS is a US limited beta.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Role approvals, time off policies and multi-country support with a customizable portal are described, but mostly by marketing pages and with no custom fields or entity detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Lattice 6.0 to 2.9.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Lattice 5.6 to 3.0.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Lattice 6.0 to 3.2.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Lattice 5.5 to 2.9.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Lattice 5.9 to 2.9."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Lattice vs Sage",
   "a": "Lattice",
   "b": "Sage",
   "total_a": "5.5",
   "total_b": "2.2",
   "winner": "Lattice",
   "margin": "3.3",
   "build_a": 4,
   "build_b": 1,
   "build_reason_a": "Docs show admin-built custom reports shared with chosen employees and scheduled exports, adding to limited-beta AI and review rules, but there is no prompt-built report or flow.",
   "build_reason_b": "Reports and checklist templates with employee task lists, but no natural-language builder, triggers or conditions found and only one source.",
   "agents_a": 5,
   "agents_b": 1,
   "agents_reason_a": "Docs show a full AI off switch, opt-in per feature, draft review before actions, sensitive-field roles and an agent dashboard log with gaps, but the agent takes single actions and runs no whole process.",
   "agents_reason_b": "No agent, approval model, audit log or AI off switch was found; only permission levels are mentioned.",
   "openness_a": 7,
   "openness_b": 2,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented MCP server with read and write scopes, same permissions, a Claude directory connector with a read-only option, a public API and SCIM, but no webhooks and API write-back limited to goals.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Only a Sage API was found, with no MCP server, no webhooks and no AI integrations.",
   "ttv_a": 7,
   "ttv_b": 4,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A sandbox on request adds the one element the current reason lacked, which puts it level with or above another platform at 7 with no sandbox.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A 30-day free trial and modular self-serve setup are documented, with implementation through partners and no fee, timeline or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 7,
   "pricing_b": 7,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Per-seat prices for each talent module and add-on and a $4,000 minimum annual agreement are published, but the HRIS is unpriced, enterprise is by quote and in-product billing is not shown.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Per-employee module prices and priced add-ons are published for the US, but no minimum is stated, the enterprise product is by quote and in-product billing is not shown.",
   "fit_a": 6,
   "fit_b": 2,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields, targeted custom roles with per-field permissions, 24 languages and multi-currency compensation cycles are documented, but there is no multi-entity or per-office policy and the HRIS is a US limited beta.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Leave policies and manager approvals are documented, but multi-entity and multi-country configuration are not shown as available.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Lattice 6.0 to 3.3.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Lattice 5.6 to 2.2.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Lattice 6.0 to 2.8.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Lattice 5.5 to 2.0.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Lattice 5.9 to 3.0."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Personio vs Deel",
   "a": "Personio",
   "b": "Deel",
   "total_a": "5.4",
   "total_b": "5.2",
   "winner": "Personio",
   "margin": "0.2",
   "build_a": 6,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "Docs show a no-code workflow builder with templates, conditions and draft or activate, and a Report Builder with permission-respecting data, but natural-language workflow building and a library of built items are not documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "A no-code workflow builder with triggers, filters, conditions, delay steps and a simulation tool is described on a marketing page, but building by description and sharing are not documented.",
   "agents_a": 4,
   "agents_b": 5,
   "agents_reason_a": "Docs add central and per-feature AI off switches with a spend limit, advisory-only screening, audited MCP setting changes and hidden person attributes, but no process-running agent or agent audit log.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Agentic workflows from triggers with human approval and logged actions cover about as many elements as another platform at 5, also on one marketing page, so 4 understates it.",
   "openness_a": 6,
   "openness_b": 8,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented official MCP server (beta, Core Pro) with read, opt-in write, per-tool switches and named clients, a webhooks API and Slack and Teams integrations, but beta status and the Core Pro API restriction limit it.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented official MCP server with read and write OAuth scopes checked per call, signed webhooks with retries, REST API and named AI clients, with gaps on plan detail and audit.",
   "ttv_a": 6,
   "ttv_b": 6,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A guided Implementation Specialist, phased payroll implementation, a 14-day trial, import tools and a one-time fee are documented, but no timeline or amount and the sandbox is on a paid support plan.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A weeks-not-months claim, described implementation steps with an onboarding manager and a documented API sandbox, but no fee and the claim is marketing only.",
   "pricing_a": 3,
   "pricing_b": 6,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Three plans with contents, named add-ons and a 12-month minimum run-time are published, but no prices and no implementation amount (a third-party figure is only a weak hint).",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Core from $5 per employee per month, contents of three tiers, and EOR, PEO, contractor, payroll and IT prices are published with month-to-month terms, but Advanced, Elite and recruiting prices are not.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 6,
