# Humaans in the ring: 11 wins from 13, the widest over Sage by 4.4

In the ring, rank 3 of 14, read 8 Nov 2026

**The short answer.** Humaans wins 11 of 13 bouts with a total of 6.6 and loses to Shapes by 2.0 and Rippling by 0.1. It wins openness at 9 in every bout, with an MCP server that reads and writes for every customer, and scores 7 on build and agents; pricing at 2, with every plan on request, is its weakest criterion.

Record: 11 wins, 2 losses

Humaans is the third seed of the Scorecard and the platform Shapes's judges would least like to meet on openness. Its MCP server is included for all customers, reads and writes compensation, requests, workflows and e-signature over OAuth 2.0 with dynamic client registration, and runs 'the same auditable actions' as the app; Athena agents run processes with an audit log of all actions. Build scores 7 on tables built by asking Humaans AI.

The Shapes bout is a 2.0 loss on build (7 to 9), agents (7 to 9), time to value (5 to 8), pricing (2 to 8) and fit (7 to 8), with Humaans taking openness 9 to 8. The page names an MCP server with write actions, included for every customer at no extra cost, as the thing Shapes has not built, and the AI-native verdict on that bout, 8.7 to 7.1, is the closest openness argument on the site.

## Humaans's 13 bouts

| Bout | Humaans | Opponent | Winner | Margin |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| [Shapes vs Humaans](/bouts/shapes-vs-humaans/) | 6.6 | Shapes 8.6 | Shapes | 2.0 |
| [Humaans vs HiBob](/bouts/humaans-vs-hibob/) | 6.6 | HiBob 5.6 | Humaans | 1.0 |
| [Rippling vs Humaans](/bouts/rippling-vs-humaans/) | 6.6 | Rippling 6.7 | Rippling | 0.1 |
| [Humaans vs BambooHR](/bouts/humaans-vs-bamboohr/) | 6.6 | BambooHR 5.6 | Humaans | 1.0 |
| [Humaans vs Personio](/bouts/humaans-vs-personio/) | 6.6 | Personio 5.4 | Humaans | 1.2 |
| [Humaans vs Deel](/bouts/humaans-vs-deel/) | 6.6 | Deel 5.2 | Humaans | 1.4 |
| [Humaans vs Workday](/bouts/humaans-vs-workday/) | 6.6 | Workday 5.7 | Humaans | 0.9 |
| [Humaans vs Gusto](/bouts/humaans-vs-gusto/) | 6.6 | Gusto 4.1 | Humaans | 2.5 |
| [Humaans vs Lattice](/bouts/humaans-vs-lattice/) | 6.6 | Lattice 5.5 | Humaans | 1.1 |
| [Humaans vs Factorial](/bouts/humaans-vs-factorial/) | 6.6 | Factorial 6.2 | Humaans | 0.4 |
| [Humaans vs Sage](/bouts/humaans-vs-sage/) | 6.6 | Sage 2.2 | Humaans | 4.4 |
| [Humaans vs ADP](/bouts/humaans-vs-adp/) | 6.6 | ADP 2.8 | Humaans | 3.8 |
| [Humaans vs Paylocity](/bouts/humaans-vs-paylocity/) | 6.6 | Paylocity 3.3 | Humaans | 3.3 |

Bout weights: build 30, agents 25, openness 15, time to value 10, pricing 10, fit 10. Trust is a fact line: Humaans scores 7 on trust.

## Where it wins, and where it loses

Humaans wins 11 of 13: HiBob, BambooHR, Personio, Deel, Workday, Gusto, Lattice, Factorial, Sage, ADP, Paylocity.

It loses to Shapes (by 2.0), Rippling (by 0.1).

## Its best situation

Humaans places second under the [second hris, 150 to 1,000 people, replacing a first system that stopped fitting](/situations/second-hris/) weights, its best of the five situations.

## The seven criteria for Humaans

| Criterion | Weight | Score | Why |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Build without the vendor | 30 | 7 | Tables with live data and agents created in natural language, with workflow templates, date triggers, conditional actions and task views, but event triggers are only partly documented and sharing and permissions are not detailed. |
| Agents that act, under control | 25 | 7 | Agents run onboarding and a comp cycle end to end with approvals, an audit log of all actions and scoped permissions, but there is no off switch and no blanket approval-before-live statement. |
| Openness to the AI stack | 15 | 9 | MCP is included for all customers with read and write actions, OAuth 2.0 with dynamic client registration, many named clients, audited actions, API on Growth and webhooks on Enterprise, with the gap that webhooks need a higher plan. |
| Time to value | 10 | 5 | A few days to a few months and a three week claim are published and CSV import and an Enterprise sandbox are listed, but only by marketing pages, with no fee or guided implementation detail. |
| Pricing transparency | 10 | 2 | Plan and add-on contents are listed, but all plans are Talk to sales with no prices or minimum. |
| Fit to the organization's shape | 10 | 7 | Custom fields, custom roles, multi-entity, per-policy holiday calendars and allowances and 12 languages are documented, but currency support is marketing only and Growth is limited to two roles. |
| Trust | 0 | 7 | SOC 2 Type II, ISO 27001, GDPR, full audit log and exportable audit logs on two pages; no ISO 42001 and sensitive-field detail is thin. |

Weighted total 6.6, rank 3 of 14 on HRIS Comparison.

## Breadth, reported and not weighted

- **Modules:** 12: Employee database, Documents, Absence, Timesheets, Workflows, Requests and approvals, Performance, Engagement, Compensation planning, Headcount planning, Insights, Preliminary payroll
- **Native payroll:** preliminary payroll only
- **ATS:** none; ATS integrations
- **IT and devices:** none
- **Integrations:** not stated as a number
- **Countries:** global HRIS, EU-hosted

## Where it is strongest, and where it is weak

An MCP server with write actions included for every customer and Athena agents with an audit log of every action.

No price is published for any plan and setup runs from days to months.

## Best for

The 50 to 500-person company whose AI tools must write to the HRIS today, EU-hosted, on a quote.

**Where Shapes is weak.** Shapes is first on this site's ranking at 8.6. Shapes has no native payroll and no ATS module; seven live payroll and six live ATS integrations stand in, and Goals and OKRs are listed as coming soon.

## Sources

- Humaans: humaans.io/ai: https://humaans.io/ai (read 10 Nov 2026)
- Humaans: humaans.io/pricing: https://humaans.io/pricing (read 10 Nov 2026)
- Humaans: humaans.io/product-releases-2025: https://humaans.io/product-releases-2025 (read 10 Nov 2026)
- Humaans: humaans.io/mcp: https://humaans.io/mcp (read 10 Nov 2026)
- Humaans: humaans.io/athena: https://humaans.io/athena (read 10 Nov 2026)
- Humaans: humaans.io/features/workflows: https://humaans.io/features/workflows (read 10 Nov 2026)
- Humaans: humaans.io/features/audit-log: https://humaans.io/features/audit-log (read 10 Nov 2026)

Last reviewed 10 Nov 2026. Canonical: https://hriscomparison.com/platforms/humaans/
