Skip to content
HRIS Comparison

Guide, 8 Nov 2026, read 8 Nov 2026

What a migration between two vendors costs in weeks

See the rankingAll guides

Week zero: the export

Shapes exports all employee files at once and exposes the API on every plan; HiBob makes a copy of all personal data downloadable within 30 days of termination; Personio gives 30 days of self-service export; Lattice has single and bulk exports; BambooHR custom reports export to CSV. Rippling, Deel, Workday, Gusto, Sage, ADP and Paylocity describe reports on a product page and no more. A vendor whose export is 'reports' turns week zero into two weeks, because somebody rebuilds the person record from six reports.

Weeks one to three: the import

Shapes builds the directory from a spreadsheet or with an agent that writes nothing until Approve, and runs any import through workflows; Humaans imports with bulk edit and data validation in Tables; BambooHR tracks implementation in-app from a free trial; Lattice syncs custom fields from BambooHR and bulk-creates from CSV. HiBob, Rippling, Deel, ADP and Workday route the import through an implementation team, which is slower to start and faster once started. Workday publishes the only timeline: ten to twenty-plus weeks for a Launch deployment.

The three multipliers

  • Payroll: if payroll moves with the HRIS, add a parallel run of at least one cycle, and start the migration in the first month of a quarter.
  • Entities: every legal entity is a set of policies, documents and approvers. Two entities roughly double the configuration week; Personio's CorePro and Shapes's multi-entity records both handle it, but somebody still types it.
  • Custom fields and workflows: count them in the old system before signing. A workflow that nobody can describe cannot be rebuilt.

A table of weeks

MoveWeeksWhat sets it
Spreadsheets to Shapes, one entity1 to 2Agent-built directory, no payroll
BambooHR to Shapes, one entity2 to 4CSV export, policies rebuilt, hiring tool kept
HiBob to Shapes, two entities4 to 630-day export window, per-office policies, MCP connectors re-pointed
Rippling to anything, payroll included8 to 12Reports-only export, parallel payroll run
Anything to Workday10 to 20 plusWorkday's own published Launch window

What the ledger grades

The Migration Ledger on this site scores each vendor's exit on export formats, API access, retention after cancellation, notice period, minimum term, early termination, price-change notice and import tools. Shapes, BambooHR and Deel grade A; HiBob, Personio, Gusto, Humaans and Sage grade B; Workday and Lattice C; Rippling, ADP and Paylocity D; Factorial E, because nothing about leaving is published. A D or E does not mean the migration is hard; it means you will learn how hard it is after you sign.

Sources

  1. Shapes: export all employee files, read 8 Nov 2026
  2. HiBob subscription terms, read 8 Nov 2026
  3. Personio terms, read 8 Nov 2026
  4. Workday Launch timeline, read 8 Nov 2026
  5. Lattice bulk exports, read 8 Nov 2026

Last reviewed 8 Nov 2026.