   "fit_reason_a": "Unlimited entities, permissions, custom attributes, per-process approvers, per-workplace currency and per-user language are documented in docs, with policies per office not shown.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Multi-country entities, job architecture, country time off policies and approvals plus payment in 120+ currencies are documented, but no custom fields, roles or per-policy approvers.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Deel 5.5 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Personio 5.8 to 5.4.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Personio 6.0 to 5.8; Deel is the specialist for payroll in 150 countries inside the HRIS.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Personio 5.5 to 5.3.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Deel 5.5 to 5.5."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Personio vs Gusto",
   "a": "Personio",
   "b": "Gusto",
   "total_a": "5.4",
   "total_b": "4.1",
   "winner": "Personio",
   "margin": "1.3",
   "build_a": 6,
   "build_b": 1,
   "build_reason_a": "Docs show a no-code workflow builder with templates, conditions and draft or activate, and a Report Builder with permission-respecting data, but natural-language workflow building and a library of built items are not documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Reports and AI suggestions with onboarding templates and employee tasks, but no natural-language builder, any-field triggers or conditions found.",
   "agents_a": 4,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Docs add central and per-feature AI off switches with a spend limit, advisory-only screening, audited MCP setting changes and hidden person attributes, but no process-running agent or agent audit log.",
   "agents_reason_b": "MCP writes come back for confirmation and admins choose data categories, but there is no HR agent running processes, no audit statement and only partial off-switch controls.",
   "openness_a": 6,
   "openness_b": 6,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented official MCP server (beta, Core Pro) with read, opt-in write, per-tool switches and named clients, a webhooks API and Slack and Teams integrations, but beta status and the Core Pro API restriction limit it.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server for customers exists, but the public API and webhooks are restricted to partners and the developer MCP server is beta.",
   "ttv_a": 6,
   "ttv_b": 7,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A guided Implementation Specialist, phased payroll implementation, a 14-day trial, import tools and a one-time fee are documented, but no timeline or amount and the sandbox is on a paid support plan.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "No setup fee, guided setup included and self-serve are documented across two sources, but no timeline or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 3,
   "pricing_b": 9,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Three plans with contents, named add-ons and a 12-month minimum run-time are published, but no prices and no implementation amount (a third-party figure is only a weak hint).",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Base and per-person prices for three plans, priced add-ons and month-to-month terms with no plan minimum are published; in-product billing is not documented.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 3,
   "fit_reason_a": "Unlimited entities, permissions, custom attributes, per-process approvers, per-workplace currency and per-user language are documented in docs, with policies per office not shown.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields through the API, time off approvals and report filters by department and address are documented, with no multi-entity, currency or language detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Personio 5.4 to 5.0.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Personio 5.8 to 3.9.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Personio 6.0 to 4.3.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Personio 5.5 to 3.8.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Personio 5.5 to 4.8."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Personio vs Paylocity",
   "a": "Personio",
   "b": "Paylocity",
   "total_a": "5.4",
   "total_b": "3.3",
   "winner": "Personio",
   "margin": "2.1",
   "build_a": 6,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "Docs show a no-code workflow builder with templates, conditions and draft or activate, and a Report Builder with permission-respecting data, but natural-language workflow building and a library of built items are not documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Ready-made and custom workflow templates with filters, conditional routing, manager creation rights and progress dashboards are described on a marketing page, but no natural-language builder is documented.",
   "agents_a": 4,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Docs add central and per-feature AI off switches with a spend limit, advisory-only screening, audited MCP setting changes and hidden person attributes, but no process-running agent or agent audit log.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Purpose-built agents for onboarding, payroll and expenses with an enable choice and monitoring of actions are described on a marketing page, but no approval step, audit log or field-level control is stated.",
   "openness_a": 6,
   "openness_b": 3,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented official MCP server (beta, Core Pro) with read, opt-in write, per-tool switches and named clients, a webhooks API and Slack and Teams integrations, but beta status and the Core Pro API restriction limit it.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server exists but only for API documentation, and webhooks and developer access are limited to early adopters, partners or custom-integration agreements.",
   "ttv_a": 6,
   "ttv_b": 2,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A guided Implementation Specialist, phased payroll implementation, a 14-day trial, import tools and a one-time fee are documented, but no timeline or amount and the sandbox is on a paid support plan.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A 4 to 16 week integration estimate and a sandbox for approved customers and partners are documented, but nothing on HR platform go-live, fee or guided implementation.",
