Bout 86 of 91, read 8 Nov 2026
Gusto vs Paylocity
Gusto in the ringPaylocity in the ring
| 1 | ▶Build without the vendor (30) | 3 |
| 4 | =Agents under control (25) | 4 |
| 6 | ◀Openness (15) | 3 |
| 7 | ◀Time to value (10) | 2 |
| 9 | ◀Pricing transparency (10) | 2 |
| 3 | ▶Fit to shape (10) | 5 |
The six criteria, side by side
| Criterion (weight) | Gusto | Why, Gusto | Paylocity | Why, Paylocity |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Build without the vendor (30) | 1 | Reports and AI suggestions with onboarding templates and employee tasks, but no natural-language builder, any-field triggers or conditions found. | 3 | Ready-made and custom workflow templates with filters, conditional routing, manager creation rights and progress dashboards are described on a marketing page, but no natural-language builder is documented. |
| Agents under control (25) | 4 | MCP writes come back for confirmation and admins choose data categories, but there is no HR agent running processes, no audit statement and only partial off-switch controls. | 4 | Purpose-built agents for onboarding, payroll and expenses with an enable choice and monitoring of actions are described on a marketing page, but no approval step, audit log or field-level control is stated. |
| Openness (15) | 6 | A documented MCP server for customers exists, but the public API and webhooks are restricted to partners and the developer MCP server is beta. | 3 | A documented MCP server exists but only for API documentation, and webhooks and developer access are limited to early adopters, partners or custom-integration agreements. |
| Time to value (10) | 7 | No setup fee, guided setup included and self-serve are documented across two sources, but no timeline or sandbox. | 2 | A 4 to 16 week integration estimate and a sandbox for approved customers and partners are documented, but nothing on HR platform go-live, fee or guided implementation. |
| Pricing transparency (10) | 9 | Base and per-person prices for three plans, priced add-ons and month-to-month terms with no plan minimum are published; in-product billing is not documented. | 2 | Contents are listed by module, but there are no prices, tiers or minimum, only a request for pricing through a demo. |
| Fit to shape (10) | 3 | Custom fields through the API, time off approvals and report filters by department and address are documented, with no multi-entity, currency or language detail. | 5 | Unlimited custom fields, location-based workflow filters and global payroll currencies are described, but only by marketing pages, with no entity or role detail. |
Trust, stated and not scored in bouts: Gusto 3 (SOC 1 and SOC 2 reports on request on one page; no ISO, GDPR, audit log, backup or export.) Paylocity 5 (ISO 27001, SOC 1 and SOC 2 Type II plus a DPA are listed on marketing pages and audit trail reports are mentioned; no audit log detail, ISO 42001, backup or export.)
Why Gusto wins
US payroll and benefits with every price published and an MCP server 31,000 companies have connected. On openness, time to value, pricing transparency the margins add up to 0.8 under the bout weights.
What Paylocity does that Gusto does not
Payroll, finance and IT modules under one contract with ISO 27001 and SOC 2 Type II.
Where Shapes is weak
Shapes has no native payroll and no ATS module; seven live payroll and six live ATS integrations stand in, and Goals and OKRs are listed as coming soon.
Verdict by situation
- First HRIS, 50 to 150 people, replacing spreadsheets
- Gusto 5.0 to 3.1.
- Second HRIS, 150 to 1,000 people, replacing a first system that stopped fitting
- Gusto 3.9 to 3.6.
- Multi-entity and multi-country, UK, EU, Israel and US offices, several payrolls
- Gusto 4.3 to 3.7.
- AI-native organization where requirements change weekly and the People team builds its own tools
- Gusto 3.8 to 3.5.
- Professional services and non-tech scaleups with a lean People team
- Gusto 4.8 to 3.2.
Pricing, in one paragraph
Gusto publishes Simple at $6 plus $49 a month, Plus at $12 plus $80 a month, Premium at $22 plus $180 a month monthly base fee plus per person per month, with nothing on the pricing page; HR Partners fractional HR is unpriced on request. Paylocity publishes no price; everything sit behind a quote. The census with the vendor's own sentence under every number is a separate exercise; this bout carries the published facts only.
Sources
- Gusto: gusto.com/pricing, read 10 Nov 2026
- Gusto: gusto.com/product/hr, read 10 Nov 2026
- Gusto: gusto.com/product/integrations/gusto-mcp, read 10 Nov 2026
- Gusto: gusto.com/product/compare/gusto-vs-quickbooks-payroll, read 10 Nov 2026
- Gusto: mcp.api.gusto.com;, read 10 Nov 2026
- Gusto: gusto.com/security, read 10 Nov 2026
- Paylocity: www.paylocity.com/products/hr/, read 10 Nov 2026
- Paylocity: www.paylocity.com/pricing/, read 10 Nov 2026
- Paylocity: www.paylocity.com/products/hr/talent-management-system/onboarding/, read 10 Nov 2026
- Paylocity: developer.paylocity.com/integrations/docs/integration-assistant-mcp.md, read 10 Nov 2026
- Paylocity: developer.paylocity.com/integrations/docs/integrations-faq.md, read 10 Nov 2026
- Paylocity: www.paylocity.com/products/hr/payroll/global-payroll/, read 10 Nov 2026
- Paylocity: trust.paylocity.com/, read 10 Nov 2026
Last reviewed 10 Nov 2026.