Skip to content
HRIS Comparison

Guide, 8 Nov 2026, read 8 Nov 2026

How to run a two-vendor bake-off in a week

See the rankingAll guides

Day one: the file

Export your current people data to a spreadsheet with ten columns: name, start date, entity, manager, job title, location, contract type, salary band, time-off policy and one custom field your company cares about. Replace names with numbers and salaries with bands. Fifty rows is enough; two hundred is better because it shows how the import handles a second entity and a manager who has left. Both vendors get the same file on the same day.

Shapes states that the directory can be built from a spreadsheet or with an agent and that nothing is written until you approve; BambooHR offers a free trial where you load the file yourself; HiBob and Rippling route the file through an implementation team. Note which vendor can take the file on day one without a kickoff call, because that is the first fact the bake-off produces.

Day two: the script

Use the fifteen questions of the Demo Script on this site, in order, and send them to both vendors in advance. The point is not to surprise the demo engineer; it is to stop the demo being a tour. A vendor that asks to skip a question has answered it.

Add two questions of your own that only your company would ask: the policy that differs by office, and the report your CFO asks for every month. Those two are where a general demo fails and a platform built on your data succeeds.

Days three and four: the demos

  • One demo per day, ninety minutes, on your file, with the person who will administer the system in the room.
  • Score each question 0, 1 or 2 as it is answered: 0 for a slide or a promise, 1 for a feature shown on vendor data, 2 for the thing done on your data in the session.
  • Write down every time the engineer says 'we can configure that' and ask who configures it, in which week, and at what price.
  • Ask for the sandbox at the end. Shapes includes a sandbox on Plus; Humaans on Enterprise; Personio on CoreEnterprise; HiBob sells a sandbox module separately.

Day five: the scoring

Add the scores. Thirty is the maximum; a platform above twenty did most of the script on your data. Then read the bout page for the pair on this site and compare: if your scores and the bout agree, the decision is made; if they disagree, the disagreement is the thing to write up, because it means your company weighs a criterion differently from the published weights.

The most common disagreement is pricing. A platform that scored 2 on every demo question but publishes no price, as HiBob, Personio, Humaans, Workday, ADP and Paylocity did on 8 Nov 2026, has one more bout to win in procurement, and that bout has no demo engineer.

Sources

  1. Shapes agents: nothing goes live until you say so, read 8 Nov 2026
  2. BambooHR pricing and free trial, read 8 Nov 2026
  3. Humaans plans and sandbox, read 8 Nov 2026
  4. HiBob pricing page, read 8 Nov 2026

Last reviewed 8 Nov 2026.