   "pricing_a": 3,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Three plans with contents, named add-ons and a 12-month minimum run-time are published, but no prices and no implementation amount (a third-party figure is only a weak hint).",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Contents are listed by module, but there are no prices, tiers or minimum, only a request for pricing through a demo.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 5,
   "fit_reason_a": "Unlimited entities, permissions, custom attributes, per-process approvers, per-workplace currency and per-user language are documented in docs, with policies per office not shown.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Unlimited custom fields, location-based workflow filters and global payroll currencies are described, but only by marketing pages, with no entity or role detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Personio 5.4 to 3.1.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Personio 5.8 to 3.6.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Personio 6.0 to 3.7.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Personio 5.5 to 3.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Personio 5.5 to 3.2."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Personio vs ADP",
   "a": "Personio",
   "b": "ADP",
   "total_a": "5.4",
   "total_b": "2.8",
   "winner": "Personio",
   "margin": "2.6",
   "build_a": 6,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "Docs show a no-code workflow builder with templates, conditions and draft or activate, and a Report Builder with permission-respecting data, but natural-language workflow building and a library of built items are not documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Drag and drop report building with sharing and a prebuilt report library are described, plus guided workflows, but only on marketing pages and with no natural-language building or admin-editable triggers.",
   "agents_a": 4,
   "agents_b": 2,
   "agents_reason_a": "Docs add central and per-feature AI off switches with a spend limit, advisory-only screening, audited MCP setting changes and hidden person attributes, but no process-running agent or agent audit log.",
   "agents_reason_b": "A virtual assistant answers HR questions and role-based access exists, but no process agent, approval model, audit log or off switch is documented.",
   "openness_a": 6,
   "openness_b": 3,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented official MCP server (beta, Core Pro) with read, opt-in write, per-tool switches and named clients, a webhooks API and Slack and Teams integrations, but beta status and the Core Pro API restriction limit it.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Docs-type developer pages show HR, time and payroll APIs with OAuth 2.0, but API Central is a separate purchase, the MCP mention is marketing only, and no webhooks were found.",
   "ttv_a": 6,
   "ttv_b": 3,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A guided Implementation Specialist, phased payroll implementation, a 14-day trial, import tools and a one-time fee are documented, but no timeline or amount and the sandbox is on a paid support plan.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "An implementation team and Client Success Executive from day one are named, with no timeline, fee or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 3,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Three plans with contents, named add-ons and a 12-month minimum run-time are published, but no prices and no implementation amount (a third-party figure is only a weak hint).",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Three package names with contents are published, but every tier is Get Pricing with no amounts, add-on prices or minimum.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 4,
   "fit_reason_a": "Unlimited entities, permissions, custom attributes, per-process approvers, per-workplace currency and per-user language are documented in docs, with policies per office not shown.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Role approvals, time off policies and multi-country support with a customizable portal are described, but mostly by marketing pages and with no custom fields or entity detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Personio 5.4 to 2.9.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Personio 5.8 to 3.0.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Personio 6.0 to 3.2.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Personio 5.5 to 2.9.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Personio 5.5 to 2.9."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Personio vs Sage",
   "a": "Personio",
   "b": "Sage",
   "total_a": "5.4",
   "total_b": "2.2",
   "winner": "Personio",
   "margin": "3.2",
   "build_a": 6,
   "build_b": 1,
   "build_reason_a": "Docs show a no-code workflow builder with templates, conditions and draft or activate, and a Report Builder with permission-respecting data, but natural-language workflow building and a library of built items are not documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Reports and checklist templates with employee task lists, but no natural-language builder, triggers or conditions found and only one source.",
   "agents_a": 4,
   "agents_b": 1,
   "agents_reason_a": "Docs add central and per-feature AI off switches with a spend limit, advisory-only screening, audited MCP setting changes and hidden person attributes, but no process-running agent or agent audit log.",
   "agents_reason_b": "No agent, approval model, audit log or AI off switch was found; only permission levels are mentioned.",
   "openness_a": 6,
   "openness_b": 2,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented official MCP server (beta, Core Pro) with read, opt-in write, per-tool switches and named clients, a webhooks API and Slack and Teams integrations, but beta status and the Core Pro API restriction limit it.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Only a Sage API was found, with no MCP server, no webhooks and no AI integrations.",
   "ttv_a": 6,
   "ttv_b": 4,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A guided Implementation Specialist, phased payroll implementation, a 14-day trial, import tools and a one-time fee are documented, but no timeline or amount and the sandbox is on a paid support plan.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A 30-day free trial and modular self-serve setup are documented, with implementation through partners and no fee, timeline or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 3,
   "pricing_b": 7,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Three plans with contents, named add-ons and a 12-month minimum run-time are published, but no prices and no implementation amount (a third-party figure is only a weak hint).",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Per-employee module prices and priced add-ons are published for the US, but no minimum is stated, the enterprise product is by quote and in-product billing is not shown.",
   "fit_a": 8,
   "fit_b": 2,
   "fit_reason_a": "Unlimited entities, permissions, custom attributes, per-process approvers, per-workplace currency and per-user language are documented in docs, with policies per office not shown.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Leave policies and manager approvals are documented, but multi-entity and multi-country configuration are not shown as available.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Personio 5.4 to 3.3.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Personio 5.8 to 2.2.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Personio 6.0 to 2.8.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Personio 5.5 to 2.0.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Personio 5.5 to 3.0."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Deel vs Gusto",
   "a": "Deel",
   "b": "Gusto",
   "total_a": "5.2",
   "total_b": "4.1",
   "winner": "Deel",
   "margin": "1.1",
   "build_a": 3,
   "build_b": 1,
   "build_reason_a": "A no-code workflow builder with triggers, filters, conditions, delay steps and a simulation tool is described on a marketing page, but building by description and sharing are not documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Reports and AI suggestions with onboarding templates and employee tasks, but no natural-language builder, any-field triggers or conditions found.",
   "agents_a": 5,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agentic workflows from triggers with human approval and logged actions cover about as many elements as another platform at 5, also on one marketing page, so 4 understates it.",
   "agents_reason_b": "MCP writes come back for confirmation and admins choose data categories, but there is no HR agent running processes, no audit statement and only partial off-switch controls.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 6,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented official MCP server with read and write OAuth scopes checked per call, signed webhooks with retries, REST API and named AI clients, with gaps on plan detail and audit.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server for customers exists, but the public API and webhooks are restricted to partners and the developer MCP server is beta.",
   "ttv_a": 6,
   "ttv_b": 7,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A weeks-not-months claim, described implementation steps with an onboarding manager and a documented API sandbox, but no fee and the claim is marketing only.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "No setup fee, guided setup included and self-serve are documented across two sources, but no timeline or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 6,
   "pricing_b": 9,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Core from $5 per employee per month, contents of three tiers, and EOR, PEO, contractor, payroll and IT prices are published with month-to-month terms, but Advanced, Elite and recruiting prices are not.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Base and per-person prices for three plans, priced add-ons and month-to-month terms with no plan minimum are published; in-product billing is not documented.",
   "fit_a": 6,
   "fit_b": 3,
   "fit_reason_a": "Multi-country entities, job architecture, country time off policies and approvals plus payment in 120+ currencies are documented, but no custom fields, roles or per-policy approvers.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Custom fields through the API, time off approvals and report filters by department and address are documented, with no multi-entity, currency or language detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Deel 5.5 to 5.0.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Deel 5.4 to 3.9.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Deel 5.8 to 4.3.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Deel 5.3 to 3.8.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Deel 5.5 to 4.8."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Deel vs Paylocity",
   "a": "Deel",
   "b": "Paylocity",
   "total_a": "5.2",
   "total_b": "3.3",
   "winner": "Deel",
   "margin": "1.9",
   "build_a": 3,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "A no-code workflow builder with triggers, filters, conditions, delay steps and a simulation tool is described on a marketing page, but building by description and sharing are not documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Ready-made and custom workflow templates with filters, conditional routing, manager creation rights and progress dashboards are described on a marketing page, but no natural-language builder is documented.",
   "agents_a": 5,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agentic workflows from triggers with human approval and logged actions cover about as many elements as another platform at 5, also on one marketing page, so 4 understates it.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Purpose-built agents for onboarding, payroll and expenses with an enable choice and monitoring of actions are described on a marketing page, but no approval step, audit log or field-level control is stated.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 3,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented official MCP server with read and write OAuth scopes checked per call, signed webhooks with retries, REST API and named AI clients, with gaps on plan detail and audit.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server exists but only for API documentation, and webhooks and developer access are limited to early adopters, partners or custom-integration agreements.",
   "ttv_a": 6,
   "ttv_b": 2,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A weeks-not-months claim, described implementation steps with an onboarding manager and a documented API sandbox, but no fee and the claim is marketing only.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A 4 to 16 week integration estimate and a sandbox for approved customers and partners are documented, but nothing on HR platform go-live, fee or guided implementation.",
   "pricing_a": 6,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Core from $5 per employee per month, contents of three tiers, and EOR, PEO, contractor, payroll and IT prices are published with month-to-month terms, but Advanced, Elite and recruiting prices are not.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Contents are listed by module, but there are no prices, tiers or minimum, only a request for pricing through a demo.",
   "fit_a": 6,
   "fit_b": 5,
   "fit_reason_a": "Multi-country entities, job architecture, country time off policies and approvals plus payment in 120+ currencies are documented, but no custom fields, roles or per-policy approvers.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Unlimited custom fields, location-based workflow filters and global payroll currencies are described, but only by marketing pages, with no entity or role detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Deel 5.5 to 3.1.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Deel 5.4 to 3.6.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Deel 5.8 to 3.7.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Deel 5.3 to 3.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Deel 5.5 to 3.2."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Deel vs ADP",
   "a": "Deel",
   "b": "ADP",
   "total_a": "5.2",
   "total_b": "2.8",
   "winner": "Deel",
   "margin": "2.4",
   "build_a": 3,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "A no-code workflow builder with triggers, filters, conditions, delay steps and a simulation tool is described on a marketing page, but building by description and sharing are not documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Drag and drop report building with sharing and a prebuilt report library are described, plus guided workflows, but only on marketing pages and with no natural-language building or admin-editable triggers.",
   "agents_a": 5,
   "agents_b": 2,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agentic workflows from triggers with human approval and logged actions cover about as many elements as another platform at 5, also on one marketing page, so 4 understates it.",
   "agents_reason_b": "A virtual assistant answers HR questions and role-based access exists, but no process agent, approval model, audit log or off switch is documented.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 3,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented official MCP server with read and write OAuth scopes checked per call, signed webhooks with retries, REST API and named AI clients, with gaps on plan detail and audit.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Docs-type developer pages show HR, time and payroll APIs with OAuth 2.0, but API Central is a separate purchase, the MCP mention is marketing only, and no webhooks were found.",
   "ttv_a": 6,
   "ttv_b": 3,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A weeks-not-months claim, described implementation steps with an onboarding manager and a documented API sandbox, but no fee and the claim is marketing only.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "An implementation team and Client Success Executive from day one are named, with no timeline, fee or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 6,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Core from $5 per employee per month, contents of three tiers, and EOR, PEO, contractor, payroll and IT prices are published with month-to-month terms, but Advanced, Elite and recruiting prices are not.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Three package names with contents are published, but every tier is Get Pricing with no amounts, add-on prices or minimum.",
   "fit_a": 6,
   "fit_b": 4,
   "fit_reason_a": "Multi-country entities, job architecture, country time off policies and approvals plus payment in 120+ currencies are documented, but no custom fields, roles or per-policy approvers.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Role approvals, time off policies and multi-country support with a customizable portal are described, but mostly by marketing pages and with no custom fields or entity detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Deel 5.5 to 2.9.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Deel 5.4 to 3.0.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Deel 5.8 to 3.2.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Deel 5.3 to 2.9.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Deel 5.5 to 2.9."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Deel vs Sage",
   "a": "Deel",
   "b": "Sage",
   "total_a": "5.2",
   "total_b": "2.2",
   "winner": "Deel",
   "margin": "3.0",
   "build_a": 3,
   "build_b": 1,
   "build_reason_a": "A no-code workflow builder with triggers, filters, conditions, delay steps and a simulation tool is described on a marketing page, but building by description and sharing are not documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Reports and checklist templates with employee task lists, but no natural-language builder, triggers or conditions found and only one source.",
   "agents_a": 5,
   "agents_b": 1,
   "agents_reason_a": "Agentic workflows from triggers with human approval and logged actions cover about as many elements as another platform at 5, also on one marketing page, so 4 understates it.",
   "agents_reason_b": "No agent, approval model, audit log or AI off switch was found; only permission levels are mentioned.",
   "openness_a": 8,
   "openness_b": 2,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented official MCP server with read and write OAuth scopes checked per call, signed webhooks with retries, REST API and named AI clients, with gaps on plan detail and audit.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Only a Sage API was found, with no MCP server, no webhooks and no AI integrations.",
   "ttv_a": 6,
   "ttv_b": 4,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A weeks-not-months claim, described implementation steps with an onboarding manager and a documented API sandbox, but no fee and the claim is marketing only.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A 30-day free trial and modular self-serve setup are documented, with implementation through partners and no fee, timeline or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 6,
   "pricing_b": 7,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Core from $5 per employee per month, contents of three tiers, and EOR, PEO, contractor, payroll and IT prices are published with month-to-month terms, but Advanced, Elite and recruiting prices are not.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Per-employee module prices and priced add-ons are published for the US, but no minimum is stated, the enterprise product is by quote and in-product billing is not shown.",
   "fit_a": 6,
   "fit_b": 2,
   "fit_reason_a": "Multi-country entities, job architecture, country time off policies and approvals plus payment in 120+ currencies are documented, but no custom fields, roles or per-policy approvers.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Leave policies and manager approvals are documented, but multi-entity and multi-country configuration are not shown as available.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Deel 5.5 to 3.3.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Deel 5.4 to 2.2.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Deel 5.8 to 2.8.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Deel 5.3 to 2.0.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Deel 5.5 to 3.0."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Gusto vs Paylocity",
   "a": "Gusto",
   "b": "Paylocity",
   "total_a": "4.1",
   "total_b": "3.3",
   "winner": "Gusto",
   "margin": "0.8",
   "build_a": 1,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "Reports and AI suggestions with onboarding templates and employee tasks, but no natural-language builder, any-field triggers or conditions found.",
   "build_reason_b": "Ready-made and custom workflow templates with filters, conditional routing, manager creation rights and progress dashboards are described on a marketing page, but no natural-language builder is documented.",
   "agents_a": 4,
   "agents_b": 4,
   "agents_reason_a": "MCP writes come back for confirmation and admins choose data categories, but there is no HR agent running processes, no audit statement and only partial off-switch controls.",
   "agents_reason_b": "Purpose-built agents for onboarding, payroll and expenses with an enable choice and monitoring of actions are described on a marketing page, but no approval step, audit log or field-level control is stated.",
   "openness_a": 6,
   "openness_b": 3,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented MCP server for customers exists, but the public API and webhooks are restricted to partners and the developer MCP server is beta.",
   "openness_reason_b": "A documented MCP server exists but only for API documentation, and webhooks and developer access are limited to early adopters, partners or custom-integration agreements.",
   "ttv_a": 7,
   "ttv_b": 2,
   "ttv_reason_a": "No setup fee, guided setup included and self-serve are documented across two sources, but no timeline or sandbox.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A 4 to 16 week integration estimate and a sandbox for approved customers and partners are documented, but nothing on HR platform go-live, fee or guided implementation.",
   "pricing_a": 9,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Base and per-person prices for three plans, priced add-ons and month-to-month terms with no plan minimum are published; in-product billing is not documented.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Contents are listed by module, but there are no prices, tiers or minimum, only a request for pricing through a demo.",
   "fit_a": 3,
   "fit_b": 5,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields through the API, time off approvals and report filters by department and address are documented, with no multi-entity, currency or language detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Unlimited custom fields, location-based workflow filters and global payroll currencies are described, but only by marketing pages, with no entity or role detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Gusto 5.0 to 3.1.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Gusto 3.9 to 3.6.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Gusto 4.3 to 3.7.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Gusto 3.8 to 3.5.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Gusto 4.8 to 3.2."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Gusto vs ADP",
   "a": "Gusto",
   "b": "ADP",
   "total_a": "4.1",
   "total_b": "2.8",
   "winner": "Gusto",
   "margin": "1.3",
   "build_a": 1,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "Reports and AI suggestions with onboarding templates and employee tasks, but no natural-language builder, any-field triggers or conditions found.",
   "build_reason_b": "Drag and drop report building with sharing and a prebuilt report library are described, plus guided workflows, but only on marketing pages and with no natural-language building or admin-editable triggers.",
   "agents_a": 4,
   "agents_b": 2,
   "agents_reason_a": "MCP writes come back for confirmation and admins choose data categories, but there is no HR agent running processes, no audit statement and only partial off-switch controls.",
   "agents_reason_b": "A virtual assistant answers HR questions and role-based access exists, but no process agent, approval model, audit log or off switch is documented.",
   "openness_a": 6,
   "openness_b": 3,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented MCP server for customers exists, but the public API and webhooks are restricted to partners and the developer MCP server is beta.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Docs-type developer pages show HR, time and payroll APIs with OAuth 2.0, but API Central is a separate purchase, the MCP mention is marketing only, and no webhooks were found.",
   "ttv_a": 7,
   "ttv_b": 3,
   "ttv_reason_a": "No setup fee, guided setup included and self-serve are documented across two sources, but no timeline or sandbox.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "An implementation team and Client Success Executive from day one are named, with no timeline, fee or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 9,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Base and per-person prices for three plans, priced add-ons and month-to-month terms with no plan minimum are published; in-product billing is not documented.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Three package names with contents are published, but every tier is Get Pricing with no amounts, add-on prices or minimum.",
   "fit_a": 3,
   "fit_b": 4,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields through the API, time off approvals and report filters by department and address are documented, with no multi-entity, currency or language detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Role approvals, time off policies and multi-country support with a customizable portal are described, but mostly by marketing pages and with no custom fields or entity detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Gusto 5.0 to 2.9.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Gusto 3.9 to 3.0.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Gusto 4.3 to 3.2.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Gusto 3.8 to 2.9.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Gusto 4.8 to 2.9."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Gusto vs Sage",
   "a": "Gusto",
   "b": "Sage",
   "total_a": "4.1",
   "total_b": "2.2",
   "winner": "Gusto",
   "margin": "1.9",
   "build_a": 1,
   "build_b": 1,
   "build_reason_a": "Reports and AI suggestions with onboarding templates and employee tasks, but no natural-language builder, any-field triggers or conditions found.",
   "build_reason_b": "Reports and checklist templates with employee task lists, but no natural-language builder, triggers or conditions found and only one source.",
   "agents_a": 4,
   "agents_b": 1,
   "agents_reason_a": "MCP writes come back for confirmation and admins choose data categories, but there is no HR agent running processes, no audit statement and only partial off-switch controls.",
   "agents_reason_b": "No agent, approval model, audit log or AI off switch was found; only permission levels are mentioned.",
   "openness_a": 6,
   "openness_b": 2,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented MCP server for customers exists, but the public API and webhooks are restricted to partners and the developer MCP server is beta.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Only a Sage API was found, with no MCP server, no webhooks and no AI integrations.",
   "ttv_a": 7,
   "ttv_b": 4,
   "ttv_reason_a": "No setup fee, guided setup included and self-serve are documented across two sources, but no timeline or sandbox.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A 30-day free trial and modular self-serve setup are documented, with implementation through partners and no fee, timeline or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 9,
   "pricing_b": 7,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Base and per-person prices for three plans, priced add-ons and month-to-month terms with no plan minimum are published; in-product billing is not documented.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Per-employee module prices and priced add-ons are published for the US, but no minimum is stated, the enterprise product is by quote and in-product billing is not shown.",
   "fit_a": 3,
   "fit_b": 2,
   "fit_reason_a": "Custom fields through the API, time off approvals and report filters by department and address are documented, with no multi-entity, currency or language detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Leave policies and manager approvals are documented, but multi-entity and multi-country configuration are not shown as available.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Gusto 5.0 to 3.3.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Gusto 3.9 to 2.2.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Gusto 4.3 to 2.8.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Gusto 3.8 to 2.0.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Gusto 4.8 to 3.0."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Paylocity vs ADP",
   "a": "Paylocity",
   "b": "ADP",
   "total_a": "3.3",
   "total_b": "2.8",
   "winner": "Paylocity",
   "margin": "0.5",
   "build_a": 3,
   "build_b": 3,
   "build_reason_a": "Ready-made and custom workflow templates with filters, conditional routing, manager creation rights and progress dashboards are described on a marketing page, but no natural-language builder is documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Drag and drop report building with sharing and a prebuilt report library are described, plus guided workflows, but only on marketing pages and with no natural-language building or admin-editable triggers.",
   "agents_a": 4,
   "agents_b": 2,
   "agents_reason_a": "Purpose-built agents for onboarding, payroll and expenses with an enable choice and monitoring of actions are described on a marketing page, but no approval step, audit log or field-level control is stated.",
   "agents_reason_b": "A virtual assistant answers HR questions and role-based access exists, but no process agent, approval model, audit log or off switch is documented.",
   "openness_a": 3,
   "openness_b": 3,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented MCP server exists but only for API documentation, and webhooks and developer access are limited to early adopters, partners or custom-integration agreements.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Docs-type developer pages show HR, time and payroll APIs with OAuth 2.0, but API Central is a separate purchase, the MCP mention is marketing only, and no webhooks were found.",
   "ttv_a": 2,
   "ttv_b": 3,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A 4 to 16 week integration estimate and a sandbox for approved customers and partners are documented, but nothing on HR platform go-live, fee or guided implementation.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "An implementation team and Client Success Executive from day one are named, with no timeline, fee or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 2,
   "pricing_b": 2,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Contents are listed by module, but there are no prices, tiers or minimum, only a request for pricing through a demo.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Three package names with contents are published, but every tier is Get Pricing with no amounts, add-on prices or minimum.",
   "fit_a": 5,
   "fit_b": 4,
   "fit_reason_a": "Unlimited custom fields, location-based workflow filters and global payroll currencies are described, but only by marketing pages, with no entity or role detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Role approvals, time off policies and multi-country support with a customizable portal are described, but mostly by marketing pages and with no custom fields or entity detail.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Paylocity 3.1 to 2.9.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Paylocity 3.6 to 3.0.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Paylocity 3.7 to 3.2.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Paylocity 3.5 to 2.9.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Paylocity 3.2 to 2.9."
  },
  {
   "bout": "Paylocity vs Sage",
   "a": "Paylocity",
   "b": "Sage",
   "total_a": "3.3",
   "total_b": "2.2",
   "winner": "Paylocity",
   "margin": "1.1",
   "build_a": 3,
   "build_b": 1,
   "build_reason_a": "Ready-made and custom workflow templates with filters, conditional routing, manager creation rights and progress dashboards are described on a marketing page, but no natural-language builder is documented.",
   "build_reason_b": "Reports and checklist templates with employee task lists, but no natural-language builder, triggers or conditions found and only one source.",
   "agents_a": 4,
   "agents_b": 1,
   "agents_reason_a": "Purpose-built agents for onboarding, payroll and expenses with an enable choice and monitoring of actions are described on a marketing page, but no approval step, audit log or field-level control is stated.",
   "agents_reason_b": "No agent, approval model, audit log or AI off switch was found; only permission levels are mentioned.",
   "openness_a": 3,
   "openness_b": 2,
   "openness_reason_a": "A documented MCP server exists but only for API documentation, and webhooks and developer access are limited to early adopters, partners or custom-integration agreements.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Only a Sage API was found, with no MCP server, no webhooks and no AI integrations.",
   "ttv_a": 2,
   "ttv_b": 4,
   "ttv_reason_a": "A 4 to 16 week integration estimate and a sandbox for approved customers and partners are documented, but nothing on HR platform go-live, fee or guided implementation.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A 30-day free trial and modular self-serve setup are documented, with implementation through partners and no fee, timeline or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 2,
   "pricing_b": 7,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Contents are listed by module, but there are no prices, tiers or minimum, only a request for pricing through a demo.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Per-employee module prices and priced add-ons are published for the US, but no minimum is stated, the enterprise product is by quote and in-product billing is not shown.",
   "fit_a": 5,
   "fit_b": 2,
   "fit_reason_a": "Unlimited custom fields, location-based workflow filters and global payroll currencies are described, but only by marketing pages, with no entity or role detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Leave policies and manager approvals are documented, but multi-entity and multi-country configuration are not shown as available.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Sage 3.3 to 3.1.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "Paylocity 3.6 to 2.2.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "Paylocity 3.7 to 2.8.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "Paylocity 3.5 to 2.0.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Paylocity 3.2 to 3.0."
  },
  {
   "bout": "ADP vs Sage",
   "a": "ADP",
   "b": "Sage",
   "total_a": "2.8",
   "total_b": "2.2",
   "winner": "ADP",
   "margin": "0.6",
   "build_a": 3,
   "build_b": 1,
   "build_reason_a": "Drag and drop report building with sharing and a prebuilt report library are described, plus guided workflows, but only on marketing pages and with no natural-language building or admin-editable triggers.",
   "build_reason_b": "Reports and checklist templates with employee task lists, but no natural-language builder, triggers or conditions found and only one source.",
   "agents_a": 2,
   "agents_b": 1,
   "agents_reason_a": "A virtual assistant answers HR questions and role-based access exists, but no process agent, approval model, audit log or off switch is documented.",
   "agents_reason_b": "No agent, approval model, audit log or AI off switch was found; only permission levels are mentioned.",
   "openness_a": 3,
   "openness_b": 2,
   "openness_reason_a": "Docs-type developer pages show HR, time and payroll APIs with OAuth 2.0, but API Central is a separate purchase, the MCP mention is marketing only, and no webhooks were found.",
   "openness_reason_b": "Only a Sage API was found, with no MCP server, no webhooks and no AI integrations.",
   "ttv_a": 3,
   "ttv_b": 4,
   "ttv_reason_a": "An implementation team and Client Success Executive from day one are named, with no timeline, fee or sandbox.",
   "ttv_reason_b": "A 30-day free trial and modular self-serve setup are documented, with implementation through partners and no fee, timeline or sandbox.",
   "pricing_a": 2,
   "pricing_b": 7,
   "pricing_reason_a": "Three package names with contents are published, but every tier is Get Pricing with no amounts, add-on prices or minimum.",
   "pricing_reason_b": "Per-employee module prices and priced add-ons are published for the US, but no minimum is stated, the enterprise product is by quote and in-product billing is not shown.",
   "fit_a": 4,
   "fit_b": 2,
   "fit_reason_a": "Role approvals, time off policies and multi-country support with a customizable portal are described, but mostly by marketing pages and with no custom fields or entity detail.",
   "fit_reason_b": "Leave policies and manager approvals are documented, but multi-entity and multi-country configuration are not shown as available.",
   "verdict_first-hris": "Sage 3.3 to 2.9.",
   "verdict_second-hris": "ADP 3.0 to 2.2.",
   "verdict_multi-entity": "ADP 3.2 to 2.8.",
   "verdict_ai-native": "ADP 2.9 to 2.0.",
   "verdict_professional-services": "Sage 3.0 to 2.9."
  }
 ]
}